@CasualGamerFatigue I want to buy them cheaply (which I have), play them without the disc noise and they have play anywhere support for my PC handheld. Do you want me to walk you through why it's not pointless or can you figure it out yourself?
@fatpunkslim sorry, let me be more specific: Xbox cloud gaming has failed. Luna and GeForce now still have their places.
Here is why more subs matter: the content remains the same. Game output doesn't need to be higher than it is in gamepass. So if we double the subscribers and therefore revenue, then Xbox cloud gaming does not need to be subsidised by the user because it is profitable within the collective subscription revenue.
By adding payment options for game pass subscribers (non-subscribers is different and that's a cool addition) you're admitting that the cloud part of your subscription was not profitable as part of the package. Probably because data centres are a joke (that's a whole different topic) when it comes to efficiency.
Everything within any subscription is subsidised by the revenue. In this case, the revenue ain't good enough, chief
@fatpunkslim I'm not talking about profitability, just why cloud gaming has failed enough to need extra payments. I think game pass is likely going to be profitable this financial year.
Remember, cloud wasn't the main draw for most users, it's a benefit, and if sub count was higher it wouldn't need subsidising further by the user
@fatpunkslim none of this is true. Unlimited Cloud gaming on xbox failed because Xbox didn't get anywhere near the subscription numbers they had projected.
The failure of game pass to meet Xbox's expectations is why cloud now needs paid tiers. If they had the 70m subscribers they had projected by now, and the same games they currently have, then this would be a non-issue.
@Echtzeit it's not that it's likely to affect a huge amount of people, it's because it's shrinkflation. Somebody using game pass (whatever tier) is now going to pay the same amount and receive less. There is no perceived positive to be had with this for a consumer, it only benefits Xbox/MS
@cronogold it's £350, it's a poor conversion for me lol! Should be about £260 (in fact, I could just buy it American and have it shipped to England cheaper...)
That statue though...it would look pretty sweet on my desk...
@badboidre Sharma is making the brand desirable again, so let's just ignore that angle because it's not really connected.
It might be easy to say save up for it, but it's a lot easier to pay £17.50 a month than £500-600 in one go and then add the subs and games. Hell, I only got a series X I'm the first place because of Xbox all access, we'd just had our first child and I wasn't about to spend £450 plus games when I didn't need to.
It's not that I don't agree that cloud gaming is fairly bad or pointless, it's that Xbox made this part of their offering and now they want to monetise the benefit further. People with no active GP sub it makes sense as an offering and I think that's cool, but the ones already subbed? Come on
@badboidre the whole point of the Xbox app on fire stick (or TVs that support it) was cloud gaming though. It doesn't matter if you or I think it's a poor way to play games, it makes it an objectively poor deal for those users.
I'll reserve judgement until we see the prices, but yeah, cloud is a cool addition to an Xbox setup but certainly not a great way to play every game.
Probably would have been an idea to keep ultimate unlimited or at 100 hours though, it's the only way someone using a fire stick can interact with it and that marketing campaign wasn't really that long ago
There are so many little steps that Xbox are taking under Asha that are leading to overall positive brand perception. She knows what she's doing this one
I'm playing through Keeper right now. It's absolutely exquisite.
BUT I do agree with the sentiment that they did not a right lot with the time they had. And Kiln was a game that was created in some stoners mind and then shoehorned into a multiplayer template. Never looked worthwhile.
They've got their freedom back now, and I still love them, and they will probably get back to making cool games in a timely manner now that they have to keep the lights on independently
@Titntin push review echoes how I felt when I saw the gameplay deep dive. Serviceable but boring gameplay wrapped in an interesting (ISH) time mechanic.
