I would have thought Indiana Jones would have been eligible last year but not this year? It came out early December 2024, right? If it's eligible, it should have been nominated for GOTY IMO.
Total travesty that South of Midnight wasn't nominated for it's art and/or music.
I walked away early from Clair Obscur, I couldn't get behind the combat or the world/environments. I keep saying that maybe I'll go back and revisit, especially after the last update, but the backlog is just too large at the moment.
Keeper was very cool experience for me. Definitely not GOTY; but perhaps something for it's art direction?
Blue Prince should win the Indie Award, even if it's up against Clair Obscur. It stands for everything Indie, it's extremely unique, and it's well designed. I couldn't stop playing this game even when I was frustrated and not feeling like I was getting anywhere.
One of my favs from this past year! It's probably not a "game of the year" for me, but boy was the art, story, world, characters, and music great! The only thing I didn't think was great, was the combat/action. That got a bit repetitive by the end of the game.
I also just finished Keeper. Great art and interesting story. At one point early in the game, I questioned what I was playing, but it did quietly suck me in and keep me wanting to play up to the end. It's a cool experience.
I'll give both Banishers and Marvel a try while I still have Ultimate. I'll admit it, I never even heard of Banishers. Marvel Cosmic Invaders, I saw the trailer when that got announced; and I've been keeping up with the news of characters in the game. I don't think I'd buy either, but trying them while I still have an active Ultimate sub is a "must".
I'm at Ultimate until at least April. I'm disappointed with the price hike....but I'm also still very happy with the product. We'll see what the library and future release window looks like come April. Perhaps I'll go back to just buying single games when they go on sale. Maybe I'll take a look and see there's still value. For now, I'm really enjoying the subscription. I've gamed more in 2025 than I have in since the early days of the Switch.
I may move forward with Ultimate by jumping in month by month. I already do this with many of the streaming platforms. If I don't see any content I'm interested in coming out, I discontinue them until I'm interested again or have more time. I might end up doing that with Ultimate.
I'm finally playing the first game currently. I don't know why I waited. Even after seeing that 2 was coming out, I had months to complete the first game! Nope! I just started last week.
I think I'm probably about 40% done. I'll be late to the party once again! I may even need a break between the two.
I'm in the minority on this for sure! I gave Clair Obscura a try but I couldn't get into it. I enjoyed the story but I found the world to be not my style and the actual gameplay/combat was also not for me. I struggled through play sessions until I finally admitted that I didn't care for it despite all the accolades and others claiming GOTY.
I played completely through South of Midnight and I enjoyed if for the most part. The style, world, and story, were incredible. I thought the gameplay was okayish. I really like this game, but I question if it should even be nominated for GOTY.
I'm currently playing Blue Prince. I really like this game. I don't feel like I'm getting anywhere though.....but I want to keep trying. It's very unique, as I've never played a game like this before. I won't claim it as GOTY until I complete it or move on.
I'm not sure what to pick this year. I don't own a Switch 2 so I haven't played Donkey Kong and I'll probably not own one before Metroid releases.
Last year I would have said Balatro or Indiana Jones for sure.
I'm probably the only person to vote for Kinect Party. I know it's not really even a game, but my kids loved that one and I have so many great memories because of that game.
It's sad. I've gamed more this year than I have in the past 5-6 years, and I credit that to Xbox Game Pass Ultimate. I thought the service provided great value, but at an additional $10 a month, I don't know if I'll continue past when it's time to renew.
I think the content in future EA games will not be effected by this the way people think. This isn't the first time investors from that region have backed gaming companies and in those situations, they have not interfered with the day to day or what those companies have produced. In my opinion, I think there are many positives from EA going private. When a company is publicly traded, the best decisions aren't always made in order to keep the shareholders happy.
I finished the game 100%. I'm not sure about the DLC. That was my favorite game I've played over the last 12 months. I enjoyed it from beginning to end. There's just waaaaay too many games that I want to play so I'm on the fence about diving back into any game that I completed.
Anytime you hear about a game going always, no matter if it's an original, sequel, or remake, it sucks; but I would prefer that recourses be geared towards the sequel if it were up to me.
I don't think it needs to be limited editions that are crazy different. What about just different colored systems or with designs based on some of the Xbox owned games? Keep it simple, but mix it up.
Personally I'm not double dipping on any systems, no matter how cool they look.....but when I'm buying a new system, and if one exist, I would most certainly at least think about it.
I think the price point also determines whether or not I'm buying.
I gave this a go but couldn't get into it. The story was cool but the combat portion wasn't fun IMO. Having a retry option maybe would have kept me playing. Maybe I'll go back for a another try but not anytime soon.
