Comments 1,298

Re: Xbox's 'Pivot Away From Console' Had Been Failing And Questioned At Microsoft, Claims Report

carlos82

I think without the direction Phil went, Xbox may not even be around now.

Realistically, what else could they have done? Xbox One lagged hugely behind PS4 due to decisions of the previous regime and Xbox's lack of first party unfortunately coincided with Playstation's purple patch on PS4.

Coming into this generation and people already having digital libraries elsewhere, Xbox were in no mans land and nobody would bankroll many billions of acquisitions just to sell those games on a console selling 30 to 40 million.

At this point I don't see how it would be possible to make games exclusive again, especially in the current hardware market

Re: Xbox Series X|S Ranked 5th In List Of Platforms Developers Are Most Interested In

carlos82

@Fiendish-Beaver I still expect to see this next Xbox because I don't feel they were ever likely to make it in big numbers anyway. Xbox Series seems to be the end of the line for true Xbox consoles with future hardware and games simply being PC versions. With Microsoft seeing their future as a publisher, with Gamepass in the cloud as much as (if not more so) PC

Re: Xbox's New Dashboard Is Going Down Well, And Some People Want It On Console & PC

carlos82

I'm not fan of the PC Xbox App but I dont think this is an improvement and it always makes me laugh how they manage to show so few games on the panel on the left, and what's with the play with friends nonsense taking up so much space?

The Xbox Series dashboard of a couple of years ago was the best, when I could organise my games how I wished its before they ruined it somewhat by removing customisation
Untitled

Re: Talking Point: Three Years Later, What Do You Think Of The GoldenEye 007 Port For Xbox?

carlos82

"the port is a good one" In what world is that true? It's garbage, not the game itself but the Xbox port is awful with a laundry list of issues from enemies getting stuck in geometry to sound issues and the fact that you can't even move at full speed with the default control scheme. It is easily the worst way to experience Goldeneye, which is a shame as the leaked cancelled port is great

Re: Playground Games Explains Fable's Open World & How It Compares To The Forza Horizon Series

carlos82

@FraserG this is exactly how I've felt about open world games for a long time. I'd much rather have a smaller world that is fully interactive, than a huge one like AC Valhalla where nothing feels remotely important.

Games like Yakuza and Shenmue were great at this and Skyrim was such a hit as even with its big world (for the time), the cities felt alive and there was adventure to be found everywhere.

So this coupled with that noc system they have and your actions being reflected by everyone, makes this a must play for me

Re: Is It Worth Buying An Xbox One In 2026?

carlos82

Perhaps the One X if you can get it cheap enough as its really good for the select back compat games. But I wouldn't go anywhere near the standard Xbox One, which regularly had poor looking versions of games, which ironically became the Series S's biggest weakness, not being able to run One X versions

Re: Five Reasons Why 2026 Is One Of The Most Important Years In Xbox History

carlos82

@Fiendish-Beaver I'm certain they'll make new hardware but it won't be a console, in the sense that it'll essentially be a PC in a box and new games running on it will simply be the PC versions and they'll have some form of backwards compatibility layer.

I've really enjoyed playing on Xbox consoles over the years but sadly those days have gone, as console gaming isn't what it used to be in general. I'll still be playing "Xbox" games as Microsoft have bought a few of my favourite IP and developers but this will be on PC

Re: Digital Foundry Impressed By Halo: Campaign Evolved, But Worried About Unreal Engine 5

carlos82

I'm so tired of UE5, I get that it's probably cheaper and easier for developers, though almost none of them seem to master it and it does have some great features. It sadly also has many issues, image quality is generally rubbish with it's poor upscaler, lumen reflections always look dreadful, even on PC, traversal stutter and insane CPU usage is common.

Of all the great games I've played this generation, the worst performing are almost always UE5

Re: Poll: Are You More Interested In The ROG Xbox Ally Now That Reviews Are Out?

carlos82

No because all the reviews did was confirm what we all knew.

This is a great PC handheld and it's not an Xbox console, so doesn't play the vast majority of my library.

Had the cheaper variant effectively been a handheld Series S, I'd have bought one. As they are, the more expensive one is the only viable product and a bit pricey for the use I'd get out of it