I heard Hellblade 2 was actually much better than the discourse suggests, shame it didn't sell that great. In any case, if anything happens, I hope they can go indie or spun off instead of outright closed.
Xbox has been horribly mismanaged since X1. It's frustrating to watch because they are sitting on so many great IP but refuse to use them. Make a new (exclusive) Banjo-Kazooie, make a new (exclusive) Conker, make a new (exclusive) Kameo, make a new (exclusive) Jet Force Gemini, make a new (exclusive) Starcraft. Come on!
@themightyant I mean that's all you can judge at this point. Actions. If they followed through on their words, we'd have better and more consistent output from them.
They'll show it when they're ready. I've been playing Deathloop and I'm kicking myself for not giving it more attention sooner. It's such an awesome game! This studio is really amazing.
Agreed on the IP area. Nintendo is amazing at this, compared to Sony and MS. Neither of the latter two are great about that on the macro level, but Sony is still better than MS.
Tbh, I don't see a problem with focusing on your platform for your showcases. It's immaterial to Xbox if a game is multiplat or not when I watch the Xbox showcase. All I care about is "Is this coming to Xbox?" (Or in the case of Nintendo, Switch/2, is it headed there). If I wanted news on if a game is coming to multiple platforms, I'd watch a generic showcase that's platform agnostic or just read about it on IGN or a similar channel.
Xbox exclusives as they existed during the Xbox 360 era are dead. I think we've all come to terms with that. However, they can pull back on PS5 and even NS2 and I don't think it would hurt the brand at all.
I kid you not when I say I was checking my Game Pass library this morning and thinking about how MS rarely updates it and won't anytime soon. What a hilarious coincidence.
Idk how this affects me since I own it, but I really need to play this game. It's a shame we'll never get another one because both entries are apparently great. You'd think a giant company like MS could take a few L's for their series' just to maintain a fanbase in the genre (like Nintendo does with some of its more niche franchises, such as Metroid) but I guess not!
@NeoRatt well other than ABK, I meant. That was a little obvious to let it go through everywhere they had to appease Governments (which in that case I'm fine with). But their earlier acquisitions should have come with exclusivity when practicable.
I'm over the acquisitions. Keep your teams accountable and make sure you actually communicate with them (i.e., manage them) because from the outside looking in, it doesn't seem like that's happening.
This is nice, but it feels like a whole lot of nothing. What incentive do people have to buy your console if your games are coming to other devices and PC? Yes, some people don't like gaming on PC. But when you have the same library on two devices, one of which people own, which do you think people will pick to buy the games on?
And would that incentivize buying a new device? No, it wouldn't.
Kind of makes you wonder what made them go multiplat, in the first place. Was it shareholders or Phil not being able to convince Satya to stay exclusive?
And you know what? I hope they go back to exclusivity!
I think everyone knows better than to take him at his word, by now. Still, I appreciate that he at least believes in what he's doing. Even if his work never lives up to his promises, it's still good overall. Besides, it's just video games, people.
I'd follow something similar to PS and Nintendo (the latter of which anyone else would never do because shareholders would riot), but really I'd start making most of the games exclusive to console. That may be harder since they are a PC software company first, contrary to Sony.
Tbh, I'd prefer they go back to straight up exclusive to console. Follow the rumored Sony model. Make multiplayer and live service PC games, then keep everything single player (the few that you do make) Xbox console exclusive.
With regulatory bodies paying attention and historical precedent, I'm aware what I'm about to say was never likely. Microsoft should have made COD Xbox exclusive and not put it on Game Pass.
This is far too common a practice and on Nintendo consoles, it's usually just third-parties. With MS, it's all of them. At least they are recognizing people don't like it.
The only way this console would have a chance is if MS pulls a (rumored) Sony and keeps single player games off PS hardware. Other than that, they shouldn't expect to sell this device to the mass market.
This thing won't be affordable and MS still has its work cut out for it. I don't see the value proposition of a console that plays PC games as well, but someone might.
I don't see why Sony would feel PS5/6 sales would be affected if the next Xbox can play first-party games via Steam because why would you choose to skip PS to play Xbox and PS games when you can do that with your PS6 and presumably play at least from PS4 to PS6 on one device? Wouldn't make any sense to change ecosystems now.