It's a "wait for sale" for me, but a definite buy at some point. The demo looked and felt amazing. Didn't think the boss was a challenge though, some old Sekiro reflexes must have kicked in 🥷
@Millionski yeah I'm ready for a bigger return to focussed linear titles that don't want 90 hours of my time and take 4 years to make instead of 6. Long games can be fun but gosh there has been so many of them this gen
Perhaps it's time for alternative media forms. Flash drives with the licence key or something similar (lord knows Xbox discs don't hold most full games anyway) would be effective as they just need a USB slot
It's gonna be a locked, smooth AF 30fps on XSX. And it looks incredible. For anyone moaning that it should be 60, give your head a shake as it really doesn't matter when the game is this damn good
@NeutronBomb I wouldn't mind the idea of paying a new one off over 12 months through Argos or Very, but not until I see a meaningful upgrade in efficiency.
Like, the Xbox ally x range looks great, but they're not actually pushing things much harder than the one we've got (they just have comfier handles, which I can buy on eBay!)
I'm just saving up whatever points I earn until a few days before it comes out. Currently enough for a £25 saving. All I do is log onto bing mobile once a day, spend 3 minutes getting points and back to my day. Accumulated 37,000 points since Feb
@Balaam_ you've been able to put points into user selected amounts for a while, but only very recently through the rewards section of the console itself.
I think it's a good PR move, but it's not one that I personally agree with. I prefer to see transparency in sales data.
Then again, I don't make a living by farming for clicks on social media like the insidious people that give it the whole "look how crap Xbox is why even put your games on there" crowd
@fatpunkslim to your really good point number 1, there were some figures last week about how high some physical sales were for select AAA games like requiem, Spiderman 2 etc. and they're much higher in Europe and UK. Albeit these were playstation figures, but it does say to me that physical has a future, even for Xbox
@carlos82 yup, totally agree. The phone model is going to be the prevalent way to buy a Helix. As long as it's interest free then I'm actually happy with that.
@Luigia I'm on the original z1e model with an upgraded battery, I wouldn't say I enjoy everything on a monitor (for example, FF7 rebirth is passable at best!) but I do love anything indie that runs 1080p 60fps natively! Awesome machines though, I would have got an Xbox ally if I'd not got this one 2 years ago
@Dodoo 🤣 no no that's too much like some kind of topless greek god. We might just have to take the long way around and say "got the emerald" instead of "emeralded"
Comments 1,487
Re: Xbox Is Officially Taking Over From PlayStation On Hideo Kojima's New 'PHYSINT' Game
Brilliant, haven't played a Kojima game I didn't love so if this gets rid of PS exclusivity for a Kojima game then it's great news to me
Re: Talking Point: How Many Games Do You Plan To Convert With Xbox Disc To Digital?
@CasualGamerFatigue online discourse is only interesting when speaking with decent people. If you want to argue nonsensically there's reddit
Re: Talking Point: How Many Games Do You Plan To Convert With Xbox Disc To Digital?
@CasualGamerFatigue I want to buy them cheaply (which I have), play them without the disc noise and they have play anywhere support for my PC handheld. Do you want me to walk you through why it's not pointless or can you figure it out yourself?
Re: Talking Point: How Many Games Do You Plan To Convert With Xbox Disc To Digital?
Hogwarts legacy, Metaphor and Starfield for me. But I'll be dipping into CEX whenever I get dragged to town much more often
Re: Xbox Appears To Be Experimenting With Cheaper Game Pass Offers For Ex-Members
I think this would work on me if they chopped it to about £13, but I checked and no such luck 🤣
Re: Final Fantasy Gets New Release Date, Demo & Trilogy Bundle Across Multiple Upcoming Games
@Evilinsane same, really hope that we get another "deal for you" for the new one at about £40, that would be "fair" for me
Re: GTA 6 Extended Preview Causes Xbox Series X|S Sales To Spike In The UK
@Mr-Cage 🤣 if she puts up with Mary Jane you might be onto a winner, not touched Mary since I was 17
Re: GTA 6 Extended Preview Causes Xbox Series X|S Sales To Spike In The UK
@Mr-Cage I only have one rule for her: the kids wear England rugby kits not Ireland 🤣
Otherwise what she says goes 😬
Re: GTA 6 Extended Preview Causes Xbox Series X|S Sales To Spike In The UK
@Mr-Cage my wife is only 1/4 Irish and she gets fiery, I reckon you're knackered when Lucia hits your screen pal
🙏ING for you
Re: Xbox's Latest Cloud Gaming TV Announcement Is Happening At The Most Awkward Time
Haha yeah I thought this was a bit tone deaf when I saw it. Really hope they reverse the decision on GP ultimate cloud hours
Re: Xbox Is Officially Putting Time Limits On Cloud Gaming For Game Pass Members
@fatpunkslim sorry, let me be more specific: Xbox cloud gaming has failed. Luna and GeForce now still have their places.
