@Kaloudz If the games Sony ports to PC a year later don’t sell very well, why would they put those games on an Xbox and lose their console selling exclusives?
Live service games will come to Xbox but that’s it IMO.
I had a good four year ride with free GPU through rewards. They have no nerfed that into oblivion and made it impossible to pay for GPU with them. With them putting games on PS I think this could be the end for me. RIP Xbox, you were a good friend.
@WildConcept6 Here is what I had in mind. I’d like to at least partially future proof but open to suggestions if you have some. I’m not trying for something comparable to PS5, sorry for confusion.
I know this won’t be a popular take but the rewards program is the main reason I’ve had an Xbox. Using it to pay for GP each month kept me with them. Next gen, I don’t see why I’d pay $700+ for a console and then $20+ per month for GP. Will be cheaper to just buy specific games on PS.
I don’t understand how people are saying 2-3 hours. I play things quickly and have 3 hours and 16 minutes so far and am not done. I was expecting around 5 hours for $20 so I have no complaints so far. I also have enjoyed the puzzles. Feels like I’m playing a different game.
@somnambulance If you don’t like what Xbox has been putting onto GamePass which has been covering the spectrum of genre, such as Expedition 33, Gears Reloaded, Indiana Jones, Lost in Random, Avowed, Blue Prince, Doom and South of Midnight, what do you play?
@Fiendish-Beaver I think this will go over like a lead balloon if the new console requires this. Like you said, consoles are plug and play. I’d just build a PC if I wanted to tinker.
I’m very excited about potentially having Steam on my Xbox. My concern is, how will these games run? Right now we are getting games made for a console, if we theoretically bought from Steam, how is that going to work FPS and graphics wise?
I think what Xbox is doing confirms what he is saying. If they were crushing it with their own subscription service like they had hoped, they would not need to port games to PS/Switch. They had wanted 100M GP subs I think and they’re probably like 35M.
Now on the other hand, GP is awesome for me as I have played so many games I wouldn’t have bought. Great for the consumer, terrible for MS.
Just because of gamepass alone I have. I’ve played around 50 games this gen which has saved a ton of money. Console (X) I’ve had no issues with, love quick resume. Just wish the controller was better. Really prefer my PS5 controller.
@XboxNumberOne I didn’t know that about the Switch. Guess it makes sense why they always seem overpriced then.
I’m still skeptical Xbox will continue down the console road. Their marketing has shifted from it for sure. Developing blades for cloud servers seems far less money intensive than a console? Additionally, an article here today shows they’re crushing sales on PS. I dunno, hope I’m wrong but the suits just want to see more dollars and I don’t see how consoles do that for them.
@XboxNumberOne Nintendo and Sony always start selling at a loss each console gen. If Xbox tries to avoid that completely they may as well not even bother because they will be overpriced.
Interesting point about the cloud servers. How often does that kind of stuff get updated? Will they ditch the series X as servers and move to something else soon?
@Millionski I’m just looking at it from a money view. They don’t make money on console sales but could be the biggest publisher in the world making tons of money that way. If they could get GP on PS I think they’d drop console today.
@Kaloudz I appreciate the optimism but a company charging more for the X than a PS5 Pro is not seriously trying to sell consoles. The handheld is for sure happening. I know they said they’re working on a new console but we are years out and that IMO could be cancelled.
In terms of GP this year has been great. After a bummer of a year last year I gave tons to play and it’s been fun.
Xbox is now run by c-suite MS execs All they care about is the bottom line. The best bottom line for them does not include consoles as they have testified they have NEVER made money on them. Their best route for making money is subs on PC and handheld and 3rd party publisher.
EDIT: I think the fact the handheld is a partnership and not them making it also points to their exit.
@Kaloudz I’m a little confused on how they’ve ever been stronger? In terms of money making, yes. Their strategy of going multiplatform is going to be major damage to the brand for people. They’re losing people now and when they go day one on PS that could be the end of them as a console maker. Maybe I’m just not understanding you but I fully expect they will become a subscription/publisher entity in the near future.
@Ricky-Spanish It feels like a throwback to PS2 into 360 days. No bloat, just a fun linear game. I’m currently in Ch5 without any real complaints. I’m enjoying it more than I enjoyed Avowed for sure.
