@OldGamer999 seriously. Playstation does a good job at taking over London tube Stations or whatever. Just random things that go viral. Nintendo has the Mario bus at the moment. Xbox just doesn’t seem to bother outside of a snarky tweet 🤣
@NoblePanda78 I think a lot of people wrote it off as a dudebro shooter but it has incredible heart. It’s easily one of my favourite series of all time.
I do think The Coalition is working on an “Unreal Engine 5” Gears 6 which is why it’s had an extended development time.
Playground doing Fable; The Initiative (hopefully still) doing Perfect Dark. That’s all we have with the old IPs so far. Get Toys For Bob and re-spun-out Vicarious Visions on Banjo and Tony Hawk. Get Nightdive (third party) on anything.
I like that they get to be motivated and work on what they want as a team. I just hope that covers some if the awesome IP Xbox now owns.
Ultimately though; just screw everything else, bring back FASA studios and bring back Shadowrun. Done.
I do hope Phil encourages some new IPs out of Activision. It’s a no brainer to be honest.
I don’t see them acquiring any more western publishers now. I do think there is the possibility of a Japanese publisher and then that would be it (for the big ones). Let’s see.
It’s really the leverage the Xbox gets along with the deal. If Square Enix, for example, thought Xbox was irrelevant before; they won’t now with XGS, Zenimax & ABK.
@themightyant even if they have to pay 20 Billion as an example; would it all be in one instalment out of that 111B? Or would they be able to spread it?
Everyone should pay their taxes correctly in the first place. So not defending Microsoft; but to already be 10 billion out in your demands is crazy!
Basically SE is the only thing that made me get a PS5. Take them out the equation and Playstation really doesn’t interest me much unfortunately. Insomniac is the only other reason but not sure they are enough by themselves.
Ive really enjoyed it so far. Lots of people trying to skew the perception of it negatively but hasn’t stopped me enjoying it. It is my GOTY so far. I haven’t played BG3 though for what it’s worth.
@themightyant I think gamepass might save Crash Team Rumble. It is heavily discounted at the moment and I can’t imagine it has done too well so far. Hopefully Gamepass can boost the numbers.
I usually keep up with gaming news and i’ve never heard of it. Completed Hi-Fi rush last week as a break from Starfield and it was incredible. Hope it gets the nods it deserves.
I actually do think something like Forza does make sense to be a platform (assuming they support it correctly going forward). I just hope they don’t take this approach with Fable and Perfect Dark etc…
@The-Grezzly-Bear yea i’m in UK too - must be a licensing thing. To be fair in the UK we do get other benefits other countries seem to miss out on - I feel for those that don’t get MS Rewards.
Just returned to this game to finish it off as a break from Starfield and it really is awesome. I hope people remember this when it comes to GOTY noms.
I hope you guys are right I would love to see a JRPG from them. As long as they are making what they want to make - that is how we get the good stuff like HI-FI Rush.
@Pimpernel I really hope they don’t copy Sony. What is the point? If you want to play a Playstation Studios game then… play a Playstation Studios game. Xbox can do their own thing. Starfield and things like Fable are much more interesting to me. But if I want to play a third person cinematic action game I can do that too. Hellblade is probably the closest Xbox have to that style of game and I would say that is enough.
The only other acquisition I would even want made (other than to save a publisher from disappearing entirely) would be Square Enix only to keep games on Xbox; but also multi-plat.
@Moonglow Yea I thought of Mighty Doom and FH5 Rally expansion but I was listing just the Gamepass additions. I think theres been discussion recently about how essential are various subscriptions and the need to cut some out and the idea that Rockstar is trying their hand at one. And Gamepass just stands tall above the rest as the one to have. Currently and in my opinion of course; with the output listed above!
For me it was having Like a Dragon Gaiden on Gamepass, Octopath II on Xbox; and there was the Pokemon-with-guns game that I have forgotten the name of which actually looks fun! But overall nothing mindblowing. I was hoping for a “one last thing”…
The emails were over 3 years old. I’m more concerned about how vicious some of the comments can be (across these 3 sites) directed at one human man who is actually just doing his job. I don’t support the whole Xbox buying Nintendo thing either but wow the hatred towards Phil can get real from some people.
Imagine doing your job at that level in an entertainment company that many people love and the community you deliver to calls you a parasite, liar, two-faced… amongst other things. Shame some of these comments aren’t monitored better to be honest. So much for #BeNice or whatever.
