Comments 1,092

Re: Microsoft Issues Statement Denying Target & Walmart Are Pulling Xbox Products

Cakefish

This should be setting off alarm bells at Xbox HQ, that they’re having to issue these public statements on a weekly basis. “We triple pinky promise we’re not doing a Sega”. Every. Single. Week. Can they not see that these rando trolls are only able to successfully light all these wildfires around camp Xbox because of declining public brand perception? People hosting negative opinions about the brand will more quickly latch onto the doomongering rumours as confirmation bias.

Re: New Rumours Suggest PS6 & Next-Gen Xbox Could Both Release In 2027

Cakefish

Going against the grain here but I think 2027 is perfect timing personally. It matches up with the expected GPU/CPU refreshes on the PC side really nicely and seeing as this Xbox is supposed to be much more PC-like, well that just makes a lot of sense to me. The hardware spec has been set already, it’s locked in. Delaying to 2030 would only mean you get 5 year old hardware at launch (as is the case with Switch 2).

Personally, I want Xbox to provide cutting-edge hardware. They don’t have exclusives so can’t be as sleepy and relaxed about console specs as Nintendo are. I want great visuals at 60fps on my living room console (PC?). Next year games are expected to push the limits of these consoles with 30fps GTA 6 being an obvious prime example. If you want 60fps you gotta refresh hardware every now and then, we all have seen how heavy UE5 is and things aren’t gonna get any better over time!

Two years may seem like nothing to old folks like us, I get it, but keep in mind that XSX will still get the latest games for many years beyond that. Next gen is not the death of XSX, I wouldn’t be surprised at all if it keeps getting games well into 2030 looking how long the XBO has lasted.

Re: Xbox 'Magnus' Leak Suggests Next Console Will Be Powerful, Expensive & Maybe A Hybrid Device

Cakefish

Me likey. Me likey this lots. This is the correct path to take. Can’t survive vs PS6 by repeating the mistakes of XSX, which failed to differentiate itself enough. Needs to completely dominate PS6 in performance terms to successfully target the enthusiast crowd. Then you need to merge with the Windows development environment to ensure it retains support despite having a niche audience. Backwards compatibility is already confirmed, so happy days. Sensible thing to do would be to scrap the multiplayer paywall to somewhat compensate for the higher upfront hardware cost.

Re: Xbox Issues Statement Denying Rumour That Next-Gen Console Could Be Cancelled

Cakefish

I’ve built a digital games collection and all the hardware accessories so I really hope there is a new Xbox to migrate over to. I was really enthusiastic about the Xbox PC rumours, and still am, I think it sounds great. Though there’s still the elephant in the room of paid online multiplayer and how that would work with Steam/GOG and XSX backwards compatible games.

Re: Talking Point: How Do You Feel About Ubisoft+ Classics Being Added To Game Pass Ultimate?

Cakefish

The impact is dampened by the fact that half the games were already on Game Pass before this announcement. Most of the Far Cry and Assassin Creed games were at least. The games that weren’t are very old and could be picked up for cheap in seasonal sales. It’s not all that exciting.

At least it guarantees Star Wars Outlaws will come to Game Pass eventually, but my Ultimate will probably have expired by then - I only have it until March next year and then I plan to transition to Essential.

Re: Xbox Game Pass Is Getting A Major Overhaul With New Names, Games & Price Changes

Cakefish

@Fiendish-Beaver I remember many comments of yours in recent months questioning the profitability of Game Pass and predicting this significant price hike. So credit for reading the room correctly, but I think we can all agree that it kinda sucks that you were right in the end haha 😅

I completely failed in my prediction of no price rise until 2026. I didn’t think they’d be brazen enough to do another price rise for a third year in a row. They went above and beyond that though with such a steep price hike so soon!

Re: Xbox Game Pass Is Getting A Major Overhaul With New Names, Games & Price Changes

Cakefish

Will be moving down to Essential tier after my Ultimate expires in early March next year. I don’t use Game Pass enough to justify paying these prices.

Bit bummed that they’re keeping console multiplayer a paid feature. Wonder how they can possibly justify that with the next Xbox PC hybrid thingy that will also have Steam? No one will want to pay to play their Steam library online - PC gamers will revolt. I suppose we’re not there yet, but ominous warning signs here.

Re: ROG Xbox Ally Prices Finally Revealed, Pre-Orders Now Live

Cakefish

The regular one is overpriced vs the Steam Deck OLED considering it has the same 4 year old APU. At least the X offers tangible performance improvements so can better justify the price differential.

Either way it’s not for me as my Switch 2 is my current handheld and I only need the one as I don’t travel all that often. I’ll keep an eye on the eventual Steam Deck 2 and Xbox Ally X2 as those should be a generational leap over Switch 2.

Re: Borderlands 4 Comparison Shows Difference Between Xbox Series X And Series S

Cakefish

@Nintendo4Sonic that was the original point behind Series S SOC design. It’s a lot easier to scale for GPU performance than CPU performance, optimising for the latter results in more fundamental changes to game design. So the idea was that with XSS having a very similar CPU to XSX it’d be able to keep up with XSX frame rate wise, just rendering the graphics at lower resolutions to account for the weaker GPU. That just never ended up happening as many games lack 60fps modes on XSS. The original vision for the console failed to materialise.

Re: Opinion: Far Cry Should Double Down On What Made It Great, Not Become Another Live Service

Cakefish

I actually liked 6 more than 5. I found having a voiced protagonist really helped the story and narrative. A silent protagonist just felt a bit off in 5 as all the characters just monologue at you relentlessly and it’s a bit weird. That’s just my opinion though.

I absolutely agree though that the series should stay true to its roots and not morph into a live service abomination!

Re: Borderlands 4 Comparison Shows Difference Between Xbox Series X And Series S

Cakefish

Oof another 30fps game on XSS? The whole point of XSS having such a similar CPU to XSX was to have framerate parity at lower resolutions, but that’s increasingly not been the case as the years have rolled on. I wonder where things went wrong exactly? Memory bandwidth I guess? Just a bit of a shame XSS never lived up to Microsoft’s original vision for the console. At least the hardware engineers can take notes for the next generation.