Here is why more subs matter: the content remains the same. Game output doesn't need to be higher than it is in gamepass. So if we double the subscribers and therefore revenue, then Xbox cloud gaming does not need to be subsidised by the user because it is profitable within the collective subscription revenue.
By adding payment options for game pass subscribers (non-subscribers is different and that's a cool addition) you're admitting that the cloud part of your subscription was not profitable as part of the package. Probably because data centres are a joke (that's a whole different topic) when it comes to efficiency.
Everything within any subscription is subsidised by the revenue. In this case, the revenue ain't good enough, chief
Re: Xbox Is Officially Putting Time Limits On Cloud Gaming For Game Pass Members
@fatpunkslim I'm not talking about profitability, just why cloud gaming has failed enough to need extra payments. I think game pass is likely going to be profitable this financial year.
Remember, cloud wasn't the main draw for most users, it's a benefit, and if sub count was higher it wouldn't need subsidising further by the user
Re: Xbox Is Officially Putting Time Limits On Cloud Gaming For Game Pass Members
@fatpunkslim none of this is true. Unlimited Cloud gaming on xbox failed because Xbox didn't get anywhere near the subscription numbers they had projected.
The failure of game pass to meet Xbox's expectations is why cloud now needs paid tiers. If they had the 70m subscribers they had projected by now, and the same games they currently have, then this would be a non-issue.
Re: Xbox Is Officially Putting Time Limits On Cloud Gaming For Game Pass Members
@Echtzeit it's not that it's likely to affect a huge amount of people, it's because it's shrinkflation. Somebody using game pass (whatever tier) is now going to pay the same amount and receive less. There is no perceived positive to be had with this for a consumer, it only benefits Xbox/MS
Re: Final Fantasy Gets New Release Date, Demo & Trilogy Bundle Across Multiple Upcoming Games
@cronogold it's £350, it's a poor conversion for me lol! Should be about £260 (in fact, I could just buy it American and have it shipped to England cheaper...)
That statue though...it would look pretty sweet on my desk...
Re: Xbox Is Officially Putting Time Limits On Cloud Gaming For Game Pass Members
@strzelec oh right, you just wanted to console war. Good luck with that.
Re: Xbox Is Officially Putting Time Limits On Cloud Gaming For Game Pass Members
@badboidre Sharma is making the brand desirable again, so let's just ignore that angle because it's not really connected.
It might be easy to say save up for it, but it's a lot easier to pay £17.50 a month than £500-600 in one go and then add the subs and games. Hell, I only got a series X I'm the first place because of Xbox all access, we'd just had our first child and I wasn't about to spend £450 plus games when I didn't need to.
It's not that I don't agree that cloud gaming is fairly bad or pointless, it's that Xbox made this part of their offering and now they want to monetise the benefit further. People with no active GP sub it makes sense as an offering and I think that's cool, but the ones already subbed? Come on
Re: Xbox Is Officially Putting Time Limits On Cloud Gaming For Game Pass Members
@strzelec I have a series x, I'm good, I'm just not seeing the positive angle on this news like you are...
Re: Xbox Is Officially Putting Time Limits On Cloud Gaming For Game Pass Members
@badboidre the whole point of the Xbox app on fire stick (or TVs that support it) was cloud gaming though. It doesn't matter if you or I think it's a poor way to play games, it makes it an objectively poor deal for those users.