There was an article a year or so ago on PushSquare where everyone was making fun of the way Jim Ryan looks as well. That wasn’t nice either. Just all a bit ***** really. Different when you are attacking a corporation like Xbox or Playstation but when it’s a human with a family I just don’t get it. Unless they actually did something bad. But this isn’t it.
The idea of Xbox buying Nintendo is fun until it’s not. I don’t ever see it happening; hostile or otherwise. But if it did of course the industry would suffer as one of the big 3 loses their identity. If Xbox desperately wants an asian presence (which I can understand them wanting) then stick to Sega or Square Enix. Or on a smaller scale - Mistwalker.
However - partnering with Nintendo on a smaller scale I am 100% behind. Just look at Goldeneye or Banjo etc.
Edit: after thinking about it more - there is one scenario where I would support this; and it’s if we are living in the timeline where Apple, Amazon, Google, Tencent etc become the dominant forces in gaming - with Microsoft standing alongside them. At that point I would be glad for them to have brought Nintendo with them. But yea thats a 20years from now scenario.
The way I see it there is only one way for them to “crack” the Japanese market. They need Japanese games as exclusives; like with Lost Odyssey and Blue Dragon… but they need to eat the cost over years and years as that exclusive library builds up; and not throw in the towel after 2 games haven’t changed their fortunes.
With Xbox games all being on PC I just don’t see it happening unfortunately. But more Japanese, or Asian in general, games will still lead to more sales so it’s a step in the right direction. Plus it helps that audiences in the West also like those games.
@Jimboss a leaked email is just an email. Things can change and we have already seen Quake and Quake II remasters come out everywhere. Even if they aren’t new surely they fall under “existing”.
@themightyant yea I agree - basically something like Quake 2 isn’t going to shift consoles (or allegiances) so why not sell it everywhere and get that PS/Switch income too. Something new and exciting though like an Elder Scrolls has that power so will be exclusive. Though I wonder about the rumoured Oblivion remake…
Voted 10/10; it’s maybe like a 9.5 realistically. About 16/17 hours in. Loving just “playing” it and not worrying about anything else. Very atmospheric and absorbing. Not done too much of the main quest. Not got any of the bugs or issues people have complained about but did just have my first crash at 16hrs but on a mission where there was a LOT exploding around me and I wasn’t helping the situation. Doesn’t matter as I save every like 20 steps for some reason!
@GrumpyDev happy to bash them; as if anyone is doing the same on Xbox’s side they should also be called out. Just pointless all round; people wasting their time on that crap.
Good thing is it’s keeping Starfield in the headlines.
Pretty embarassing for the Playstation lot really.
I saw someone saying they were glad this “flop of a game didn’t come out on Playstation”, which is pretty sad. But also would have more impact had they said nothing at all. I don’t understand the goal; since a comment like that isn’t going to make me stop playing - if anything it makes me more grateful I get to play it and enjoy it even more.
@Fiendish-Beaver of course - i’m just saying it’s my GOTY so far. I haven’t played Baldur’s Gate 3 yet so who knows, maybe that will de-throne it but at the moment Starfield is at the top spot.
Great achievement for a great game. I can’t wait to get back to it. It’s easily my GOTY so far, not forgetting all the other great games I have played this year (still haven’t started Pikmin 4 though so… you know).
@Kaloudz they are all basically reskins of eachother but I have enjoyed a good few of them over the years on mobile and Switch. Game dev story being the standout. You place rooms and items down but a lot of it is about staff morale and finances etc. They are simple games.
I’m loving it. Running around doing missions and levelling up. It’s got some serious menu issues but they can be fixed in the future (and the planet map sucks - though it has encouraged me to open my eyes a bit and remember the locations). But the game itself is great if you allow patience and take it as it is. Not sure exactly what people were expecting, but at the moment it is playing like a Bethesda game in space… which is exactly what I thought it would be. It won’t dethrone Elder Scrolls but it’s still extremely strong.
Also i’ve heard multiple people say the game has a slow start but I would argue this is quicker at getting going than most RPGs like it. For reference i’m around 10 hours in.
@Kienda great comment and really puts things into perspective. Sometimes we are all so wired in; we need to take a step back. Loving the positive reactions this game is getting and, though tempted with early access, I am really looking forward to playing it next week.
For me, Oblivion, Skyrim and the Fallout games are some of the best gaming experiences I have had with some of my longest playtimes (maybe only FFXIV got them beat with hours played) so I will try my best to savour this.