Comments 833
Re: Report: Xbox Has Been Asking Its Studios To Hit 'Higher Profit Margins' Since 2023
This is inspiring me to run away from Xbox. Fast, very fast.
Joking aside, physical games looks more appealing now so you’re not tied to any one ecosystem.
Re: Sarah Bond Says Fans Will Soon Be Able To Play PlayStation Studios Games On An Xbox Device
@Kaloudz If the games Sony ports to PC a year later don’t sell very well, why would they put those games on an Xbox and lose their console selling exclusives?
Live service games will come to Xbox but that’s it IMO.
Re: Xbox Game Pass Is Getting A Major Overhaul With New Names, Games & Price Changes
I had a good four year ride with free GPU through rewards. They have no nerfed that into oblivion and made it impossible to pay for GPU with them. With them putting games on PS I think this could be the end for me. RIP Xbox, you were a good friend.
Re: Microsoft Rewards Set To Remove 'Direct' Xbox Game Pass Redemptions From October 1st
@WildConcept6 Here is what I had in mind. I’d like to at least partially future proof but open to suggestions if you have some. I’m not trying for something comparable to PS5, sorry for confusion.
https://pcpartpicker.com/list/mcdWh7
Re: Microsoft Rewards Set To Remove 'Direct' Xbox Game Pass Redemptions From October 1st
@WildConcept6 If what I wanted to build wasn’t $1,450 I would keep my PS5 and have a PC.
I am however leery of dealing with drivers and such. Console is just so easy with plug and play.
Re: Microsoft Rewards Set To Remove 'Direct' Xbox Game Pass Redemptions From October 1st
Shocking, more nerfs to the program.
I know this won’t be a popular take but the rewards program is the main reason I’ve had an Xbox. Using it to pay for GP each month kept me with them. Next gen, I don’t see why I’d pay $700+ for a console and then $20+ per month for GP. Will be cheaper to just buy specific games on PS.
It was a good run though.
Re: Indiana Jones Order Of Giants DLC Launches To 'Mixed' Feedback In First 24 Hours
@Trmn8r Well that sucks. I have GamePass and bought the digital upgrade for $20 on cdkeys this week.
Re: Indiana Jones Order Of Giants DLC Launches To 'Mixed' Feedback In First 24 Hours
@Trmn8r You don’t? It’s $19.99 by itself.
I don’t understand how people are saying 2-3 hours. I play things quickly and have 3 hours and 16 minutes so far and am not done. I was expecting around 5 hours for $20 so I have no complaints so far. I also have enjoyed the puzzles. Feels like I’m playing a different game.
Re: Ex-PlayStation Exec Still Not Convinced By 'Dangerous' Xbox Game Pass Model
@Lup Unless you’re owned by MSFT of course.
Re: Xbox Will Apparently Announce More PS5 & Switch 2 Ports 'In The Coming Weeks'
@Balaam_ I really enjoyed that game. I’d play again on the Pro.
Re: Talking Point: As A Game Pass Subscriber, Do You Still Spend Money In Xbox Sales?
I haven’t bought a single game on Xbox this gen. Only use GP.
Re: Poll: Helldivers 2 Isn't On Xbox Game Pass, So Will You Be Buying It?
@SeaDaVie Thanks. I looked it up again and what I had seen was for a AA title. 😐
Looks like it’s around 40-50% of original budget.
Re: Poll: Helldivers 2 Isn't On Xbox Game Pass, So Will You Be Buying It?
@Questionable_Duck Millions of dollars??? Can you supply any proof of this? From what I’ve seen it costs them roughly six figures to port to PC.
Re: PS Plus Has 'Surpassed Expectations' Since Becoming More Like Xbox Game Pass
It’s not even remotely close to GamePass. Lol.
Re: Talking Point: Have This Month's Announcements Made You Excited About Xbox Again?
@somnambulance I follow. I misunderstood what you were meaning.
Re: Talking Point: Have This Month's Announcements Made You Excited About Xbox Again?
@somnambulance If you don’t like what Xbox has been putting onto GamePass which has been covering the spectrum of genre, such as Expedition 33, Gears Reloaded, Indiana Jones, Lost in Random, Avowed, Blue Prince, Doom and South of Midnight, what do you play?
Re: 'Blood Message' Looks Like Assassin's Creed Meets Tomb Raider, And It's Coming To Xbox
In the current time of copious amounts of souls and giant open worlds, I welcome any and all linear, story driven games.