Genie's out of the bottle, they really won't be able to put it back in. Tbh, that isn't a good thing. Even partly unchecked Sony (which we have now) is a bad thing. They've required proprietary memory for their consoles in previous generations and would do that now if they could. Make no mistake, if they can remove Nintendo from the equation then you'll see that mask come off. Yes, Nintendo is a competitor of Sony's based on how they have recently been aggressively "lowering" PS5 prices to get headlines that they "won" in hardware sales for x month (yes, those headlines matter if you follow the industry closely enough).
Comments 1,697
Re: Report: Xbox Already Planned To 'Sunset Or Split With' Ninja Theory Before Senua Reveal
I heard Hellblade 2 was actually much better than the discourse suggests, shame it didn't sell that great. In any case, if anything happens, I hope they can go indie or spun off instead of outright closed.
Re: Xbox CSO Shuts Down Rumour About Exclusives, Insists They'll Happen Every Year
Xbox has been horribly mismanaged since X1. It's frustrating to watch because they are sitting on so many great IP but refuse to use them. Make a new (exclusive) Banjo-Kazooie, make a new (exclusive) Conker, make a new (exclusive) Kameo, make a new (exclusive) Jet Force Gemini, make a new (exclusive) Starcraft. Come on!
Re: Xbox CSO Shuts Down Rumour About Exclusives, Insists They'll Happen Every Year
@themightyant I mean that's all you can judge at this point. Actions. If they followed through on their words, we'd have better and more consistent output from them.
Re: Report: Multiple Xbox Studios In 'Active Negotiations' With Microsoft To Avoid Closure
@HonestHick Idk what you're talking about. Hellblade is a great game.
Re: Report: Multiple Xbox Studios In 'Active Negotiations' With Microsoft To Avoid Closure
Absolutely horrible. This should be a last resort for such a massive company.
Re: Rumour: Journalist Suggests Two Xbox Studios Are 'At Risk Of Being Closed' In 2026
Hey guys, we aren't putting out enough games. Let's close down a studio!
Arkane would be a huge loss. Deathloop is an incredible game!
Re: Microsoft Has Considered 'Spinning Out Or Restructuring' Xbox, Claims Report
My economics professor told my class about this years ago. Not surprised it's still on the table.
Re: Xbox's New Startup Animation Is Now Live For Everyone, Plus Four Other New Features
I noticed this when I booted up my XSX earlier today.
Re: The Coalition Reveals Campaign Length & Other New Details For Gears Of War: E-Day
Of the games shown, this was graphically one of the best.
Re: Xbox CEO Asha Sharma "Doesn't Believe" GenAI World Models Will Replace AAA Games
I agree with her.
Re: 'We'll Start To See Radically Different Business Models' - Xbox Boss Talks Future Of Consoles
Let's just ignore the fact that XBOX maker MS is a major reason that console prices are going up because of their push to go all in on AI.
Re: 'This Is The Start Of A Program' - Xbox Exec Addresses Questions Around Exclusivity
Just make some games exclusive and leave it at that. Sony did that and nobody is questioning them.
Re: 'It Doesn't End With Gears & Clockwork' - Xbox Reporter Teases More Console Exclusives
@MinervaX76 perhaps. I still see value in at least delaying PC because Helix is a hybrid. Sell the console half!
Re: 'It Doesn't End With Gears & Clockwork' - Xbox Reporter Teases More Console Exclusives
@Skinny-Pete that's MS' own doing. That's what I'm getting at.
Re: 'It Doesn't End With Gears & Clockwork' - Xbox Reporter Teases More Console Exclusives
Until MS stops putting PC games day and date with XBOX console, this means little.
Re: Xbox Fans Question Marvel's Blade Absence From XGS 2026
They'll show it when they're ready. I've been playing Deathloop and I'm kicking myself for not giving it more attention sooner. It's such an awesome game! This studio is really amazing.
Re: Matt Booty Explains Xbox's Plans For Exclusive Games Going Forward
Spyro is single player and that's coming to PS5 and Switch 2. Not that I'm complaining since I'm buying it on the latter. Lol
Re: Poll: How Would You Grade The Xbox Games Showcase 2026?
