Comments 1,270

Re: Xbox Series S Compared To Switch 2 In Hogwarts Legacy Analysis, And The Results Are Surprising

carlos82

What's surprising about the more powerful console with a significantly higher power draw running games better? It's a handheld console that can also be used on the TV and let's be honest, the overwhelming majority (myself included) aren't buying it to play the standard AAA games that are everywhere. We're buying it for Nintendo's games.

I also wouldn't call the Series S good value, in fact I'd say it's terrible value in today's market. The 1tb option is almost the same price as a digital PS5 (actually currently more expensive due to an offer on PS5) and not that far behind the digital X

Re: Talking Point: What's Your Xbox Game Of The Year For 2025 So Far?

carlos82

On that list there's only Doom The Dark Ages I've really put any time into, so it wins by default but I'd also say its a very good game and in my top 3 overall so far this year, just behind Mario Kart World and with Death Stranding 2 at the top. In terms of the modern Doom games, I prefer it to Eternal but Doom 2016 is still the best of them.

Just a bit of a shame Oblivion has such performance issues as I really want to continue playing that as well

Re: Here's Your First Look At Steam Games On The Xbox PC App

carlos82

This is great for those handhelds but I don't see myself using it on my PC as the Steam UI is significantly better than the Xbox app, plus 99.9% of my library is there. Not only that but you've been able to add non Steam games to your library there for as long as I can remember, so I already have a consolidated library

Re: No, The ROG Xbox Ally Handheld Doesn't Play Native Console Games

carlos82

@FraserG for newer games it makes no real difference it being a PC over a console but for me personally, if it had been a true Xbox handheld that could play 360 and og Xbox games I'd be very tempted, as a PC I just don't care as I wouldn't ever use it over my actual PC.

@deadmaker exactly, out of around 120 or so digital games that I own on Xbox, 13 show up on PC as play anywhere, with even games from studios Xbox have bought still not available to me

Re: Review: Xbox Retro Classics - A Great Addition To Game Pass, With Just One Caveat

carlos82

It's not even just a good Internet connection but your location. My Internet is great but this is basically unplayable for me, as is Xcloud in general but when Stadia was around, that worked fine.

I don't see why these simply can't be downloaded as I'd guess that even in their best state, it'd still have noticable lag for the Atari games specifically

EDIT: I tried it again today and it worked much better, still noticable lag but not unplayable and I even managed to survive for 120 seconds on River Raid without dying

Re: Talking Point: How Do You Feel About Linear Vs. Open World Games On Xbox?

carlos82

I don't have a preference, other than to say if a game is open world, then the world has to do something to justify it other than simply being a large area to scatter icons to check off.

GTA and RDR need no introduction for how they use their open worlds and then you have Dsath Stranding which made the world itself an obstacle to be overcome

Re: Xbox Is Raising The Price Of Consoles, Games And Accessories

carlos82

@RBRTMNZ definitely based upon what? Trump has raised tariffs astronomically for parts from China and Nintendo moved some production to Vietnam to avoid those but manufacturing costs are higher there.

The case manufacturer Hyte, literally cannot afford to sell their own product in the USA anymore

Re: Hands On: Oblivion Remastered Is Impressive, But There Are Some Performance Issues At Launch

carlos82

I've been playing this on PS5 Pro and one thing it sounds like it has in common with Xbox is the quality mode looks awful in motion, the performance mode is nice and smooth so far. I'd also suggest turning off the screen space reflections as whilst they can look nice, they're hugely distracting as they pop in and out of existence.

Other than that it doesn't look really nice and the combat feels much better at even this early stage

Re: Indiana Jones PS5 Fans Not Happy With Xbox's Physical Media Habits

carlos82

@Deshalu absolutely we need all 3 to be competitive, my only issue with Xbox is that whilst I accept they (and others do of course) want physical to be the minority of sales, I wish they'd at least put the entire game on disc or use multiple discs, even charge a premium for them if necessary but make physical copies actually that.

Re: Indiana Jones PS5 Fans Not Happy With Xbox's Physical Media Habits

carlos82

@Deshalu In the interest of fairness I did try it with quite a few Nintendo games and yes Tears of The Kingdom wouldn't play without an update first, nor would Odyssey but BOTW did, though the copy I currently have seems to be a later print of the current version number. Everything else run straight off the cartridge with no fuss and I'm certain the above games did as well back when they came out, but it seems they've flagged certain games to be on a specific update in the latest firmware revisions, perhaps to combat piracy.

EDIT: Looking on reddit, it could simply be that the Switch remembers the version of certain games you've played and won't let you revert to an earlier one and I'm not going to reformat it and delete my saves to find out

Re: Indiana Jones PS5 Fans Not Happy With Xbox's Physical Media Habits

carlos82

@Deshalu I'm pretty sure all of Sony's own (offline and single player) games have a complete playable version on disc and Nintendo certainly have all of theirs playable from a cartridge without any installation needed.

Xbox are the outliers here in terms of platform holders and either don't even bother with a physical version or have little data on the disc supplied

Re: Talking Point: Could Sony 'Block' PlayStation Games On An Xbox Handheld?

carlos82

This "Xbox" handheld is just a handheld PC with an Xbox sticker on anyway, so I doubt Sony will care too much, especially when they only port their bigger games to PC after they've exhausted the bulk of their sales on their own console anyway. And let's be honest, this thing won't be selling in big enough numbers for Sony to take notice either

Re: Xbox Login Raises Concerns About Preservation Of Forza Horizon 5 On PlayStation

carlos82

My thoughts are always the same, no single player games should ever require an online connection or account login. For Sea of Thieves it makes sense as that's an always online game and at least you got the benefit of your progression following you.

For this though it should not be necessary and you can't even share your progress over to Playstation. Then again Playstation's own GT7 is completely unplayable offline for no good reason, so it's not like they're any better