Great for Xbox and Bethesda to have delivered such a great experience and definitely a win for Gamepass!
I’m happy with the response overall. Was hoping it was 85 or above and so far it is… can still drop of course. But regardless the reaction is positive. Inject these Bethesda games into my veins please. Going to enjoy myself playing the game and let the fanboys fight amongst themselves.
@StonyKL Kind of hard to prove when a game has been knocked down; though as an example there is the Quake II review on Push Square. Though I actually wasn’t talking about Multiplats (if it’s the same game on Xbox and Playstation then it’s the same game - the bias isn’t going to be that blatant!).
More just that if 2 games of the same quality were released, one on Xbox and one on Playstation, the Playstation game would get the higher reviews and praise. Like how Stray (exclusive at the time) was ridden high. Not a bad game of course but bigged up because it was a playstation release. Plus looking at the metacritic scores of Playstation exclusives I just don’t think they deserve them (again not bad games and well produced but… where is the fun?). My opinion of course.
I don’t watch every youtuber or influencer so i’m seeing it from my perspective. I mean I do listen to Kinda Funny and even they would find it hard to deny they skew blue overall.
Anyway the one that comes to mind that is a fair match-up would be Psychonauts 2 vs Ratchet and Clank Rift Apart. In my opinion the former blows the latter out the water but the reviews didn’t show that.
Comments 1,209
Re: Giant Animated 'XSphere' Showcases Xbox Games Lineup In Las Vegas
@OldGamer999 seriously. Playstation does a good job at taking over London tube Stations or whatever. Just random things that go viral. Nintendo has the Mario bus at the moment. Xbox just doesn’t seem to bother outside of a snarky tweet 🤣
Re: Soapbox: Gears Of War Should Return To Its Horror-Themed 'Mad World' Roots
@NoblePanda78 I think a lot of people wrote it off as a dudebro shooter but it has incredible heart. It’s easily one of my favourite series of all time.
I do think The Coalition is working on an “Unreal Engine 5” Gears 6 which is why it’s had an extended development time.
Re: Soapbox: Gears Of War Should Return To Its Horror-Themed 'Mad World' Roots
Yes please. I have a rendezvous with death.
Re: Xbox Boss Would Love To 'Revisit' Older Franchises More, Uses Quake 2 As An Example
Playground doing Fable; The Initiative (hopefully still) doing Perfect Dark. That’s all we have with the old IPs so far. Get Toys For Bob and re-spun-out Vicarious Visions on Banjo and Tony Hawk. Get Nightdive (third party) on anything.
I like that they get to be motivated and work on what they want as a team. I just hope that covers some if the awesome IP Xbox now owns.
Ultimately though; just screw everything else, bring back FASA studios and bring back Shadowrun. Done.
Re: Phil Spencer Is 'Incredibly Excited' About The Future Of Xbox
I do hope Phil encourages some new IPs out of Activision. It’s a no brainer to be honest.
I don’t see them acquiring any more western publishers now. I do think there is the possibility of a Japanese publisher and then that would be it (for the big ones). Let’s see.
Re: These Seven Games Are Coming To Xbox Game Pass (October 19 - 31)
Wow what an awesome surprise. Happy to try it though I am a p**** when it comes to horror.
Re: Xbox Game Pass's 'Like A Dragon Gaiden' Will Launch Without English Voiceover
Fine by me - i’ve gone through all of them in Japanese. Incredible series.
Re: Here's A Look At Every Xbox Studio Following The ActiBlizz Acquisition
From roughly 2,500 employees in 2020 to 22,000 in 2023 😵
Re: UK CMA Approves Microsoft's Acquisition Of Activision Blizzard
It’s really the leverage the Xbox gets along with the deal. If Square Enix, for example, thought Xbox was irrelevant before; they won’t now with XGS, Zenimax & ABK.
Re: Microsoft Plans To Appeal As IRS Requests $28.9 Billion In Back Taxes
@themightyant even if they have to pay 20 Billion as an example; would it all be in one instalment out of that 111B? Or would they be able to spread it?
Everyone should pay their taxes correctly in the first place. So not defending Microsoft; but to already be 10 billion out in your demands is crazy!
Re: New Rumour Hints At Exciting Future For Square Enix Games On Xbox
Basically SE is the only thing that made me get a PS5. Take them out the equation and Playstation really doesn’t interest me much unfortunately. Insomniac is the only other reason but not sure they are enough by themselves.
Hopefully Xbox can get all the SE goodies!
