Comments 1,313

Re: Xbox Reporter Addresses Game Pass Confusion, Says It's Still A Profitable Service In 2025

Cakefish

@BacklogBrad I was going to say something very similar (to your first comment). If Game Pass weren’t profitable then it wouldn’t have survived for this long in its current form. It really is as simple as that I think. Xbox is no charity.

Microsoft have no qualms shutting down studios, making employees redundant, cancelling games, raising prices of hardware and games all in the name of the sacred profit margin. They are cutthroat. I don’t see why Game Pass would be an exception to this rule.

Re: Poll: Helldivers 2 Isn't On Xbox Game Pass, So Will You Be Buying It?

Cakefish

Maybe! Depends if there’s interest from my brothers firstly, as it’s co-op game so it’s not just my decision alone.

The late August timing is problematic for me personally though as I’ll be away from Xbox for much of September. By the time I get back Borderlands 4 will be out and if that reviews well we’re likely to prioritise it. Then Little Nightmares 3 comes out not long after as another co-op game on our radar.

Re: Xbox Founding Member 'Not Pleased' With State Of The Brand In 2025

Cakefish

I’ll reserve judgement until after tomorrow’s mass layoff and studio closure announcement that is rumoured to happen. Actions speak far louder than words. That’s when we will know what Xbox truly values. Do they value high quality games like Psychonauts 2 or do they value annualised, micro-transaction infested slop? Let’s see. Double Fine is the canary in the coal mine. If they die, then it signals that Xbox are set on a dark path. Psychonauts 2 is my favourite first party XSX game and Keeper is easily the most interesting Xbox release in all of 2025. Don’t you dare harm Double Fine!

Re: Talking Point: What's Your Xbox Game Of The Year For 2025 So Far?

Cakefish

Split Fiction, easily.

The only other 2025 game I’ve played on Xbox this year is South of Midnight. It was alright, fairly decent, but couldn’t hold a candle to the co-op masterpiece that is Split Fiction.

My overall 2025 GOTY will very likely end up being a toss-up between Split Fiction and Metroid Prime 4.

Re: Talking Point: What Do You Want To See From Xbox In The Second Half Of The Year?

Cakefish

1) Do not close any talented studios via mass layoffs. Hands off Double Fine!

2) Zero Game Pass price rises or messing about with the Core to Ultimate conversion offer. That would be appreciated.

3) No nerfing of Microsoft Rewards points. It’s already not as good as it was in its prime, let’s not degrade it any further.

4) I want to see more OS updates that focus on QOL additions to the home screen, dashboard, store, games & apps etc. Don’t stay still, keep improving the Xbox OS. I hope Xbox Ally doesn’t consume all of their focus, leaving XSX forgotten and unloved.

That’s about it I suppose, I’m not being too demanding here I feel.

Re: Xbox Play Anywhere Is Growing Massively In 2025, And There's A Lot More To Come

Cakefish

@Isolte can’t argue against those points because I agree, but I think that’s exactly why they are working on this controller-friendly UI on the Xbox Ally. That’s the first step, I think that handheld is being used as a testing ground. It’s basically copying Valve’s Steam OS, which isn’t a bad idea in my opinion because everybody and their dog raves about how good Steam OS is.

Re: Imminent Xbox Layoffs Could Include Entire Studios, Warns Industry Veteran

Cakefish

@Fiendish-Beaver you’re right, you’re absolutely right. Though I still reserve the right to be angry at Phil if he dares touch my precious Double Fine. Of all the studios, the one that delivered the narrative platforming masterpiece that is Psychonauts 2 must be spared. There is so much incredible talent in that studio. Keeper better not be their swang song!

Re: Here's Your First Look At Steam Games On The Xbox PC App

Cakefish

So when you try to access the in-game UI does it default to Xbox or Steam? I presume Xbox. Is it possible to access the Steam in-game UI via controller though?

These will be relevant not only for the Xbox Ally but also the next home Xbox (yes I’m still a believer! 😅)

Re: Imminent Xbox Layoffs Could Include Entire Studios, Warns Industry Veteran

Cakefish

@Fiendish-Beaver nah Phil can’t get off the hook that easily. As far as I know Microsoft is not run like an absolute monarchy, I doubt Satya is micromanaging Xbox to the extent where he’s dictating exactly which studios will get culled. Those decisions will be on Phil and his executive team’s shoulders.

