Comments 435

Re: Xbox Wins FTC Court Case As Judge Denies Preliminary Injunction

Moby

@S1ayeR74 The EU agency approved the deal. The CMA is the UK agency that is currently under appeal. The CMA was ridiculously biased during the first review that no one is surprised they have done nothing to Sony. They all but threw a tantrum over fears MS could make CoD an exclusive, even though Sony was busted admitting it wasn't really anticompetitive.

Re: Xbox Wins FTC Court Case As Judge Denies Preliminary Injunction

Moby

I've said from the beginning this was all grandstanding. The fact the CMA is now "willing" to pause litigation is a signal they would rather negotiate concessions vs having MS win on appeal with zero concessions.

It's "curious" to also see the FTC do nothing about Sony's anticompetitive behavior brought to light during the hearing....

Re: Sarah Bond: Xbox Game Pass Ultimate's Least Popular Feature Is Cloud Gaming

Moby

Am I the only one not surprised? Of course it's not profitable yet. Stadia was sort of the first foray ino cloud and MS has been trying to pick up where stadia left off. If they stick with it, they could easily grab a huge share of the future market. The Xbox streaming app isn't even readily available everywhere yet.

MS is playing down cloud to show they are not a threat now, but they are definitely in a good position. Especially, since butt-hurt Sony got busted admitting it was never really about CoD. Lol

Re: Xbox's Redfall Plan 'Right Now' Is To Keep The Studio Open & Working On Updates

Moby

I'm with a few of the commenters here, the fallout over this game seems exaggerated. The game did have bugs but nothing game busting. The graphics were a disappointment for sure, but overall it was fun. I played thru it and even started over for a bit before finding something new and shiny to move onto. Granted, had I purchased vs playing on GP I might have been a tad more disappointed but I've played worse games for sure.

To me the focus on multiplayer and always online mode for single player was the most annoying aspects.

Re: Ubisoft's New Prince Of Persia Game Is Getting Blasted On YouTube

Moby

Is it maybe just music for the trailer and not the game? One can hope because the music doesn't really fit the game and it's jarring.

Am I the only one that feels like a lot of big devs are phoning it in on graphics? This game looks like an XOne release title TBH. If it comes to GP I'd try it, but the music does put me off.

Re: Xbox's Redfall Drops Out Of US Top Played Charts Less Than A Month After Launch

Moby

I honestly think this game was in the pipeline for the end of the XOne and due to COVID they were hella behind so kind of rushed it out. Had this released on XOne I think we'd all be giving it more credit.

My hunch is they needed to get it out so rather than start over they just pushed it out. I haven't attempted to play the co-op and honestly don't see a reason to try. I can definitely see why it's not staying in the top 10, but is playable.

Re: Redfall Dev Reveals Sadness Over 'Mean Spirited' Feedback From Peers

Moby

It feels like a last gen console release. I guess I'm not up in arms because it's on GP and I'm not out any money. I think the price increase on a game churned out quickly is the real complaint. It was sold as a triple-A title and it's clearly not. People feel cheated.

@Darylb88 the game is not fundamentally broken. Seriously, did you even play it? It's buggy for sure but nowhere near as many bugs as No Man's Sky or Cyberpunk when they were released. And that's jus two recent games. NMS was virtually unplayable due to several game breaking bugs.

Re: Microsoft Reckons It 'Lost The Worst Generation To Lose' With Xbox One

Moby

The XOne was an example of pure greed. People seem to forget Sony was planning much the same path. They did an about face a few months before their release and caught MS completely off guard. It was a savvy switch and Sony gobbled up market share.

It's ironic to see the rules somewhat reversed now. MS is maneuvering to leap frog over Sony if they don't get it together. GP is still better than Sony's terrible and very frustrating "tiered" system (and cheaper). Xcloud/streaming access is paving the way for multiple 3rd party mobile consoles without spending a dime of MS revenue. Sony's "remote play" is practically unusable. MS only needs to bring in a few more powerhouse games and they will truly eat up market share. (Clearly the Activision acquisition was part of that goal)

MS is definitely playing the long game. If they can keep it up, they'll surpass Sony in the next generation.