Re: Xbox Is Officially Putting Time Limits On Cloud Gaming For Game Pass Members
I'll reserve judgement until we see the prices, but yeah, cloud is a cool addition to an Xbox setup but certainly not a great way to play every game.
Probably would have been an idea to keep ultimate unlimited or at 100 hours though, it's the only way someone using a fire stick can interact with it and that marketing campaign wasn't really that long ago
Re: Final Fantasy Gets New Release Date, Demo & Trilogy Bundle Across Multiple Upcoming Games
Can't believe it, I've already spent £65 on ff7 remake and rebirth and I could have had the whole lot for £80 😭
Re: 'Your Transparency Is Remarkable' - Xbox Fans Are Loving The New Insight Into Server Outages
There are so many little steps that Xbox are taking under Asha that are leading to overall positive brand perception. She knows what she's doing this one
Re: Fable Encourages You To Make The Game As Easy Or As Difficult As You Like
@Balaam_ for probably the first time, I 100% agree. Difficulty related achievements are good for short campaigns only, or the dustbin.
Sony actually does this commendably with their 1st party stuff nowadays, the platinums are the right amount of challenge and time.
Re: 'We Aren't Joking' - Double Fine Promises Brütal Legend 2 If They Can Fundraise Enough Money
I'm playing through Keeper right now. It's absolutely exquisite.
BUT I do agree with the sentiment that they did not a right lot with the time they had. And Kiln was a game that was created in some stoners mind and then shoehorned into a multiplayer template. Never looked worthwhile.
They've got their freedom back now, and I still love them, and they will probably get back to making cool games in a timely manner now that they have to keep the lights on independently
Re: Roundup: Here's What The Critics Are Saying About The Blood Of Dawnwalker
@Titntin push review echoes how I felt when I saw the gameplay deep dive. Serviceable but boring gameplay wrapped in an interesting (ISH) time mechanic.
Re: Roundup: The First Reviews Have Dropped For Onimusha: Way Of The Sword, And They're Very Good
It's a "wait for sale" for me, but a definite buy at some point. The demo looked and felt amazing. Didn't think the boss was a challenge though, some old Sekiro reflexes must have kicked in 🥷
Re: State Of Decay 3 Confirms New Release Window & Closed Beta Plans
@Millionski yeah I'm ready for a bigger return to focussed linear titles that don't want 90 hours of my time and take 4 years to make instead of 6. Long games can be fun but gosh there has been so many of them this gen
Re: 'The Entire Supply Chain Is Collapsing' - Xbox Disc Drive Situation Gets More Awkward
Perhaps it's time for alternative media forms. Flash drives with the licence key or something similar (lord knows Xbox discs don't hold most full games anyway) would be effective as they just need a USB slot
Re: Three Xbox-Specific Takeaways From The GTA 6 Extended Preview
@LostInBlue0 it's like Hell blade 2 levels of fidelity but a massive world, I was blown away!
Re: Three Xbox-Specific Takeaways From The GTA 6 Extended Preview
It's gonna be a locked, smooth AF 30fps on XSX. And it looks incredible. For anyone moaning that it should be 60, give your head a shake as it really doesn't matter when the game is this damn good
Re: GTA 6 Dev Hints At Lengthy 80-Hour Runtime, But With A Potential Catch Or Two
GTA 5 was like an 80 hour game for me. You live in these worlds, not rush the story. The longer the better.
Re: ROG Xbox Ally X20 Pre-Orders Go Live Today, Release Date & Prices Revealed
@NeutronBomb I wouldn't mind the idea of paying a new one off over 12 months through Argos or Very, but not until I see a meaningful upgrade in efficiency.
Like, the Xbox ally x range looks great, but they're not actually pushing things much harder than the one we've got (they just have comfier handles, which I can buy on eBay!)