Re: Talking Point: One Month On From Launch, How Are You Feeling About Starfield?
Ive really enjoyed it so far. Lots of people trying to skew the perception of it negatively but hasn’t stopped me enjoying it. It is my GOTY so far. I haven’t played BG3 though for what it’s worth.
Re: After Almost Two Years, Next Week Could Be The Finale For Xbox's ActiBlizz Takeover
@themightyant I think gamepass might save Crash Team Rumble. It is heavily discounted at the moment and I can’t imagine it has done too well so far. Hopefully Gamepass can boost the numbers.
Re: Chants Of Sennaar Nominated For 'Xbox Game Of The Year' At Golden Joystick Awards
I usually keep up with gaming news and i’ve never heard of it. Completed Hi-Fi rush last week as a break from Starfield and it was incredible. Hope it gets the nods it deserves.
Re: Roundup: Here's What The Critics Are Saying About Forza Motorsport
I actually do think something like Forza does make sense to be a platform (assuming they support it correctly going forward). I just hope they don’t take this approach with Fable and Perfect Dark etc…
Re: Xbox Adds More Perks For Game Pass Ultimate Members (October 2023)
@The-Grezzly-Bear yea i’m in UK too - must be a licensing thing. To be fair in the UK we do get other benefits other countries seem to miss out on - I feel for those that don’t get MS Rewards.
Re: Xbox Adds More Perks For Game Pass Ultimate Members (October 2023)
The free movie perk is really good but shame it continues to be US only…
Re: These Four Games Are Coming To Xbox Game Pass (October 4-17)
I bought Ishin a couple weeks before the TGS gamepass announcement. You are all very welcome.
Re: Review: Hi-Fi RUSH - Tango Gameworks Drops A Beat-Bopping Banger On Xbox Game Pass
Just returned to this game to finish it off as a break from Starfield and it really is awesome. I hope people remember this when it comes to GOTY noms.
Re: The Xbox Series S 'xScreen' Is Now Officially Licensed By Microsoft
If I had a Series S I would be all over this.
Edit: that is a shame it’s so expensive in the UK…
Re: Phil Spencer Visits Hi-Fi RUSH Xbox Studio Tango Gameworks
I hope you guys are right I would love to see a JRPG from them. As long as they are making what they want to make - that is how we get the good stuff like HI-FI Rush.
Re: Capcom Would 'Gracefully Decline' Any Acquisition Attempt From Xbox
@Tharsman don’t forget Hi-Fi Rush
Re: Capcom Would 'Gracefully Decline' Any Acquisition Attempt From Xbox
@Pimpernel I really hope they don’t copy Sony. What is the point? If you want to play a Playstation Studios game then… play a Playstation Studios game. Xbox can do their own thing. Starfield and things like Fable are much more interesting to me. But if I want to play a third person cinematic action game I can do that too. Hellblade is probably the closest Xbox have to that style of game and I would say that is enough.
The only other acquisition I would even want made (other than to save a publisher from disappearing entirely) would be Square Enix only to keep games on Xbox; but also multi-plat.
Re: CMA Approval A 'Significant Milestone' Towards Xbox Merging With Activision Blizzard
@Moonglow Yea I thought of Mighty Doom and FH5 Rally expansion but I was listing just the Gamepass additions. I think theres been discussion recently about how essential are various subscriptions and the need to cut some out and the idea that Rockstar is trying their hand at one. And Gamepass just stands tall above the rest as the one to have. Currently and in my opinion of course; with the output listed above!
Re: CMA Approval A 'Significant Milestone' Towards Xbox Merging With Activision Blizzard
The First-Party Gamepass additions in 2023 have been pretty crazy already; without ABK:
Xbox Game Studios:
Zenimax Media:
Like that is an awesome and varied line-up to support a subscription service. Will be wild with ABK involved too.
Re: Poll: How Would You Grade The Xbox Tokyo Game Show 2023 Event?
For me it was having Like a Dragon Gaiden on Gamepass, Octopath II on Xbox; and there was the Pokemon-with-guns game that I have forgotten the name of which actually looks fun! But overall nothing mindblowing. I was hoping for a “one last thing”…
Edit: Palworld I think? Looks fun.
Re: Phil Spencer Issues Statement In Response To Massive Xbox Leak
The emails were over 3 years old. I’m more concerned about how vicious some of the comments can be (across these 3 sites) directed at one human man who is actually just doing his job. I don’t support the whole Xbox buying Nintendo thing either but wow the hatred towards Phil can get real from some people.
