Comments 1,313

Re: Talking Point: After Halo: Campaign Evolved, What Do You Want Xbox To Do With The Series?

Cakefish

Infinite is probably actually my least favourite of the mainline Halo games. It’s a game I’ve soured more and more on over time. Narratively it just feels incomplete, it’s just filler. Halo 5 may have butchered Cortana, but at least it tried to tell a story. And it had the variety in biomes and cinematic flair that Infinite sorely lacks. For Infinite to be partially redeemed in my eyes they need to actually directly continue the plot it set up (because that’s the thing, the entire game feels like just an intro chapter) and not repeat the ‘we’ll address the cliffhanger of the previous game off-screen and pretend it never happened’ thing again. Infinite feels like a game designed with a meaty story expansion in mind that just never arrived in the end. Do Infinite round 2 that addresses the issues of the original and you’d have a strong entry in the series I think.

Re: Xbox Announces Price Reductions For Game Pass Ultimate & PC Game Pass

Cakefish

Very cool (nice job Asha), buuuuut there is a catch!

The conversion rate of Essential to Ultimate, which I consider to be the true price of Game Pass, only improved from 40% to 45%. So an effective 12.5% reduction in price. It’s nice, but not nearly as dramatic as the reduction in the monthly rolling price, which is a bit of a shame. I don’t think it’s quite enough to convince me to convert my stacked years of Essential into Ultimate.

Still, can’t complain! I really like the direction the new management is heading in so far.

Re: Xbox Boss Declares Game Pass Is 'Too Expensive' And Needs A 'Better Value Equation'

Cakefish

Oopsies lol

Guess it confirms that they lost a substantial number of subscribers since last year’s price hikes. They wouldn’t be saying this kind of thing otherwise if they weren’t seeing actual negative impacts to the bottom line. It’s not surprising, but interesting to see it all but confirmed nonetheless.

As for what would entice me back to Game Pass Ultimate I don’t even know. My issue is that the majority of games I want to play either aren’t in the library at all or get added years down the line after I’ve already bought them. That problem can’t be resolved, it’s just that my gaming tastes are niche. A more flexible system sounds good, but that wording is pretty vague, could mean anything really.

It’ll be interesting to see what changes and how quickly they make these changes! Earlier reports were saying there’d be no major changes to the Game Pass tiers this year, but with new management anything is possible.

Re: 'What Do You Want Added?' - Xbox Engineer Requests Ideas For New Console Features

Cakefish

I know asking for complete ad removal from dashboard is unrealistic, but I never want to see another damn obnoxious Tesco advert ever again on my Xbox like we were subjected to last month, or any non-gaming related advert for that matter. If you insist on adverts on my gaming box then I insist that they must be gaming related at the very least.

I’d also like the ability to order my store wish list by various things such as custom rankings, release date, pricing, current sales, console type, etc. Just like Steam has.

There’s so many other possibilities here. How genuinely refreshing that they actually are bothering about consoles again after completely forgetting about XSX|S ever since 2023. The new leadership is firing on all cylinders so far, so promising, I only hope the momentum is maintained through the rest of the year and beyond!

Re: Xbox Spring Sale 2026 'Preview' Now Live, 600+ Games Discounted

Cakefish

@Fiendish-Beaver ah thank you! I went to uni and got a master’s degree, but I don’t want to pretend I’m a genius science boffin or anything like that. I’m not very good at maths, so while I can do the basic statistics, I can’t do anything too fancy. So my current role is more data collection orientated than on the analysis side of things. Plenty of opportunities to develop and branch out though!

Re: Talking Point: What Are You Playing This Weekend? (March 28-29)

Cakefish

I’ll be starting Code Vein 2 tonight! I played a few hours before my extended work trip back in Feb, but deleted my character so I could start from scratch now that the game has seen a couple big patches while I’ve been away. Should apparently be another big patch launching next week that adds auto item pickup and more performance improvements so looking forward to that! Can’t wait to get properly stuck in, I love soulslikes so much 😊

Re: Xbox Spring Sale 2026 'Preview' Now Live, 600+ Games Discounted

Cakefish

@Fiendish-Beaver sorta kinda but also not really. Let me explain!