Good showcase, but it didn't really convince me that MS is changing course with Xbox.
Re: Five New 'Xbox Player Voice' Requests That Have Been Trending Over The Past Week
Agreed on the IP area. Nintendo is amazing at this, compared to Sony and MS. Neither of the latter two are great about that on the macro level, but Sony is still better than MS.
Re: Fallout 76 Is Getting A Free Xbox Series X|S Upgrade This Summer
Idk why I thought this was already a thing, but cool. This game is much better than how it launched.
Re: 'It Was A Miss, And I Own It' - Xbox CEO Hints At Removing PS5 & Switch Logos From Showcases
Tbh, I don't see a problem with focusing on your platform for your showcases. It's immaterial to Xbox if a game is multiplat or not when I watch the Xbox showcase. All I care about is "Is this coming to Xbox?" (Or in the case of Nintendo, Switch/2, is it headed there). If I wanted news on if a game is coming to multiple platforms, I'd watch a generic showcase that's platform agnostic or just read about it on IGN or a similar channel.
Re: Matt Booty Explains Why Xbox Won't Talk About Project Helix At June's Showcase
I wasn't really expecting to hear more about it until later this year, anyway. Seems like it will be very expensive so I'm on the fence about it.
Re: Xbox Delays Fable To February 2027, And It's Basically Because Of GTA 6
As others have said, this was very predictable.
Re: These Are The Top 25 'XBOX Player Voice' Requests After One Week
Xbox exclusives as they existed during the Xbox 360 era are dead. I think we've all come to terms with that. However, they can pull back on PS5 and even NS2 and I don't think it would hurt the brand at all.
Re: Xbox Ships Its First Mini-Feature In Response To Player Voice Feedback
Small change, but I prefer it.
Re: Xbox's New Chief Strategy Officer Is Planning To 'Revive Storied Franchises'
Banjo-Threeie and Blinx 3, let's go!
Re: Batman: Arkham Knight Joins Xbox Play Anywhere, And More Major Titles Could Be On The Way
Oh, cool. I still need to 100% this game to get the real ending.
Re: Xbox Adds Nine Titles To Game Pass Essential In New Surprise Update
I kid you not when I say I was checking my Game Pass library this morning and thinking about how MS rarely updates it and won't anytime soon. What a hilarious coincidence.
Re: Mina The Hollower Promises 'One Of The Greatest Top-Down Adventures Ever' On Xbox This Month
Based on the demo, I believe them because it was exceptional.
Re: Xbox Exec Invites Fans To Share Backwards Compatibility Requests On Special Website
The Cybertron Transformers games.
Re: 'The Results Ain't Pretty' - Oblivion Remastered Analysis Claims It's 'Still Broken' After One Year
Maybe when the Switch 2 version comes out, every other version will look and perform better.
Then Nintendo fans can wait a year+ for it to be serviceable!
Re: The Outer Worlds To Be Partially Delisted, Free 'Spacer's Choice Edition' For Those Affected
Idk how this affects me since I own it, but I really need to play this game. It's a shame we'll never get another one because both entries are apparently great. You'd think a giant company like MS could take a few L's for their series' just to maintain a fanbase in the genre (like Nintendo does with some of its more niche franchises, such as Metroid) but I guess not!
Re: 'I've Ordered A Series X, I'm Back In' - Lapsed Xbox Fan Attracts The Attention Of Asha Sharma
Tbh, I don't see what would make someone jump (back, or in the first place) in at this point.
Re: Reaction: Xbox Is Changing For The Better, And Now Microsoft Needs To Be Consistent
Literally 1 thing has happened since Asha took over. Nothing else.
Re: Xbox Is Officially 'Reevaluating' What To Do About Exclusivity
@NeoRatt well other than ABK, I meant. That was a little obvious to let it go through everywhere they had to appease Governments (which in that case I'm fine with). But their earlier acquisitions should have come with exclusivity when practicable.
Re: It's Been Years Since Xbox Acquired A Studio, But It Sounds Like They're Considering It Again
I'm over the acquisitions. Keep your teams accountable and make sure you actually communicate with them (i.e., manage them) because from the outside looking in, it doesn't seem like that's happening.