Imagine doing your job at that level in an entertainment company that many people love and the community you deliver to calls you a parasite, liar, two-faced… amongst other things. Shame some of these comments aren’t monitored better to be honest. So much for #BeNice or whatever.
There was an article a year or so ago on PushSquare where everyone was making fun of the way Jim Ryan looks as well. That wasn’t nice either. Just all a bit ***** really. Different when you are attacking a corporation like Xbox or Playstation but when it’s a human with a family I just don’t get it. Unless they actually did something bad. But this isn’t it.
Re: Xbox's Phil Spencer Was Dead Serious About Wanting To Acquire Nintendo In 2020
The idea of Xbox buying Nintendo is fun until it’s not. I don’t ever see it happening; hostile or otherwise. But if it did of course the industry would suffer as one of the big 3 loses their identity. If Xbox desperately wants an asian presence (which I can understand them wanting) then stick to Sega or Square Enix. Or on a smaller scale - Mistwalker.
However - partnering with Nintendo on a smaller scale I am 100% behind. Just look at Goldeneye or Banjo etc.
Edit: after thinking about it more - there is one scenario where I would support this; and it’s if we are living in the timeline where Apple, Amazon, Google, Tencent etc become the dominant forces in gaming - with Microsoft standing alongside them. At that point I would be glad for them to have brought Nintendo with them. But yea thats a 20years from now scenario.
Re: Microsoft Is Targeting 2028 For A 'Hybrid' Next Generation Xbox Console
Perhaps they now have leverage with the FTC to push through another large acquisition…
Re: Pick One: Which Is The Best Bethesda Game Studios RPG?
Oblivion for me. Absolutely mindblowing experience playing that in 2006. Love the world too. And that opening cutscene is epic.
Re: Phil Spencer On Tokyo Game Show 2023: 'The Future For Xbox In Japan Is Bright'
The way I see it there is only one way for them to “crack” the Japanese market. They need Japanese games as exclusives; like with Lost Odyssey and Blue Dragon… but they need to eat the cost over years and years as that exclusive library builds up; and not throw in the towel after 2 games haven’t changed their fortunes.
With Xbox games all being on PC I just don’t see it happening unfortunately. But more Japanese, or Asian in general, games will still lead to more sales so it’s a step in the right direction. Plus it helps that audiences in the West also like those games.
Re: Starfield Could Have Had Fallout's Version Of Earth
@themightyant I agree I was kinda exploring waiting for something else to drop. But just for other peoples’ sakes - I appreciate you adding the tags.
Re: Starfield Could Have Had Fallout's Version Of Earth
@themightyant I think that was the spoiler the article was trying to avoid; just saying…
Re: Xbox Boss Reiterates Platform Exclusives Will Be Determined On A 'Case-By-Case Basis'
@Jimboss a leaked email is just an email. Things can change and we have already seen Quake and Quake II remasters come out everywhere. Even if they aren’t new surely they fall under “existing”.
@themightyant yea I agree - basically something like Quake 2 isn’t going to shift consoles (or allegiances) so why not sell it everywhere and get that PS/Switch income too. Something new and exciting though like an Elder Scrolls has that power so will be exclusive. Though I wonder about the rumoured Oblivion remake…
Re: Poll: Based On What You've Played So Far, What Score Would You Give Starfield?
Voted 10/10; it’s maybe like a 9.5 realistically. About 16/17 hours in. Loving just “playing” it and not worrying about anything else. Very atmospheric and absorbing. Not done too much of the main quest. Not got any of the bugs or issues people have complained about but did just have my first crash at 16hrs but on a mission where there was a LOT exploding around me and I wasn’t helping the situation. Doesn’t matter as I save every like 20 steps for some reason!
Re: Oh Look, Starfield Is Getting Review Bombed On Metacritic
@GrumpyDev happy to bash them; as if anyone is doing the same on Xbox’s side they should also be called out. Just pointless all round; people wasting their time on that crap.
Good thing is it’s keeping Starfield in the headlines.
Re: Oh Look, Starfield Is Getting Review Bombed On Metacritic
Pretty embarassing for the Playstation lot really.
I saw someone saying they were glad this “flop of a game didn’t come out on Playstation”, which is pretty sad. But also would have more impact had they said nothing at all. I don’t understand the goal; since a comment like that isn’t going to make me stop playing - if anything it makes me more grateful I get to play it and enjoy it even more.