Personally I feel Moon has created unnecessary drama with this announcement. Why not just say the Xbox version has been delayed or we're working through something with Xbox. I think the original statement they released is confusing and created negativity.
The game looks awesome. It's on my radar. Ultimately it depends if it's on a platform that I have access to.
When I clicked on the link for 3 months of ultimate for $49, it showed up as the normal price of $59. I'm assuming Amazon has already closed this sale.
I personally really enjoy Xbox at the moment. It's been great on my Series X and our PC. Game Pass is really good value.
I think the writing is on the wall about the future of the brand's hardware. But I'm gaming in the "now". I'm currently enjoying the system and games. Who knows what system or service I'll be gaming on 3+ years from now. It doesn't mean I'm happy with this direction, but I am really enjoying the current run of awesome games they're putting out.
I was about halfway through the campaign on Ultimate Edition when they announced this. I decided to put a pin in that session and wait for reloaded to come out.
I agree with other's post above, they need to do this with 2 & 3, specifically 2. Gear 2 was the reason I purchased a 360!
I love achievements, but not achievement hunting. When I'm playing games I'm really enjoying and planning on finishing, I really do try to lock down as many as I can, but I also don't get too stressed if I miss some either.
I'm not planning on purchasing games on this list, just to boost my score. I'd rather my money go somewhere else.
I just started this game last night. I made it through the prologue and stopped after the cut scene at the beginning of Act 1. I'm playing on Expedition difficulty but I'll admit that timing the dodge and parry has been a struggle for me. Story seems cool so far.
I'm now a couple more chapters into South of Midnight and I have an update in regard to my placement of South of Midnight not being as good as Indy. I still think Indy is a better game, but South of Midnight is closing he game a little. The story is good and the world they are building in South of Midnight is very unique and fresh! I'm loving it.....just not as much as I enjoyed Indy.
Even if I started that game the day it dropped on gamepass, there's absolutely no chance that I would have been able to finish it in that time period. Add in the fact that there's so many quality games competing for gamer's attention, that low number doesn't surprise me at all.
Personally, I'm much more likely to start Avowed, Clair, or Doom first.
I just recently finished Indy and immediately started South of Midnight. I'm only about 4-5 chapters into South of Midnight but from what I've played, I prefer Indiana Jones overall. I am really enjoying the story and style of South of Midnight, but in my opinion, the controls and camera are not near as good as Indy. I'm excited to get to Avowed, Doom, and Elder at some point.
I've owned most Nintendo Systems throughout the years. I will continue that with the Switch 2. But it will not be on day one. I can't justify the purchase right now with the backlog of games I have on PC/Xbox/Switch.
I've owned systems from many companies, I tend to keep coming back to Xbox and Nintendo. Personally, gamepass is awesome! I do probably 75% on Series X and the other 25% on PC; but primarily it's just games on gamepass.
I had gamepass last year for a couple months for the PC. It was okay at the time but we found ourselves playing the same basic games that were cheaper to straight up buy.
We got a Xbox in December and we've subscribed to Ultimate since then. All I can say is that it's been A++ since then. However, if I had to pick the strongest month, I would agree that it's probably been April.
Is there a better subscription than Gamepass at the moment? I have no regrets spending my hard earned money on Ultimate.
I'm guessing I'm about halfway through Indiana Jones. Next up is South of Midnight. Then it's going to come down to Clair, Oblivion, or one of the many other banger titles on the service. Doom is right around the corner!
Comments 80
Re: Vampire Crawlers Is A Survivors Spin-Off, And It's Set For Xbox Game Pass In 2026
Very interested in this. I can't wait to see this world in a different genre. I'm still playing Survivors.
Re: Dave The Diver Finally Announced For Xbox, And It's Splash-Landing Today!
I love Dave the Diver! I doubt that I'll double dip, but I strongly recommend this game.
Re: Two Xbox Game Pass Titles Nominated For GOTY At The Game Awards, But Microsoft Misses Out
I would have thought Indiana Jones would have been eligible last year but not this year? It came out early December 2024, right? If it's eligible, it should have been nominated for GOTY IMO.
Total travesty that South of Midnight wasn't nominated for it's art and/or music.
I walked away early from Clair Obscur, I couldn't get behind the combat or the world/environments. I keep saying that maybe I'll go back and revisit, especially after the last update, but the backlog is just too large at the moment.
Keeper was very cool experience for me. Definitely not GOTY; but perhaps something for it's art direction?
Blue Prince should win the Indie Award, even if it's up against Clair Obscur. It stands for everything Indie, it's extremely unique, and it's well designed. I couldn't stop playing this game even when I was frustrated and not feeling like I was getting anywhere.