I can only hope the fact Double Fine announced their new game just a couple weeks ago means that they are safe.

How sad that we are even discussing this when Microsoft have been boasting of record-breaking Xbox revenue in their last quarterly report.

Re: Xbox Officially Adds Steam Integration Via New PC App Feature

Cakefish

@NishimuraX thing is though if they wanted to do a Sega, why not now? Why commit to a whole extra generation of hardware that’s doomed to be a Wii U level disaster? I don’t see the logic there. I think that they do definitely want to transition away from traditional consoles in favour of PC, but in a way that retains as much of their existing customer base as possible.

@TheGameThrifter Oh I agree that cloud streaming absolutely wouldn’t count as backwards compatibility as far as I’m concerned either. It needs to be running on local hardware for sure. I think they have given up on console honestly, but as long as the real deal offline backwards compatibility is in place then I personally don’t have an issue with this.

Re: Xbox Officially Adds Steam Integration Via New PC App Feature

Cakefish

@TheGameThrifter I think that Xbox is moving entirely to being an open platform, based on Windows. I think XSX is the last of the traditional closed platform consoles. Backwards compatibility has been confirmed by Microsoft already, thankfully.

@NishimuraX I don’t see how a traditional XSX2 can be viable in the current market. We’ve all seen the sales figures for XSX|S over the past few years, and they really aren’t pretty. I don’t see how XSX2 can avoid repeating the fate of the Wii U if it just attempts to offer more of the same. I think Microsoft needs to do something truly radical for Xbox to survive. I also think it’s telling that although these rumours have been circulating for many months now, Microsoft have made absolutely no attempt whatsoever to dampen the flames.

Re: Here's What's Included In The Xbox June 2025 Update

Cakefish

It’s a bit disappointing they never gave the option to centre-align the tiles if you choose to reduce the number of them on the Home Screen. They look a bit odd clustered up on the left hand side, it creates an unbalanced aesthetic. As it currently is implemented I don’t think l I’ll use that feature. Hopefully they’ll give some more options in future.

Re: Xbox Officially Adds Steam Integration Via New PC App Feature

Cakefish

If this isn’t evidence of Steam on next Xbox I don’t know what is 👀

I think the strategy is to piggyback off Valve’s success. It’s a way to conveniently advertise Game Pass to Steam users.

If you can’t beat them, join them. That sort of thinking.

Yeah I did just copy-paste my comment on the other article here, but it’s definitely relevant here too! 😅

Re: Here's What's Included In The Xbox June 2025 Update

Cakefish

If this isn’t evidence of Steam on next Xbox I don’t know what is 👀

I think the strategy is to piggyback off Valve’s success. It’s a way to conveniently advertise Game Pass to Steam users.

If you can’t beat them, join them. That sort of thinking.

Re: Xbox Data Shows 'Most' Console Owners Are Playing On Other Devices As Well, Says Exec

Cakefish

Chicken and egg situation really. Microsoft has been actively encouraging this for years now. It’s not surprising to see the numbers play out when converting console gamers into windows PC gamers appears to have been their long term strategy all along.

I have both XSX and PC. I wholeheartedly welcome the upcoming merger of these two platforms. Best of both worlds: Steam, free online play, controller-friendly UI, and Quick Resume. Sounds wonderful to me.

Re: Talking Point: Have This Month's Announcements Made You Excited About Xbox Again?

Cakefish

@NishimuraX Yes I guess I am trying to will it into existence! I’ve been very critical and negative on the direction that Xbox has been heading in over the past year and a half. I’m aware that some of the community here have found that grating. Now that I finally have reason to be positive about the brand again it feels so good!

@Titntin like you I already have a PC, but I think this is perfect for me. This would allow me to access my Steam library on my TV via a controller-friendly interface. Play Anywhere theoretically already provides this kind of functionality, but in reality it really doesn’t because only 5-10% of the Xbox library supports it (it also doesn’t do anything for all the games that skip Xbox).