Comments 506

Re: Talking Point: When Did You First Get Introduced To The World Of Xbox?

dskatter

Visited a friend who had the OG XBox back in the day and he showed me a few games. I wasn’t overwhelmingly impressed, and happily continued being a PS and Nintendo guy.

April of last year, I decided to get a series X and check out the Halo series and a few others, along with some BC improved games. Probably would have sold the console after that, but I discovered Forza Horizon 4 and 5, and that got me to stay.

Of course, now that 5 (and likely 6) are coming to PS…well, I’ll still keep my series X. I picked up a decent library of games for it, though my PS consoles will always have pride of place!

Re: EA Seems To Think That Live Service Would Have Helped Xbox RPG Dragon Age: The Veilguard

dskatter

Yes, Veilguard failed because of the lack of live service. It wasn’t the bugs, the bad writing, the virtue signaling, the dialog options bearing no resemblance to what your character actually says, or anything like that.

Nope. It was that darn missing live service. Never mind that EA’s football/soccer game was also a failure, and that was its usual connected and looty self.

Re: Soapbox: As A Huge Forza Fan, I'm Fine With Horizon 5 Going To PS5

dskatter

@IOI Every platform becomes unsupported eventually. If MS stopped making new consoles tomorrow, how does that devalue your current game library? Plus, digital purchases are just indefinite rentals anyway, they aren’t forever.

Besides, Sony doesn’t make PS3 or Vita consoles anymore, yet I can still download my purchased games for them, even though they’re indefinite rentals for essentially dead platforms.

Also, that’s awesome about cross play, thanks for that info! Cross-save would be AMAZING.

Re: Soapbox: As A Huge Forza Fan, I'm Fine With Horizon 5 Going To PS5

dskatter

I bought my first Xbox, a series X last year so I could play some of the exclusives I’d missed out on in the past. Halo, Gears of War, etc, then I’d sell the console, satisfied I’d tried them out.

I’m not a driving game fan. At all. So out of curiosity I fired up Horizon 4 on gamepass expecting to play for ten minutes and then delete.

Nearly a year later, I have bought Forza Horizon 2 and 3 on disc, and the ultimate editions of 4 and 5 digitally with no plans to sell the series X.

That said? I will also get Horizon 5 on PS5, possibly even the ultimate edition, and it will also be my preferred platform for Horizon 6 whenever that comes out. I HOPE for day one on there, but I’ll happily play it on gamepass or just buy it outright on X as well as PS5 if it isn’t. Hell, I might buy it for both platforms anyway, just because I’ve enjoyed the series so much. Put your money where your mouth is, right?

Maybe MS will implement cross-play for the Horizon series future releases so XBox and PS5 owners can enjoy the playground together!

Re: EA Says Two Of Its Major AAA Titles 'Underperformed' In 2024

dskatter

1.5 million engaged could mean a lot of things.

It could mean total sales, but that’s really doubtful. It could mean sales-before-refunding for folks who got it on Steam, tried it and hated it and got their money back. It could include people who played it via GeForce Now for free.

Words matter. If this was actual games sold where they got some appreciable money back, they’d actually say SOLD, not engaged.

Re: PS5 Pro Surprisingly Loses To Xbox Series X In HDMI Bandwidth Test

dskatter

@bazchillin “While PlayStation made cuts like removing CD playback and lacking UHD Blu-ray support on the PS4 and PS5”

Erm. You do know the PS5 is a fully functional 4k bluray player, right? Every PS5 with a disc drive is a 4k bluray player. That said, I invested in a separate 4k player to spare my PS5 and Series X’s optical drives some wear and tear.

As for the cd part…a few years ago I was surprised to learn that the PS4 didn’t have the ability to play cds…and then I remembered that I ripped all my CDs years ago and have never used my game console to play music since the PS2. Genuinely surprised that the series X can play them. I learned something new today, and I hope you did as well with the PS5 and 4k movie playing!

Re: Suddenly Getting Banned From Microsoft Rewards? You're Not Alone

dskatter

@Kieduss Blatantly incorrect. I have one account, only earn points from my Xbox and the app, and haven’t abused a damn thing. My account got suspended sometime between yesterday afternoon and this morning.

I suggest not making sweeping generalizations in the future. You’ll look less foolish.

@Lucylu1983 Looks like mine is back up and running now. Thanks for that info!

Re: Hi-Fi RUSH Dev Posts New Year Message As Studio Is 'Reborn' Outside Of Xbox

dskatter

@Sol4ris I more meant that the people who play said games and then don’t buy them is sad.

Obviously you are DEFINITELY an outlier, as am I! But (and yes, this is anecdotal, I know) my series X-owning friend at work has bought exactly three games since getting the X at launch. He’s a gamepass guy. Hell, the only reason he still has Forza Horizon 4 is because I bought it for him digitally over the holidays.

He’s the only other series X owner I know, so my knowledge pool is admittely small. But he’s definitely not an outlier from what I see online, and that’s why I find it sad.

Re: Hi-Fi RUSH Dev Posts New Year Message As Studio Is 'Reborn' Outside Of Xbox

dskatter

@Rog-X Tell me you find every opportunity to disparage Sony in an article unrelated to Sony without telling me you find every opportunity to disparage Sony in an article unrelated to Sony.

@LogicStrikesAgain “Especially if it’s not made exclusive to a platform with a userbase that isn’t particularly prone to buying games.”

Just this. The number of people who wait for games to hit GamePass is sad. That said, I freely admit GamePass DID get me to buy Hi-Fi Rush digitally after trying it out on my Series X. Unfortunately, most people wouldn’t actually buy the game afterwards.

Re: Black Myth: Wukong's Xbox Saga Just Got A Whole Lot More Confusing

dskatter

Heh. This was reported on Push Square just before I went to bed, and I mentioned that the Pure XBox comments when it got reported here should be interesting.

Just woke up and reading all these now. I love being right. munches popcorn

That said, it’s too bad the series S continues to be a millstone around dev’s necks, having to release for S and X simultaneously.

Re: Xbox's Indiana Jones Success Has Apparently Left Disney Wanting More

dskatter

I definitely look forward to a sequel. There were some odd dialogue-repetition bugs that popped up, including characters who were nowhere near to me having audible speech, but other than that I had a blast. Was very pleasantly surprised.

Will definitely be buying the PS5 physical copy now that I’ve rented it on GP.

Re: Poll: How Many Xbox Games Have You Actually Bought In 2024?

dskatter

Well, I’ve only had an Xbox since April of this year, but let’s see here!

37 physical games

35 digital games, including some free-to-buy like the first two Crackdowns, and the recent EA freebies.

Not bad for eight months of ownership!

…don’t ask me how many PS or Switch games I’ve purchased this year, though…