Re: Xbox Boss Says Starfield 'Exceeded' 1 Million Concurrent Players On Launch Day
@Fiendish-Beaver of course - i’m just saying it’s my GOTY so far. I haven’t played Baldur’s Gate 3 yet so who knows, maybe that will de-throne it but at the moment Starfield is at the top spot.
Re: Xbox Boss Says Starfield 'Exceeded' 1 Million Concurrent Players On Launch Day
Great achievement for a great game. I can’t wait to get back to it. It’s easily my GOTY so far, not forgetting all the other great games I have played this year (still haven’t started Pikmin 4 though so… you know).
Re: Kairosoft Is Bringing Five Simulation Games To Xbox Next Week
@Kaloudz they are all basically reskins of eachother but I have enjoyed a good few of them over the years on mobile and Switch. Game dev story being the standout. You place rooms and items down but a lot of it is about staff morale and finances etc. They are simple games.
Re: Starfield Fan's Potato-Filled Spaceship Shows Off Impressive Physics System
I love this! Never let a single potato go! The beauty of a BGS game ❤️
Re: Early Access Players, What Are Your First Impressions Of Starfield?
I’m loving it. Running around doing missions and levelling up. It’s got some serious menu issues but they can be fixed in the future (and the planet map sucks - though it has encouraged me to open my eyes a bit and remember the locations). But the game itself is great if you allow patience and take it as it is. Not sure exactly what people were expecting, but at the moment it is playing like a Bethesda game in space… which is exactly what I thought it would be. It won’t dethrone Elder Scrolls but it’s still extremely strong.
Also i’ve heard multiple people say the game has a slow start but I would argue this is quicker at getting going than most RPGs like it. For reference i’m around 10 hours in.
Re: PSA: Starfield Streams Will Reportedly Go Live Ahead Of Early Access
Removed
Re: Bethesda Thanks Fans For Their Support As Starfield Enters Early Access
@Kienda great comment and really puts things into perspective. Sometimes we are all so wired in; we need to take a step back. Loving the positive reactions this game is getting and, though tempted with early access, I am really looking forward to playing it next week.
For me, Oblivion, Skyrim and the Fallout games are some of the best gaming experiences I have had with some of my longest playtimes (maybe only FFXIV got them beat with hours played) so I will try my best to savour this.
Great for Xbox and Bethesda to have delivered such a great experience and definitely a win for Gamepass!
Re: PSA: Starfield Streams Will Reportedly Go Live Ahead Of Early Access
@ArmoredMore lovely how you have now edited your comment… not my fault you misread.
Re: PSA: Starfield Streams Will Reportedly Go Live Ahead Of Early Access
@ArmoredMore I didn’t say anyone was bashing Starfield.
Re: Roundup: Here's What The Critics Think Of Starfield So Far
I’m happy with the response overall. Was hoping it was 85 or above and so far it is… can still drop of course. But regardless the reaction is positive. Inject these Bethesda games into my veins please. Going to enjoy myself playing the game and let the fanboys fight amongst themselves.
Re: Roundup: Here's What The Critics Think Of Starfield So Far
@themightyant ah strange, it’s sorted itself now. First time I had seen it but i’m usually not so eager. Thanks for the info 👍
Re: Roundup: Here's What The Critics Think Of Starfield So Far
The metacritic score has disappeared for me now. I could see it earlier. Weird.
Re: PSA: Starfield Streams Will Reportedly Go Live Ahead Of Early Access
@StonyKL Kind of hard to prove when a game has been knocked down; though as an example there is the Quake II review on Push Square. Though I actually wasn’t talking about Multiplats (if it’s the same game on Xbox and Playstation then it’s the same game - the bias isn’t going to be that blatant!).
More just that if 2 games of the same quality were released, one on Xbox and one on Playstation, the Playstation game would get the higher reviews and praise. Like how Stray (exclusive at the time) was ridden high. Not a bad game of course but bigged up because it was a playstation release. Plus looking at the metacritic scores of Playstation exclusives I just don’t think they deserve them (again not bad games and well produced but… where is the fun?). My opinion of course.
I don’t watch every youtuber or influencer so i’m seeing it from my perspective. I mean I do listen to Kinda Funny and even they would find it hard to deny they skew blue overall.
Anyway the one that comes to mind that is a fair match-up would be Psychonauts 2 vs Ratchet and Clank Rift Apart. In my opinion the former blows the latter out the water but the reviews didn’t show that.