Trailer genuinely looks good. Hope this turns out to be a hit.
Re: Report: Xbox Working On Massive Backwards Compatibility Overhaul Called 'Xbox Classics'
@InterceptorAlpha I was going to tag you but you’re too fast!
Re: Reaction: Xbox's Next-Gen News Is Exciting, But It Also Leaves More Questions Than Answers
@Fiendish-Beaver I think this will go over like a lead balloon if the new console requires this. Like you said, consoles are plug and play. I’d just build a PC if I wanted to tinker.
Re: Reaction: Xbox's Next-Gen News Is Exciting, But It Also Leaves More Questions Than Answers
I’m very excited about potentially having Steam on my Xbox. My concern is, how will these games run? Right now we are getting games made for a console, if we theoretically bought from Steam, how is that going to work FPS and graphics wise?
Re: Poll: When Do You Think Xbox's Next-Gen Console Is Coming Out?
@Grumblevolcano That is an interesting point! I hadn’t though about a new windows playing a role.
Re: Xbox Emphasises That Its Next-Gen Devices 'Aren't Locked To A Single Store'
@InterceptorAlpha Thanks for the extra info. So would you say she was lying since she said with your current library?
Re: Xbox Emphasises That Its Next-Gen Devices 'Aren't Locked To A Single Store'
@InterceptorAlpha I must be out of the loop because I’m not sure what you’re saying.
@VoidPunk Can you send me what you watched because it must be different.
Re: Xbox Emphasises That Its Next-Gen Devices 'Aren't Locked To A Single Store'
@InterceptorAlpha They said it would be BC today, did they not?
Re: Talking Point: Would You Like To See A New Type Of Forza Game In 2026?
Give me all of the Forza Horixon. Please and thank you.
Re: MindsEye Dev Shares 'Sincere Apology' With Xbox Hotfix Now In The Works
Why do you launch a game like this? An apology seems weak when they knew it was a technical mess.
Re: Reaction: Xbox Games Showcase 2025 Was Just OK, But Next Year Should Be Amazing
I’ll be honest I far from an optimist but I thought this was a good show. At least 10 games on GP I’ll be playing in the next 12ish months.
2025 GamePass: Gears Reloaded, CoD, Keeper, The Outer Worlds 2, High on Life 2, Ninja Gaiden 4.
2026 GamePass: Fable, Gears E-Day, FH6, Halo, Plague Tale and more.
Re: Reaction: Xbox Games Showcase 2025 Was Just OK, But Next Year Should Be Amazing
@Lucylu1983 What is GTA6?
Re: Last Chance! What Are Your Final Hopes For The Xbox Games Showcase 2025?
Fable gameplay
Guitar Hero reboot (pipe dream)
WoW on console (unlikely)
Forza Horizon 6
Banjo reboot (unlikely)
Re: Forza On PS5 Has 'Easily' Made $100 Million For Xbox, Says Analyst
@Ricky-Spanish Gotcha, an aesthetic thing. I believe they were marketing it as family friendly.
Re: Forza On PS5 Has 'Easily' Made $100 Million For Xbox, Says Analyst
@Ricky-Spanish Can I ask why you think this? Some of the levels are quite challenging, certainly not fit for kids.
Personally it was either my GOTY last year or runner up to IJ.
Re: Surprise! Black Myth: Wukong Finally Has A Release Date For Xbox
@Kaloudz I also thought it was supposed to be quite hard. Please report back if you play it. 😂
I’ve beaten Elden Ring (final boss about broke me) and Bloodborne so maybe there is hope I can play this.
Re: Xbox Is Giving Away Deathloop For Free, But Only The PC Version
It’s hard to describe how bad I thought this game was.
Re: 007 First Light Gameplay Looks Absolutely Epic, And It Comes To Xbox Next Year
This looks incredible. I don’t understand what you people were watching.
Re: Xbox Dominates PS5 Charts, Forza Horizon 5 'Most Downloaded' Game In May
@Millionski Highly encourage just stopping this discourse. You’re getting nowhere with him.
Re: Xbox Games Showcase 2025: Date, Start Times, Rumours, Leaks & More
@ButterySmooth30FPS I know this is a joke but I’m 100% on board with this
Any one seen the rumors of some Ubisoft games coming to GamePass?