Re: This Xbox Game Studios Adventure Deserved More Nominations At The Game Awards 2025
@Cikajovazmaj I think your post is perfect! That's my feelings about it too.
Re: This Xbox Game Studios Adventure Deserved More Nominations At The Game Awards 2025
One of my favs from this past year! It's probably not a "game of the year" for me, but boy was the art, story, world, characters, and music great! The only thing I didn't think was great, was the combat/action. That got a bit repetitive by the end of the game.
I also just finished Keeper. Great art and interesting story. At one point early in the game, I questioned what I was playing, but it did quietly suck me in and keep me wanting to play up to the end. It's a cool experience.
Re: Marvel Cosmic Invasion Is Suddenly A 'Day One' Xbox Game Pass Title, Arriving In December
I'll be downloading this for sure.
Re: These Nine Games Are Coming To Xbox Game Pass (November 19 - December 2)
I'll give both Banishers and Marvel a try while I still have Ultimate. I'll admit it, I never even heard of Banishers. Marvel Cosmic Invaders, I saw the trailer when that got announced; and I've been keeping up with the news of characters in the game. I don't think I'd buy either, but trying them while I still have an active Ultimate sub is a "must".
Re: Red Dead Redemption To Receive Free Xbox Series X|S Upgrade This December
@TheOldHunter4K This is a series I've never played. I might finally start with this update.
Re: Poll: Now That The Dust Has Settled, Which Xbox Game Pass Tier Are You Subscribed To?
I'm at Ultimate until at least April. I'm disappointed with the price hike....but I'm also still very happy with the product. We'll see what the library and future release window looks like come April. Perhaps I'll go back to just buying single games when they go on sale. Maybe I'll take a look and see there's still value. For now, I'm really enjoying the subscription. I've gamed more in 2025 than I have in since the early days of the Switch.
I may move forward with Ultimate by jumping in month by month. I already do this with many of the streaming platforms. If I don't see any content I'm interested in coming out, I discontinue them until I'm interested again or have more time. I might end up doing that with Ultimate.
Re: Fallout 4: Anniversary Edition Isn't Getting The Best Reception From Fans Right Now
I love the game but I wouldn't buy this. I would only buy this if I never played it.
I'm sure it'll be a good sell on the Switch 2 for Nintendo fans who never made it to the Wasteland.
Re: Xbox & Bethesda Announce Fallout 4: Anniversary Edition For Next Month
I love Fallout 4. If this comes to gamepass, I'll revisit so I can play through the DLCs.
Re: The Outer Worlds 2: Release Date, Release Times & How To Get Early Access On Xbox
I'm finally playing the first game currently. I don't know why I waited. Even after seeing that 2 was coming out, I had months to complete the first game! Nope! I just started last week.
I think I'm probably about 40% done. I'll be late to the party once again! I may even need a break between the two.
Re: Jurassic World Evolution 3 Roars Its Way To Xbox This October
I thought 2 was a very fun game. I don't know if I'll grab this day 1 but I will check it out at some point.
Re: Talking Point: As We Approach GOTY Season, What's Your Pick As Things Stand?
I'm in the minority on this for sure! I gave Clair Obscura a try but I couldn't get into it. I enjoyed the story but I found the world to be not my style and the actual gameplay/combat was also not for me. I struggled through play sessions until I finally admitted that I didn't care for it despite all the accolades and others claiming GOTY.
I played completely through South of Midnight and I enjoyed if for the most part. The style, world, and story, were incredible. I thought the gameplay was okayish. I really like this game, but I question if it should even be nominated for GOTY.
I'm currently playing Blue Prince. I really like this game. I don't feel like I'm getting anywhere though.....but I want to keep trying. It's very unique, as I've never played a game like this before. I won't claim it as GOTY until I complete it or move on.
I'm not sure what to pick this year. I don't own a Switch 2 so I haven't played Donkey Kong and I'll probably not own one before Metroid releases.
Last year I would have said Balatro or Indiana Jones for sure.
Re: Insomniac's Xbox Exclusive Sunset Overdrive Celebrates Its 11-Year Anniversary This Month
I never played this game but I've been interested. How does it hold up?
Re: Talking Point: How Often Do You Replay Games?
I think Fallout 3, Windwaker, and Gears 1 & 2 are the only games I've ever replayed outside of games from the NES generation.
Re: Indiana Jones And The Great Circle Anniversary Update Brings New Game+ To Xbox
I love the game but I don't think this is enough to make me revisit.
Re: Pick One: Which Is Your Favourite Double Fine Game On Xbox?
