Comments 914

Re: Xbox Officially Adds Steam Integration Via New PC App Feature

Coletrain

@NishimuraX could be. PC gaming and Xbox will both live on either way. I just don't know how a more powerful series X gives Xbox any advantages without a point of differentiation, and this seems to be the only end point that people can see.

Unless online becomes free. That could work too...

Re: Xbox Officially Adds Steam Integration Via New PC App Feature

Coletrain

@NishimuraX have you considered that the pc console could become a possibility? If you think of the handheld PCs right now, a big lump of the cost is in the windows licence, right?

So, if the next console doesn't need a licence, a) because windows made it; and b) because it's running the same OS layer than the new Rog Xbox handhelds will use, so it can be done at cost. Still would expect £700-800, but not a four figure sum, because it could just not bother giving you access to a desktop mode.

It might seem a bit dystopian, but when you think of how carefully worded Sarah Bond's AMD announcement was, it's feasible

Re: ROG Xbox Ally Release Window Verified By Major Outlet, But Questions Remain Over Price

Coletrain

@Kaloudz agree with @Medic_alert the SD is excellent but tops out at 15w, so once a game gets too much for it then you just can't play it. With the ROGs or other handhelds you can typically have up to 25-30w through them (plugged in helps too) which helps massively with performance on more modern titles.

I want to see what this new Xbox app thing does though, because the main draw of steam OS over windows is that games (generally) run using either less power or need less power for the same performance!

Re: ROG Xbox Ally Release Window Verified By Major Outlet, But Questions Remain Over Price

Coletrain

@Kaloudz here's how I think it'll work based on rumoured specs of the chipset:

Indies: great
2D games: excellent
AAA and newer titles: good-ish but at 720p for decent performance and likely running at 25w TDP so maybe 1h30 battery life for them.
Xcloud and remote play: excellent (especially if you do it via Edge and download better xcloud), uses hardly any battery and runs for hours

Re: Final Fantasy 16 Delivers Great FPS But 'Weird' Visuals On Xbox Series X

Coletrain

@PsBoxSwitchOwner no excuses on my part, I'm supporting it. I hope the sales do improve for them, but yeah I fully accept that most huge FF fans probably already have a ps5 for this stuff. I would like to know the port cost though, it's a much easier measure of success/failure and as always it's just going to get spun into a "Xbox players don't buy games" story for a few days

Re: ROG Xbox Ally Gets Price & Release Date Info In 'Exclusive' Report

Coletrain

@Herculean same mate. Just added a Rog ally into the mix coz I needed a new general PC anyway, but the switch comes with me on holidays and the Rog is mostly YouTube and cloud/remote play gaming at home.

I know what point the guy is making, I just wouldn't personally feel comfortable bringing an £800/$900 handheld with me anywhere ha

Re: ROG Xbox Ally Gets Price & Release Date Info In 'Exclusive' Report

Coletrain

@BAMozzy oh ok, well if your point is that it won't be better for Xbox gamers then yeah, of course! But just anecdotally, I played through Mafia definitive edition on the Rog, 900p, 40fps through Radeon chill and 18w so still needed to be plugged in after about 1h15 - the UI and text were tiny, character models look super small, and it just isn't a good way to play those kinds of games IMHO.

Now playing indie titles or emulated stuff, it's a beast. I love that functionality. It just doesn't outdo the switch YET but yeah the new Xbox app layer looks promising for efficiency. My wishlist would be bigger screen and that the z2e chip can run things at 17w comfortably. Big ask though!

Re: ROG Xbox Ally Gets Price & Release Date Info In 'Exclusive' Report

Coletrain

@BAMozzy you're off tangent here for a lot of this. There's no question PC is a better ecosystem than Nintendo (like you said, I certainly wouldn't want to play COD on a switch 2 over a PC or series console), but it's not a better handheld gaming system. They've had to shove an 80wh battery into the ally x (and now Xbox ally x) to get it even close to a respectable battery life.

Here's the hill I'm willing to die on in summary: the switch 2 is doing the same battery life or better with a quarter of the battery size, has a bigger screen, is hyper optimised for small screen gaming and has a better form factor. The Xbox ally in particular doesn't move the needle here (I picked up my Rog ally for £320, so price alone isn't the main factor), as it's just not capable of running new games natively at a satisfying level. The switch 2 is, and it's going to be very selective about it.

Re: ROG Xbox Ally Gets Price & Release Date Info In 'Exclusive' Report

Coletrain

@BAMozzy yeah, again I totally agree with you and everyone else that's commented that the ally is a more open and diverse platform. But it's not a good handheld/portable device. It's heavy, you need to plug it in to get the best of it, and the battery life is bad for newer games in most cases.

I see your argument and for you, a PC handheld is a much better fit, no doubt. But let's not pretend that having open platforms is some kind of boon for the handheld market, I'd still much rather have those storefronts on a plugged in device AKA a gaming PC. For me, Zelda and Mario games have that magic that your typical game just doesn't have. It's crap that it's within a walled garden, but I'd sooner play them than protest against the practice. And they do this in a lightweight form factor that makes actual sense.

I like this kind of discourse, and I hope that the Xbox ally x is everything you want it to be and more mate.

Re: ROG Xbox Ally Gets Price & Release Date Info In 'Exclusive' Report

Coletrain

@BAMozzy that new Xbox app layer could be a game changer, until I see it then I still think switch 2 is a better portable (and I stress portable because you're obviously right about choice, storefronts, free online etc)

I think you have to compare them on a number of factors, and for the price switch 2 will order some special gaming. Do love steam Indies though, there are some real beauties hidden in there