Re: Xbox Quietly Releases New 4TB Expansion Card For Series X|S
@Titntin multiple Pros??? Hardcore.
Re: Our Predictions For The 2025 Xbox Games Showcase
Surely we see Fable gameplay and potentially a release date???
Re: Xbox Building A Handheld 'Makes No Sense', Says Former Blizzard Boss
Do they have any idea what they want to do at this point?
Re: Sony Has Approached Subscriptions 'Healthier' Than Xbox, Says Former PlayStation Boss
I think what Xbox is doing confirms what he is saying. If they were crushing it with their own subscription service like they had hoped, they would not need to port games to PS/Switch. They had wanted 100M GP subs I think and they’re probably like 35M.
Now on the other hand, GP is awesome for me as I have played so many games I wouldn’t have bought. Great for the consumer, terrible for MS.
Re: Talking Point: What Game Franchises Would You Pay $80 For On Xbox?
Halo, Diablo, Final Fantasy, Uncharted and GoW probably.
Re: Talking Point: Do You Feel You've Had Value For Money With Your Xbox Series X|S?
Just because of gamepass alone I have. I’ve played around 50 games this gen which has saved a ton of money. Console (X) I’ve had no issues with, love quick resume. Just wish the controller was better. Really prefer my PS5 controller.
Re: Opinion: If Xbox Is 'Just' A Game Pass Machine, That's Still Enough For Me
@XboxNumberOne Fake drama? I’m just giving my perspective.
Re: Opinion: If Xbox Is 'Just' A Game Pass Machine, That's Still Enough For Me
@XboxNumberOne I didn’t know that about the Switch. Guess it makes sense why they always seem overpriced then.
I’m still skeptical Xbox will continue down the console road. Their marketing has shifted from it for sure. Developing blades for cloud servers seems far less money intensive than a console? Additionally, an article here today shows they’re crushing sales on PS. I dunno, hope I’m wrong but the suits just want to see more dollars and I don’t see how consoles do that for them.
Re: Opinion: If Xbox Is 'Just' A Game Pass Machine, That's Still Enough For Me
@XboxNumberOne Nintendo and Sony always start selling at a loss each console gen. If Xbox tries to avoid that completely they may as well not even bother because they will be overpriced.
Interesting point about the cloud servers. How often does that kind of stuff get updated? Will they ditch the series X as servers and move to something else soon?
Re: Opinion: If Xbox Is 'Just' A Game Pass Machine, That's Still Enough For Me
@Millionski I’m just looking at it from a money view. They don’t make money on console sales but could be the biggest publisher in the world making tons of money that way. If they could get GP on PS I think they’d drop console today.
Re: Opinion: If Xbox Is 'Just' A Game Pass Machine, That's Still Enough For Me
@Kaloudz That special X is just speckled with same storage as the Pro. A terrible deal in comparison.
I hope you’re right about them not exiting because I’ve gotten some insane value from GP. I just don’t think where it appears things are going.
Re: Opinion: If Xbox Is 'Just' A Game Pass Machine, That's Still Enough For Me
@Kaloudz I appreciate the optimism but a company charging more for the X than a PS5 Pro is not seriously trying to sell consoles. The handheld is for sure happening. I know they said they’re working on a new console but we are years out and that IMO could be cancelled.
In terms of GP this year has been great. After a bummer of a year last year I gave tons to play and it’s been fun.
Xbox is now run by c-suite MS execs All they care about is the bottom line. The best bottom line for them does not include consoles as they have testified they have NEVER made money on them. Their best route for making money is subs on PC and handheld and 3rd party publisher.
EDIT: I think the fact the handheld is a partnership and not them making it also points to their exit.
Re: Opinion: If Xbox Is 'Just' A Game Pass Machine, That's Still Enough For Me
@Kaloudz I’m a little confused on how they’ve ever been stronger? In terms of money making, yes. Their strategy of going multiplatform is going to be major damage to the brand for people. They’re losing people now and when they go day one on PS that could be the end of them as a console maker. Maybe I’m just not understanding you but I fully expect they will become a subscription/publisher entity in the near future.
Re: Phil Spencer Discusses Why Xbox Game Pass Isn't For Everyone These Days
@Ricky-Spanish It feels like a throwback to PS2 into 360 days. No bloat, just a fun linear game. I’m currently in Ch5 without any real complaints. I’m enjoying it more than I enjoyed Avowed for sure.