Re: This Week's Xbox Charts Show The Power Of Backwards Compatibility

Moby

Seems like a nice hand off from the recent and current sales of 360 titles. I don't really play many old 360 games but even I was tempted with some of the sale prices

And now that people are pretty confident the merger is going to happen I'm sure many might want to catch up on the old games before the newest comes to GP.

Re: No Man's Sky Brings Its Fractal Update To Xbox Game Pass

Moby

We've become so accustomed to being milked dry on games that we see faults with a developer trying to continuously deliver a better game with ever improving content. HG has come along way on this game. It went from literally busted to a widely played game with a ridiculous amount of free content.

Maybe knowing how bad they bombed the first time and being a small dev, they are focused on making it bigger and better for a smaller profit margin. I'd say they have the right approach. I certainly hope they don't get bought out and turned into another MTX game factory.

Would anyone have faulted them for charging even a small fee for the most recent expedition after so much free content?

Re: Microsoft Reveals Xbox 360 Marketplace Will Close In The Near Future

Moby

@shoeses some games will still be available via the regular store. You can always redownload games you own. If you have not purchased a 360 game by now, that's on you. It isn't reasonable to think MS would host a separate store front for old console games forever, regardless of compatibility. Nowhere did I read it was shutting down complete access to backwards compatible games, just the storefront for new sales.

Re: Xbox Surpasses 120M Monthly Active Users, As Game Pass Reaches 'New Highs'

Moby

MS is playing the long game. After the terrible XOne release and new leadership, they are making the right moves to rebrand and build back a lost customer base.

GP is doing so well even Sony had to upgrade their own meager offering, even though it still sucks. The tier system is a total joke. Xcloud makes GP an even better deal with play anywhere for a large % of GP games. Sony's remote play is terrible. Oh yeah, and and unlike Sony, MS doesn't pay developers to not develop games for Sony.

Frankly I don't want MS to pull into 1st place. By always being slightly behind it encourages them to keep focus on making gamers happy instead of shareholders.

Re: Reaction: Xbox Needs A New, Reliable Competitor For PS5's 'DualSense Edge'

Moby

I had the peeling rubber issue with the 1st Elite. The 2nd one has held up quite nice. I like the heft and feel of the Elite over conventional, but I don't use the paddles. Picked up a custom Elite 2 for Xmas. The battery life is definitely a plus. Really missing the share button though.

My current PS5 controller is already drifting and I don't play much on PS, so that is a disappointment. It is nice to see Sony finally update the shape of their controllers, but 'm not upgrading to the Edge due to the ridiculous price.

Re: 'The Callisto Protocol' Sales Expectations Lowered By Analysts

Moby

I wanted to like this game. I too walked away towards the end. The terrible combat mechanics really ruined it. The story was a bit weak but
still detailed enough to give you an outline. One would expect a deeper dive into the story in the 2nd game should it happen. My hunch is this was the plan.

Sadly, the game really failed to deliver on the hype.

Re: Talking Point: Is It Time For Xbox To Sunset The 'Games With Gold' Program?

Moby

If you buy gold for the year and GP monthly, it works out to the same price as paying for UGP monthly for the same year anyway.

Gold offerings have been pretty lame for a long time. It's one of the areas where MS truly fails to even compete with Sony, much less excel. Either beef it up or ditch it and reduce the price for "online access".

Re: How Would You Grade The Xbox Series X|S Generation So Far?

Moby

All things considered, B+. It's been a long hard road with near constant chip shortages, suppliers closed or shutdown, and oh yeah COVID. (It's like people don't even remember the whole world being affected.) I'm eager to see what they have up their sleeve for 2023.