I'm probably the only person to vote for Kinect Party. I know it's not really even a game, but my kids loved that one and I have so many great memories because of that game.
Re: Poll: What Are Your Plans For Xbox Game Pass After This Week's News?
It's sad. I've gamed more this year than I have in the past 5-6 years, and I credit that to Xbox Game Pass Ultimate. I thought the service provided great value, but at an additional $10 a month, I don't know if I'll continue past when it's time to renew.
Re: EA To Be Acquired By Consortium Of Investors For $55 Billion USD
Right or wrong, I'll leave for others to discuss.
I think the content in future EA games will not be effected by this the way people think. This isn't the first time investors from that region have backed gaming companies and in those situations, they have not interfered with the day to day or what those companies have produced. In my opinion, I think there are many positives from EA going private. When a company is publicly traded, the best decisions aren't always made in order to keep the shareholders happy.
Re: ROG Xbox Ally Prices Finally Revealed, Pre-Orders Now Live
I'm more likely to pull the trigger on a Switch 2 than I am for this.
.....but that's just me.
I'm extremely happy with my Xbox X, PC, and Game Pass Ultimate.
Re: Alinea Analytics Says Gears Reloaded Is Tracking Well Behind Forza Horizon 5 On PS5
I think this is common sense. I wouldn't have bet on Gears to out perform Forza on PS5.
Now if they put Gears 6 on PS5, that would be a different story maybe.
Re: Talking Point: It's Not On Xbox Game Pass, So Will You Be Buying The Indiana Jones DLC?
I finished the game 100%. I'm not sure about the DLC. That was my favorite game I've played over the last 12 months. I enjoyed it from beginning to end. There's just waaaaay too many games that I want to play so I'm on the fence about diving back into any game that I completed.
Re: Fallout Season 2 Heads To 'Iconic New Vegas Locations' This December
Can't wait! Fallout is one of my favorite video game series.
I thought season 1 was way too short, but awesome.
Re: Report: BioShock Remake Cancelled As Upcoming Sequel Hits Development Troubles
Anytime you hear about a game going always, no matter if it's an original, sequel, or remake, it sucks; but I would prefer that recourses be geared towards the sequel if it were up to me.
Re: Talking Point: Should Xbox Bring Back Limited Edition Consoles?
I don't think it needs to be limited editions that are crazy different. What about just different colored systems or with designs based on some of the Xbox owned games? Keep it simple, but mix it up.
Personally I'm not double dipping on any systems, no matter how cool they look.....but when I'm buying a new system, and if one exist, I would most certainly at least think about it.
I think the price point also determines whether or not I'm buying.
Re: Expedition 33 Update 1.4.0 Now Live On Xbox, Here Are The Patch Notes
I gave this a go but couldn't get into it. The story was cool but the combat portion wasn't fun IMO. Having a retry option maybe would have kept me playing. Maybe I'll go back for a another try but not anytime soon.
Re: No Rest For The Wicked May Skip Xbox 'For The Time Being' Due To 'Current Market Conditions'
Personally I feel Moon has created unnecessary drama with this announcement. Why not just say the Xbox version has been delayed or we're working through something with Xbox. I think the original statement they released is confusing and created negativity.
The game looks awesome. It's on my radar. Ultimately it depends if it's on a platform that I have access to.
Re: Poll: Which Of Xbox's Fall 2025 Games Are You Most Excited About?
I'll pick The Outer World 2 but I'm looking forward to playing COD and Keeper too. I'll wait and see what everyone says about Ninja Gaiden.
Re: Amazon Prime Day 2025 - Best Deals On Xbox Games, SSD Expansion Cards, 4K TVs, Accessories, Game Pass And More
When I clicked on the link for 3 months of ultimate for $49, it showed up as the normal price of $59. I'm assuming Amazon has already closed this sale.
Re: Helldivers 2 Is Officially Releasing For Xbox This August
This one doesn't excite me much, but it's great for those who have been hoping for this on the Xbox.
Re: Xbox Founding Member 'Not Pleased' With State Of The Brand In 2025
I personally really enjoy Xbox at the moment. It's been great on my Series X and our PC. Game Pass is really good value.
I think the writing is on the wall about the future of the brand's hardware. But I'm gaming in the "now". I'm currently enjoying the system and games. Who knows what system or service I'll be gaming on 3+ years from now. It doesn't mean I'm happy with this direction, but I am really enjoying the current run of awesome games they're putting out.
Re: Despite Being Very Familiar, I Can't Wait To Play More Gears Reloaded Later This Year
I was about halfway through the campaign on Ultimate Edition when they announced this. I decided to put a pin in that session and wait for reloaded to come out.
