Comments 1,368

Re: PDP Unveils New Xbox Guitar Controller For Rock Band 4 And Fortnite Festival

PhileasFragg

Awesome to see these again, but I do worry how long Fortnite Festival will be around for as while it was SUPER popular when it first released the player count has dropped significantly since then.

Considering it needs an influx of new songs (they're adding a couple a week right now), and licencing costs for the music, and specific devs for that mode I do wonder if it'll stick around.

Re: Poll: How Many Physical Xbox Games Do You Have In Your Collection?

PhileasFragg

I have about 10 physical games I think. All ones I got very cheap second hand. I got out of console gaming after my PS3 died, and didn't get back in until the One S, and since then I've been digital first for sure (especially with Game Pass).

I've expressed my opinions on here before that the physical releases have been rendered useless as games are tied to their servers and updates so you don't really have the game on your shelf any more. You have all the disadvantages of physical (takes up space, can be lost, need to swap discs), but almost none of the advantages besides marginal resale value, and lending to a friend.

Re: Talking Point: Do You Think Xbox Will Release Another Disc-Based Console?

PhileasFragg

When there's a mid generation refresh they'll keep the disc for the highest end model, but I'm not as sure with whatever will come next.

The used and retail market is dwindling so there's not the pressure there there once was, and game discs are becoming pointless as you need to install the game to the hard drive and update from the internet to play anyway.

The only reason I'd want to get a version with drive is so I can play movies and CDs all on one device rather than buying separate devices for everything.

Re: Limited Run Gets Brutally Honest As Xbox Misses Out On Two New Ports

PhileasFragg

@ZYDIO So they haven't been taking away games. Just TV, music, and Movies?

That's a different matter as my point is games now are all tied into the platform and publisher's eco system so they'll shut down the game and update servers, and it doesn't matter if you have a disc version or not as it's all a digital passkey. I bought CoD WWII second hand the other week, and I still hade to download and install the 45Gb game to my hard drive despite the disc.

If they remove a game it wouldn't matter what medium you have. Unlike movies, TV, and Music which don't have all that, and so can be kept in physical form independent of an online requirement.

Re: Limited Run Gets Brutally Honest As Xbox Misses Out On Two New Ports

PhileasFragg

Honestly I don't really buy games physically any more. The only time I do is when they're 2nd hand and can thus get the disk cheaper than the digital version.

Games these days require online connections, updates, DLC, etc. so the disc doesn't really have the game like in the past. So really it just takes up shelf space, and turns it into a collectable shelf ornament.

Re: Talking Point: Do You Think Xbox Will Ever Stop Making Consoles?

PhileasFragg

I mean Atari and Sega are long gone as hardware developers despite being massive in the gaming space.

MS are more diversified than they were, but that can also mean they could cut their losses more easily if the hardware market didn't work out.

I'm in favour of more cross platform titles as when hardware manufacturers need to compete on price, features, and quality rather than just having the most popular software.

Re: Xbox Has Changed Game Pass Quests For 2024, And Fans Aren't Happy

PhileasFragg

Rewards is going to be gutted by the end of this year for sure. It's clear someone in Microsoft ran all the numbers and saw that it just was too expensive a system to run, and they need to slow down the points gain.

GPQ was a good way to get people to engage with different Game Pass games, but a requirement to do all this to get rewards is a barrier to all but the most dedicated, but still keep the points to save face. I think they'd get rid of it all together if they could.

Re: Poll: Three Years On, What Do You Think Of Quick Resume For Xbox Series X|S?

PhileasFragg

I think it's really good, but with more and more games having online centric features it can cause annoying issues that mean you have to restart the game. Also there's a couple games (Guardians of the Galaxy is one) that have had issues where quick resume makes the game gradually slow down.

I just think more developers need to take QR into account. Fortnite is the biggest game on the Xbox, and one of the biggest in the world, but still has these issues years later.

Re: Starfield Dev Calls Out 'Unreasonable' Criticism From Some People On Social Media

PhileasFragg

Besides some really bad scams and asset flips developers really do work hard, and put their talent and experience to the best use they can. that's something that should always be acknowledged and respected.

In the end though sometimes bad creative choices are made, and even if executed perfectly you need to accept the consequences of those actions.

Still this small sub culture of people picking on individual developers, etc. needs to stop, and treat people with respect and have some damn perspective. For gamers this is all a fun past time and distraction, but for developers this is their career and their livelihood (and that of their families) can be ruined by scapegoating.

Re: Sea Of Thieves Adds Private Servers In This Week's 'Safer Seas' Update

PhileasFragg

I think they've got a good compromise. It's designed for new players and for people who want to just chill out a bit.

The level cap means that high level players will get nothing worthwhile out of it. So when you're starting out learn now things work in Safer Seas before moving over to high seas.

The game has a very steep learning curve, even with the added starter island, and this should help out.