Comments 914

Re: Microsoft Issues Statement Denying Target & Walmart Are Pulling Xbox Products

Coletrain

@Fiendish-Beaver I suppose it depends very much on the feature set. If this console can genuinely run PC code at a TV friendly frame rate, then £800 (WITHOUT online fees for multiplayer) is quite compelling, and I'd wager there's enough gamers in the Xbox/PC market that would be interested in a homogenised PC console.

I wouldn't expect Xbox to be able to pry away people from the playstation fan base because they have their own thing in cinematic, polished games. But they already have probably 60/70 million people using series and xbone consoles regularly, so it's not too much to convert just under half of them.

All this with the usual caveat of whether or not they can deliver and more importantly market the damn thing correctly 🤦

Re: Xbox 'Magnus' Leak Suggests Next Console Will Be Powerful, Expensive & Maybe A Hybrid Device

Coletrain

@OldGamer999 series x is my first Xbox and I fell in love with it very quickly. I actively did not get a ps5 as I was burnt out on the exclusives and wanted to try Forza, halo and gears (now played all halo games, first 3 gears of war games and Forza horizon 4 + 5, all excellent.) The controller fits my hands better as well which was a nice bonus.

But I will have no problem going back to a ps6 if it's purely and simply the better product. You're right, we need to know what MS is planning to make that decision. Until then, every game I could want to play I have access to, with the exception of astro bot(!)

Re: Xbox 'Magnus' Leak Suggests Next Console Will Be Powerful, Expensive & Maybe A Hybrid Device

Coletrain

@OldGamer999 yes I agree, they're leaving the consoles to Sony and Nintendo. They make most of their money from services and software anyway, so I just assume they'll sell hardware at cost instead of subsidised, and sales numbers won't matter. The console wars will be over because it will play everything a pc can, and they'll rake in money hand over fist without their additional 30% cut and not care

Re: AMD's Partnership On PS6 Will Benefit 'Every Gaming Platform', Says General Manager

Coletrain

@Fiendish-Beaver I agree 60fps is enough for me as well. Although I don't think it's about what the eyes can comprehend, higher framerates are more about perceived smoothness and reduced input latency. I'm sure the PC gamers in the forum can attest to this better than I.

This is all buzzwords to me, but my interpretation generally is that more efficient data compression should allow for these higher framerates as standard, because the GPU load is decreased on a scene by scene basis meaning a faster rendering pipeline. Think this is what we all sort of expected from next gen anyway!

Re: ROG Xbox Ally X Continues To Sell Out, While Standard Version Remains More Readily Available

Coletrain

@BAMozzy yeah the ergonomics are actually a huge selling point and will make a massive difference.

This won't matter to you once you've got your new beast (!) but for AAA fare I always use 720p (900p if I can), fsr or rsr if needed and set Radeon image sharpening to 70-80%. Cleans up the image and looks 1080p-like (at least on a small screen, doesn't work on monitor). I find that usually gives me lots of performance headroom within the memory constraints of the device

Re: ROG Xbox Ally X Continues To Sell Out, While Standard Version Remains More Readily Available

Coletrain

@BAMozzy the Xbox ally looks like a nice enough product, but it won't be more power efficient than a z1e device because it's using older architecture (rDNA 2 vs 3). The bigger battery helps, so running an easier game like hollow knight silksong it'll go longer than an OG ally, but anything that requires a higher power envelope just won't be worth running.

If you pop a 65w jsaux battery into the OG Ally z1e that'll be more efficient than Xbox ally in most gaming scenarios

Re: Two Games Are Available Today With Xbox Game Pass (October 7)

Coletrain

@Vandrid I hope they do revisions to the model, but I'm willing to see how the premium tier pans out too. I cancelled ultimate about 2 months ago as I've bought loads of great non-GP games this year and not touched them!

I'm not super interested in day one COD, but it'll be nice to play stuff like Keeper or Avowed at a cheaper tier a few months on

Re: Xbox Issues Statement Denying Rumour That Next-Gen Console Could Be Cancelled

Coletrain

I didn't believe the rumour when I saw it anyway (as DF sometimes say, single source reporting is rarely accurate), but I think what makes people so worried is that Xbox consistently shift focus and strategy to the point where it's hard to feel valued, or that your library of games is safe.

So yes, it's a crap rumour, but the fact that it's so feasible was an issue. I do hope next gen hardware is still happening for them, but the fact it's not an automatic buy for me yet speaks volumes about their messaging

Re: Microsoft Set To Announce 'Free' Xbox Cloud Gaming Tier With Ads

Coletrain

If they want to do an ad supported tier they shouldn't timegate it. They're already getting the ad revenue, no need to limit the user.

I will say (despite my overwhelmingly negative views on Xbox at the moment) that xcloud has been impressive when I've used it this year, in fact most of the services I've used have (including Amazon Luna for fellow Prime members)

Re: Poll: What Are Your Plans For Xbox Game Pass After This Week's News?

Coletrain

I'd already let my sub lapse to play non-GP titles, so my plans haven't changed in that regard. However, it's a massive shame as the way I used GPU was to sub for a month when a cool game came to the service that I could beat in a month. Which means I won't be playing really cool games like Keeper for some time now, until it drops onto Premium.

Honestly, I feel bewildered, angry, and taken for granted as someone who truly loves the Series X as a piece of kit