Comments 1,487

Re: Talking Point: Do You Think Project Helix Will Support Physical Xbox Games?

Coletrain

No, no disc drive, the PC market has phased it out so at best an attachment for older Xbox games might be sold. I'd be lying if I said I cared, I've bought 2 disc games on XSX in 4.5 years.

I'd love to see them provide an option to digitise old disc purchases, but the logistics of having to prove you own the disc every now and then don't seem worth it

Re: Xbox Series X Gets Major 'Just For You' Discount On The Microsoft Store

Coletrain

@themightyant yes they have to get the UX spot on for Helix to be a success, it's a very tall order! I'm still very, very interested but it's good to know that we will likely have ps6 to fall back on if Helix is somehow a disaster.

Quite a long term view there marketing wise and I agree in that sense, but as a quick, punchy little tagline I do think this one is a winner. I'm seeing XSX digital certified refurbished on my store for £344.99, not sure how well that's being advertised!

Re: Xbox Series X Gets Major 'Just For You' Discount On The Microsoft Store

Coletrain

@Banjo- yeah exactly. And I've said this before, but at the time I was foolishly on board with the "everything is an Xbox" campaign.

In hindsight, I was miles out, and only an actual Xbox and a half decent PC are "Xboxes", everything else was a cloud dependent limitation to the real experience.

I do like cloud, I do like play anywhere, but they're complimentary, not the focus for me

Re: Xbox Series X Gets Major 'Just For You' Discount On The Microsoft Store

Coletrain

@themightyant think about it this way. There was a disastrous marketing campaign that "everything is an Xbox", and now a campaign focussed solely on saying that "THIS (an Xbox) is an Xbox".

It's genius and a step above anything we saw with Sarah Bond at the helm

Edit: I do think she's quickly realised that Helix is dead in the water without a strong Xbox Series user base

Re: Xbox Reveals New Details On 'Project Helix' Next-Gen Console, Says Devs Will Get It In 2027

Coletrain

@Gemini53 re: comment 54. Yes, I'm currently about to start hogwarts legacy for the first time, tried to find the best graphics mode for series X and the DF video from 3 years ago is basically saying none of them. Obviously I'll just try myself and figure it out but I would love them to update on poor performers from launch (and I do enjoy their content in fairness, even if series consoles are getting much less coverage now!)

Re: Xbox Must Live Up To Expectations Of Fans Who Have 'Counted On Us', Says Microsoft Boss

Coletrain

Dear Xbox,

You keep raising the prices on Hardware and Game pass, and nerfing the rewards program. You made V bucks and Ubisoft classics a part of GPU. That's not a very useful move to actual Xbox players.

The things we "expect you to do" you keep doing and we're now used to getting screwed over.

I hope GDC shows everyone a clear direction so that I can go a day without reading that Xbox is dead!

Re: Next Xbox Console Could Be Affected By PlayStation Pulling Back On PC

Coletrain

@PsBoxSwitchOwner I'm not saying that to artificially inflate the number, but seeing as the PC push is for extra sales on PS published titles only that would be the apt comparison. Also, 2% of whatever the revenue is (it's in the billions of dollars, right?) isn't chump change.

Obviously this move is strategic and their prerogative, all I'm highlighting is this 2% of revenue thing is likely quite a decent portion of first party game sales. The way the narrative threads itself online is like Sony 1st party sales on console are massive.

Re: Next Xbox Console Could Be Affected By PlayStation Pulling Back On PC

Coletrain

@themightyant I suppose the most useful metric would be % of PC sales on first party output Vs console sales on first party output. So you know, if revenue of first party games on console is only 6% of total revenue, then 1.5% of total revenue on PC games is pretty good. But if it's much higher then not so good.

We're relying on you for the facts here as you have a decent interest in scrutinising the financials 🤣 which is much appreciated

Re: Next Xbox Console Could Be Affected By PlayStation Pulling Back On PC

Coletrain

@Millionski I agree that the "you don't need an Xbox" was a ridiculous misstep.

Further bleed? Yeah, maybe. Very price dependent of course. As I mentioned I don't think for a second that ps6 won't outsell a nextbox, I was just making points that Sony won't grow any further due to exclusives. If it can grow again, it'll be based on price and Xbox failures (fingers crossed they're not a failure!)

Re: Next Xbox Console Could Be Affected By PlayStation Pulling Back On PC

Coletrain

@DennisReynolds I'm not comparing a ps6 with a next box, it will obviously sell more, it'd be naive to think otherwise. I'm saying the exclusive thing isn't the needle mover given dev costs (and time) unless they improve it.

It's not going to attract new users, just existing ones. All the data and reports have consoles trending down. PS6 isn't magically immune to this.

Re: Next Xbox Console Could Be Affected By PlayStation Pulling Back On PC

Coletrain

@DennisReynolds next gen consoles are going to cost more than this gen, Xbox couldn't possible bleed any more users over to ps5 than they have already; the install base becomes lower by default. Exclusives aren't all going to sell Spiderman numbers. And they're costing more to make. You're looking at 4-5m copies sold at full price to break even on some of these projects.

1st party wise Insomniac and team asobi are the only ones coming up smelling of roses. It's been a weird time this gen for them

Re: Xbox Boss Questioned On Whether Exclusives Could Return In The Future

Coletrain

@Banjo- for sure. To be honest I find the Xbox "exclusives" more interesting to play anyway, they just don't hit that 90 on metacritic to sell the consoles as well as ps5 games do (although I do think some of them are a little overhyped in reviews, like Spiderman 2 looks good but not 90 good)

Give me more stuff like Keeper and South of Midnight and I'm a happy camper