This is a pseudonym I originally came up with as a teenager for some gaming related forum, can’t remember which one specifically. My brain thought of ‘fishcake’ and then flipped it around. The surreal concept of a fish composed of cake amused me so it stuck in my mind and here we are. I started reusing it for most other gaming accounts too. I was interested in marine biology back then too so fishy things were on my mind a lot.

The survey was beam trawling. Collecting data on fish such as length, weight, sex, maturity etc. Some larger sharks/rays get tagged and released. Lots of environmental data collected too. Water samples, chlorophyll samples, sediment samples etc.

I’m not at sea all the time, these things come about once or twice a year. Usually I spend a few weeks at sea per year. This year is a bit of a bumper one though where I’ll be spending ~9 weeks at sea in total if all goes to plan. Still got some more sea trips on the calendar later in the year.

I’m not good at ping pong at the best of times, I have terrible hand-eye coordination, so yeah you can imagine how that went at sea. Still good fun though haha 😂

Re: Microsoft Beats Out Sony & Nintendo In Metacritic's 2026 Game Publisher Rankings

Cakefish

At the risk of coming across as a hater here I personally think it’s rather silly to lump ports of old games in with brand new titles to generate annual meta rankings. When half the titles for Xbox are just PS5/Switch 2 ports what useful information is that even supposed to convey? It would be better if the ports of older games were separated out from the actual new releases, so we can just focus on the true 2025 output.

Re: Talking Point: What Do You 'Expect' From Xbox Over The Next Five Years?

Cakefish

It’s so hard to say as so many things still up in the air, especially as the leadership just changed. The route they appear to be going down is transitioning to a PC only brand, but attempting to make PCs much more living room friendly in the process. I’m very interested in seeing where it goes, but also I struggle to see how they can compete with Steam which de facto owns the PC market.

Re: 'We Will See More Games Come To Xbox Quicker' - Microsoft Exec Talks Plans For The Future

Cakefish

“so bringing them from Steam to the Xbox Store hopefully won't present anywhere near as many hurdles in the next generation.”

Well not really, in my opinion. Xbox App already exists on PC and most publishers default to Steam regardless. Not a problem if Helix supports Steam of course, but just wanted to point out there’s no barrier to developers using Xbox on PC currently, they just choose not to. I don’t see how Helix will dramatically change this dynamic honestly, usurping Steam as the default PC storefront is a gigantic mountain to climb, to say the least!

Having more timely indie releases on XSX in the meantime would be a very good thing though.

Re: Fortnite Price Hikes Are Coming, And They'll Affect Xbox Game Pass Ultimate

Cakefish

@Fiendish-Beaver I personally think it’d make much more sense to simply raise price of Ultimate until it’s profitable, if it’s not already. Maybe it sheds a lot of users but at least then it’s still technically offered as an option, avoiding the terrible PR from spending a decade hyping up day one Game Pass titles only to suddenly kill them off completely.

Re: Fortnite Price Hikes Are Coming, And They'll Affect Xbox Game Pass Ultimate

Cakefish

@Fiendish-Beaver wasn’t the whole point of the pivot to PlayStation intended to offset loss of Xbox first party game sales? I don’t see why it’d be beneficial to give up on years worth of cultivating a brand (Game Pass) only to kill it cold. The whole thing would’ve been pointless and with no exclusives to turn back to and no Game Pass either then how does Xbox hope to compete with PlayStation and Steam? After putting all their eggs into the Game Pass basket I don’t see how they can ditch it and survive.

I’m no longer subscribed to Ultimate so it’s not an issue for me personally, but the main talking point about Xbox the past half decade has been Game Pass. I think the PR hit would be quite significant.

Well if the 25% price hike thing is true then that’s not good at all. Microsoft will be in hot water for sure if they go for that yet again (fourth year in a row if I count correctly). Hopefully Essential escapes the price hike madness 🤞