Re: Asha Sharma Says 'Efficiency' And 'Affordability' Are Top Of Mind For Xbox Project Helix
It's definitely going to be finance options; as long as they're interest free then dammit, I'm in
Re: Xbox Disc To Digital Announced, Supports Thousands Of Physical Games At Launch
Ahhh my £15 metaphor refantazio physical purchase worked out 🤣
Re: ROG Xbox Ally X20 Pre-Orders Go Live Today, Release Date & Prices Revealed
Currently hugging my z1e Rog ally that I paid £320 for...what has the world come to
Re: I'm Halfway Towards Getting GTA 6 For Free On Xbox, But I've Run Into Some Issues
I'm just saving up whatever points I earn until a few days before it comes out. Currently enough for a £25 saving. All I do is log onto bing mobile once a day, spend 3 minutes getting points and back to my day. Accumulated 37,000 points since Feb
Re: Two Former Xbox Studios Confirm Their Independence And Plans For The Future
I'll always love and keep playing double fine games. I'm happy they're independent again.
Re: I'm Halfway Towards Getting GTA 6 For Free On Xbox, But I've Run Into Some Issues
@Balaam_ you've been able to put points into user selected amounts for a while, but only very recently through the rewards section of the console itself.
Re: The Blood Of Dawnwalker Has Two Performance Modes On Xbox Series X, But No 60FPS
I won't be buying it but not performance related. I watched the gameplay stuff on YouTube and it looks so boring.
Re: Xbox Has Reportedly Pulled Out Of Sharing Digital Sales Data With Circana
I think it's a good PR move, but it's not one that I personally agree with. I prefer to see transparency in sales data.
Then again, I don't make a living by farming for clicks on social media like the insidious people that give it the whole "look how crap Xbox is why even put your games on there" crowd
Re: Xbox Reportedly Makes Up Less Than 5% Of US Physical Sales In 2026
@fatpunkslim to your really good point number 1, there were some figures last week about how high some physical sales were for select AAA games like requiem, Spiderman 2 etc. and they're much higher in Europe and UK. Albeit these were playstation figures, but it does say to me that physical has a future, even for Xbox
Re: 'Nightmare Scenario' - GTA 6 Fans Fear The Worst As Leaks Become Far More Serious
Looking forward to putting my details into Rockstar Social Club when the multiplayer element launches, they seem really tight with online security
Re: Three Methods Could Keep Xbox Project Helix Under $1,000, Suggests Analysis
@carlos82 yup, totally agree. The phone model is going to be the prevalent way to buy a Helix. As long as it's interest free then I'm actually happy with that.
Re: Talking Point: Would You Buy A New Version Of The Simpsons: Hit & Run For Xbox Series X|S?
I never played it, to my shame 😓 but yes would buy just to see what the hype was about
Re: Kingdom Hearts IV Joins Xbox Play Anywhere, Along With Multiple Other Surprises
@Banjo- hope so man. I want to replay 1 & 2 on handheld but sort of have the option on the SX too
Re: Talking Point: Amid Rising Console Prices, What Would You Do If Your Xbox Broke Tomorrow?
@Luigia I'm on the original z1e model with an upgraded battery, I wouldn't say I enjoy everything on a monitor (for example, FF7 rebirth is passable at best!) but I do love anything indie that runs 1080p 60fps natively! Awesome machines though, I would have got an Xbox ally if I'd not got this one 2 years ago
Re: Talking Point: Amid Rising Console Prices, What Would You Do If Your Xbox Broke Tomorrow?
I'd be hitting the ROG Ally hard. Already got a huge backlog of indie games on there
Re: This Kingdom Hearts-Inspired Platformer Is Out Now On Xbox, And Reviews Are Looking Great
Looks ok buuutttt I think I'd rather pick up Kena when it goes on sale than this. Art direction is gorgeous though
Re: Six Years On, Mafia: Definitive Edition Might Finally Be Getting A 60FPS Xbox Upgrade
@oopsiezz yeah 3 was 10/10 atmosphere and writing, 4/10 poor gameplay for me. Still glad I played it though.
Re: Talking Point: Xbox Is Getting Its Own Platinum Trophy, But What Will Make It Different?
@Dodoo 🤣 no no that's too much like some kind of topless greek god. We might just have to take the long way around and say "got the emerald" instead of "emeralded"