I agree with other's post above, they need to do this with 2 & 3, specifically 2. Gear 2 was the reason I purchased a 360!
Re: Lots Of Xbox Games Have Quietly Received New 1000G Achievements
I love achievements, but not achievement hunting. When I'm playing games I'm really enjoying and planning on finishing, I really do try to lock down as many as I can, but I also don't get too stressed if I miss some either.
I'm not planning on purchasing games on this list, just to boost my score. I'd rather my money go somewhere else.
Re: These Seven Games Are Coming To Xbox Game Pass (July 2-15)
Chicken Horse is awesome fun but I'll stick with that on the Switch.
I can't wait to play TH3+4!
Re: Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 Update '1.3.0' Now Live On Xbox, Here Are The Patch Notes
I just started this game last night. I made it through the prologue and stopped after the cut scene at the beginning of Act 1. I'm playing on Expedition difficulty but I'll admit that timing the dodge and parry has been a struggle for me. Story seems cool so far.
Re: Indiana Jones 'The Order Of Giants' Expansion Whips Onto Xbox In September 2025
I'm interested. I thought the base game was awesome.
Re: Poll: What Were Your Top 5 Reveals At The Xbox Games Showcase 2025?
1. Clockwork
2. The Outer Worlds 2
3. High on life 2
4. Dawnwalker
5. Indy DLC
Re: Roundup: All The Xbox Reveals From The MIX Summer Showcase 2025
Neon Inferno looks really cool.
Re: Xbox Fan Shares & Compares Recent Aggregate Review Scores For First-Party Releases
I'm now a couple more chapters into South of Midnight and I have an update in regard to my placement of South of Midnight not being as good as Indy. I still think Indy is a better game, but South of Midnight is closing he game a little. The story is good and the world they are building in South of Midnight is very unique and fresh! I'm loving it.....just not as much as I enjoyed Indy.
Re: One Month On, Oblivion Remastered Has A Pretty Low Completion Rate On Xbox
Even if I started that game the day it dropped on gamepass, there's absolutely no chance that I would have been able to finish it in that time period. Add in the fact that there's so many quality games competing for gamer's attention, that low number doesn't surprise me at all.
Personally, I'm much more likely to start Avowed, Clair, or Doom first.
Re: Xbox Fan Shares & Compares Recent Aggregate Review Scores For First-Party Releases
I just recently finished Indy and immediately started South of Midnight. I'm only about 4-5 chapters into South of Midnight but from what I've played, I prefer Indiana Jones overall. I am really enjoying the story and style of South of Midnight, but in my opinion, the controls and camera are not near as good as Indy. I'm excited to get to Avowed, Doom, and Elder at some point.
Re: Talking Point: Xbox Fans, How Many Of You Are Buying A Switch 2?
I've owned most Nintendo Systems throughout the years. I will continue that with the Switch 2. But it will not be on day one. I can't justify the purchase right now with the backlog of games I have on PC/Xbox/Switch.
Re: Poll: Which Is Your Favourite Gears Of War Game On Xbox?
Gears 2 & 3 for me! Although the OG, especially the remake, is also really good.
Re: Opinion: If Xbox Is 'Just' A Game Pass Machine, That's Still Enough For Me
I've owned systems from many companies, I tend to keep coming back to Xbox and Nintendo. Personally, gamepass is awesome! I do probably 75% on Series X and the other 25% on PC; but primarily it's just games on gamepass.
Re: Xbox Is Raising The Price Of Consoles, Games And Accessories
So happy I picked up my Series X for a great deal back in November!
Re: Talking Point: Has This Been The Best Month Ever For Xbox Game Pass?
I had gamepass last year for a couple months for the PC. It was okay at the time but we found ourselves playing the same basic games that were cheaper to straight up buy.
We got a Xbox in December and we've subscribed to Ultimate since then. All I can say is that it's been A++ since then. However, if I had to pick the strongest month, I would agree that it's probably been April.
Re: Phasmophobia Passes 3 Million Console Sales, Try It For Free On Xbox
I saw there's no review for it on this site. Can anyone who played this offer an opinion? Thanks in advance!
Re: These Are The Top-Selling Games In The Xbox Spring Sale 2025
The sale is incredible. So many great games on that list.
But for me, the current backlog is too large for me to justify a purchase.
Re: Roundup: Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 Is Getting Incredible Reviews So Far
Is there a better subscription than Gamepass at the moment? I have no regrets spending my hard earned money on Ultimate.
I'm guessing I'm about halfway through Indiana Jones. Next up is South of Midnight. Then it's going to come down to Clair, Oblivion, or one of the many other banger titles on the service. Doom is right around the corner!