Comments 1,352

Re: Roundup: The First Reviews Have Arrived For Mortal Shell 2

Cakefish

I bought the first game years ago after seeing the positive reviews it got and it ended up being the least enjoyable soulslike I’ve ever purchased. I really didn’t click with it at all. So I’m a bit cautious of this one. I’ll do some research and maybe add to my wish list if it sounds promising. It’ll need to change quite a lot from the original to get me on side though.

Re: SanDisk Announces Three New Expansion Cards For Xbox Series X|S

Cakefish

Great to finally have more competition, but what on earth has happened to these prices? Argos are currently selling the Seagate 1TB card for £350?! 🤯 Amazon is a bit more sane but still very sobering at £230ish, no cheaper than they were back at launch. So even bespoke proprietary memory is suffering from the AI explosion, that’s crazy.

Plus, with no confirmation of forwards compatibility with Helix it’s kind of a very risky purchase to buy this late into XSX generation. They absolutely should announce forwards compatibility, I don’t like the thought of all the ewaste that’ll be generated if these cards just end up as mini bricks going forwards 😔

Re: Xbox Announces 3,200 Job Cuts And Four Studio Departures

Cakefish

Sad news regarding the wider job losses, but I’m personally relieved that Double Fine survives. Phew! 😮‍💨 Hope they don’t have to downsize though. I’d love a Psychonauts 3 one day. Also good that the other endangered studios also found buyers or investors.

Re: As PlayStation Announces The End Of Disc-Based Releases, Will Xbox Follow Suit?

Cakefish

When we heard that Helix is at its core a PC then this was all but officially confirmed. PC market has been all digital for eons.

As others have pointed out already, the Xbox stats are much more heavily skewed digital than PlayStation is so there’s even less incentive for retention of physical.

Maybe Asha will surprise us, but given they’re strongly rumoured to be mercilessly axing half a dozen of their most talented studios because the financial situation at Xbox is so dire I doubt there’s the budget to prioritise physical games.

Re: Marvel's Blade Reportedly In Danger As Xbox Considers Shutting Arkane Studios

Cakefish

Things seemed really positive for a few months there. Why can’t good times ever last with Xbox? 😢

I can see why Phil jumped ship when he did, he didn’t want his legacy to be tarnished with all these brutal closures.

They bought all of these studios to diversify away from Halo/Gears/Forza and add variety to Game Pass and yet now they are mercilessly culling them all.

I still feel very sad about Double Fine in particular, but losing all of these at once is such a damaging blow to the brand. It’s as baffling as Sony closing Bluepoint, but on an even larger scale ugh 😣

Re: Matt Booty Explains Xbox's Plans For Exclusive Games Going Forward

Cakefish

It’s very good that exclusives are back on the menu imo. It’s needed after Sony backtracked on PC ports in order to keep their games off Helix. Xbox hardware wouldn’t have been able to survive after that happened. Glad that Asha could see the current strategy was unsustainable. It’ll be too little too late to revive XSX|S, but they need to get the ball rolling now so Helix can launch with a solid ‘console exclusive’ lineup. It’s great that Asha actually remembers the promise that Phil made back at XSX|S launch of great Xbox exclusives, Phil forgot that over the years and the brand massively suffered as a result.

Re: Xbox Games Showcase 2026: Date, Start Times, What To Expect & More

Cakefish

Not really feeling the same buzz as previous years now that my Ultimate has expired and I’m cruisin’ along on Essential, but I’m still curious to see more on Gears and Halo. Fable less so because of the delay into 2027, that kinda killed my excitement factor for that one for now. As is typical for me it’s actually the third party games that excite me the most because they are the complete wildcards. Might see more of Tides of Annihilation and I’d be well up for that!

Re: Talking Point: After Halo: Campaign Evolved, What Do You Want Xbox To Do With The Series?

Cakefish

Infinite is probably actually my least favourite of the mainline Halo games. It’s a game I’ve soured more and more on over time. Narratively it just feels incomplete, it’s just filler. Halo 5 may have butchered Cortana, but at least it tried to tell a story. And it had the variety in biomes and cinematic flair that Infinite sorely lacks. For Infinite to be partially redeemed in my eyes they need to actually directly continue the plot it set up (because that’s the thing, the entire game feels like just an intro chapter) and not repeat the ‘we’ll address the cliffhanger of the previous game off-screen and pretend it never happened’ thing again. Infinite feels like a game designed with a meaty story expansion in mind that just never arrived in the end. Do Infinite round 2 that addresses the issues of the original and you’d have a strong entry in the series I think.

Re: Xbox Announces Price Reductions For Game Pass Ultimate & PC Game Pass

Cakefish

Very cool (nice job Asha), buuuuut there is a catch!

The conversion rate of Essential to Ultimate, which I consider to be the true price of Game Pass, only improved from 40% to 45%. So an effective 12.5% reduction in price. It’s nice, but not nearly as dramatic as the reduction in the monthly rolling price, which is a bit of a shame. I don’t think it’s quite enough to convince me to convert my stacked years of Essential into Ultimate.

Still, can’t complain! I really like the direction the new management is heading in so far.