Re: Asha Sharma Says Xbox Is Investing To Make Series X|S Consoles A 'First-Class Experience Again'
This is nice, but it feels like a whole lot of nothing. What incentive do people have to buy your console if your games are coming to other devices and PC? Yes, some people don't like gaming on PC. But when you have the same library on two devices, one of which people own, which do you think people will pick to buy the games on?
And would that incentivize buying a new device? No, it wouldn't.
Re: Xbox Is Officially 'Reevaluating' What To Do About Exclusivity
Kind of makes you wonder what made them go multiplat, in the first place. Was it shareholders or Phil not being able to convince Satya to stay exclusive?
And you know what? I hope they go back to exclusivity!
Re: Fable Creator Says His New Game Is 'Most Significant Event' In His Entire 40-Year Career
I think everyone knows better than to take him at his word, by now. Still, I appreciate that he at least believes in what he's doing. Even if his work never lives up to his promises, it's still good overall. Besides, it's just video games, people.
Re: You're The Xbox Boss And Need To Figure Out Exclusivity, What Decision Are You Making?
I'd follow something similar to PS and Nintendo (the latter of which anyone else would never do because shareholders would riot), but really I'd start making most of the games exclusive to console. That may be harder since they are a PC software company first, contrary to Sony.
Re: Xbox Is Having 'Very Big Discussions' About Exclusivity, Says Reporter
Tbh, I'd prefer they go back to straight up exclusive to console. Follow the rumored Sony model. Make multiplayer and live service PC games, then keep everything single player (the few that you do make) Xbox console exclusive.
Re: Rumour: Microsoft Might Not Launch Call Of Duty 2026 On Xbox Game Pass
With regulatory bodies paying attention and historical precedent, I'm aware what I'm about to say was never likely. Microsoft should have made COD Xbox exclusive and not put it on Game Pass.
Re: Starfield Gets Major Free Update & New Expansion Next Month, Alongside PS5 Release
This is pretty big with the other changes made. Kind of makes me wish I hadn't beaten it a while back.
Re: Xbox Announces Policy Changes To Treat Games More 'Fairly' On The Microsoft Store
This is far too common a practice and on Nintendo consoles, it's usually just third-parties. With MS, it's all of them. At least they are recognizing people don't like it.
Re: Capcom Is Ready To Unleash Pragmata Early As Release Date Gets Brought Forward
This is really good news. Hope ppl with Xbox as their primary console enjoy this one! I will probably get Forza as my next Xbox game, tho.
Re: 'It Will Lead In Performance' - Xbox's Price Tag For Project Helix Could Be Pretty High
The only way this console would have a chance is if MS pulls a (rumored) Sony and keeps single player games off PS hardware. Other than that, they shouldn't expect to sell this device to the mass market.
Re: Xbox Announces New 'Project Helix' Console, Says It Will Play PC Games
This thing won't be affordable and MS still has its work cut out for it. I don't see the value proposition of a console that plays PC games as well, but someone might.
Re: Next Xbox Console Could Be Affected By PlayStation Pulling Back On PC
A rumor about a rumor. What a world we live in.
I don't see why Sony would feel PS5/6 sales would be affected if the next Xbox can play first-party games via Steam because why would you choose to skip PS to play Xbox and PS games when you can do that with your PS6 and presumably play at least from PS4 to PS6 on one device? Wouldn't make any sense to change ecosystems now.
Re: Opinion: Xbox Should Consider Cancelling Halo: Campaign Evolved For PS5
I think they should, but they won't.
Re: Xbox Boss Questioned On Whether Exclusives Could Return In The Future
Genie's out of the bottle, they really won't be able to put it back in. Tbh, that isn't a good thing. Even partly unchecked Sony (which we have now) is a bad thing. They've required proprietary memory for their consoles in previous generations and would do that now if they could. Make no mistake, if they can remove Nintendo from the equation then you'll see that mask come off. Yes, Nintendo is a competitor of Sony's based on how they have recently been aggressively "lowering" PS5 prices to get headlines that they "won" in hardware sales for x month (yes, those headlines matter if you follow the industry closely enough).