Comments 1,313

Re: Xbox Exec Explains Why Some Games Are 'Day One' For PS5, And Others Aren't

Cakefish

@IOI @Fiendish-Beaver @PsBoxSwitchOwner 100% agreed. I don’t see how it’s possible to interpret this in any other way when stacked on top of all the other previous statements they’ve made and of course the Fable/Halo day one confirmations etc. The moment they said Halo was a day-and-date PlayStation franchise from now on, any lingering ambiguity died for me personally. The evidence is simply overwhelming at this point.

Re: These Are The 10 Highest-Rated Original Xbox Games Of All Time, But Do You Agree?

Cakefish

@FraserG yeah I just looked it up myself! I agree with the high metascore. The game has aged like fine wine too, maybe partly because rail shooter is a dead genre these days so nothing has superseded it (a bittersweet thought). The cutting edge graphics, timeless art design, and wonderful music also play a huge role in the graceful ageing of the game. It was the very first game I ever bought for my XSX in fact! I wish Sega would bring PD back from the dead.

Re: Happy New Year!

Cakefish

Thank you for being a great resource for Xbox news/reviews/opinion pieces. Plenty of interesting things happening this year!

Re: Poll: How Many Xbox Games Have You Actually Bought In 2025?

Cakefish

@Fiendish-Beaver haha you’re welcome! I really enjoyed the first game too, it seemed perfect for a sequel as there were definitely a few areas they could improve further and I thought the formula had so much potential. Hopefully they don’t cancel our preorders, but the pricing has been that way for literally months now, so they clearly aren’t paying close attention! Just don’t spread the word too far and wide 🤐😉

Merry Christmas btw!

Re: Poll: How Many Xbox Games Have You Actually Bought In 2025?

Cakefish

8 in total (if we’re counting DLC separately, 7 if not). This year I purchased:

  • Split Fiction
  • Lies Of P
  • Pumpkin Jack
  • Lies Of P: Overture
  • Code Vein 2
  • Little Nightmares 3
  • Once Upon A Katamari
  • Borderlands 4

The reason I preordered Code Vein 2 so early is because there’s a pricing error on the Microsoft Store where the Deluxe Edition is being sold for Standard Edition pricing. £20 cheaper than other platforms. Don’t tell Bandai Namco 🤫

Re: Talking Point: Which Xbox Games Deserved More Love This Year?

Cakefish

I think Split Fiction suffered from not having the novelty factor that It Takes Two benefitted from. Additionally it got quickly overshadowed by the Clair Obscur hype train.

Then when it later launched on Switch 2 it was overshadowed by Mario Kart World, Cyberpunk 2077, and Donkey Kong Bananza.

Re: Talking Point: What Games Are You Playing Over Christmas Break?

Cakefish

Switch 2 games mostly. I’m finishing up Kirby & the Forgotten Land and then will move onto Metroid Prime 4.

I could bring my Xbox with me too when I travel, but honestly there’s not much I’m currently playing there right now so not really worth the hassle.

I still need to finish Once Upon A Katamari, but otherwise I’m just waiting for Code Vein 2, which I’ve already preordered — pretty darn excited for that one!

Re: Talking Point: How Much Time Have You Spent Gaming On Xbox Consoles This Year?

Cakefish

On PC I played: God of War Ragnarok, Horizon Zero Dawn Remastered (& Frozen Wilds), Horizon Forbidden West (& Burning Shores), REPO, PEAK, and Keeper.

On Xbox I played: Nier Automata (until the ‘real’ ending), Split Fiction (three times over), South of Midnight, Pumpkin Jack, Lies of P Overture, Little Nightmares 3, Borderlands 4 and a little bit of Once Upon A Katamari (but haven’t finished it yet).

On Switch 2 I played: Sonic x Shadow Generations, Kirby & the Forgotten Land (still need to finish the epilogue), and I intend to play Metroid Prime 4 over Christmas break.

So majority Xbox; maybe 50-60% in terms of playtime? PC maybe 35-45% ish? Switch 2 probably 5-10%.

Re: Xbox Celebrates 'Incredible' 2025 And Thanks The Fans In End Of Year Message

Cakefish

Mixed bag year honestly

On the one hand; hardware cost increases way beyond the competition - boo! Also massive Game Pass price hike - boo!

On the other hand; the first party output was fairly decent overall (especially Keeper) and third party additions to Game Pass were pretty good too.

I feel 2026 needs to be better overall though. Less of the bad, more of the good please.