Comments 180

Re: Xbox Disc To Digital Adds Feature That Lets You Check Your 'Licence History'

Shinato2024

@Fiendish-Beaver You can thank Sony and the media for that, because it was one of the things you could have done on the Xbox One as originally planned; however, the media kept harping on a single issue and failed to explain these features to the public. The way it was supposed to work was that you could sell your digital license, and the studio would also receive a share of the sale price. Who knows—maybe Microsoft will bring this plan back in the future.

Re: Analysis Firm Shares Their Sales Estimates For Gears Of War: E-Day

Shinato2024

That guy pulls numbers out of thin air. He doesn't have access to Microsoft or Steam sales data; he makes sales estimates, and—according to leaks—he uses the number of store comments to estimate game sales figures.

Another thing: this guy is someone who didn't like Microsoft's decision not to release certain games on PlayStation, effectively bringing back exclusivity for some titles. He was already predicting poor numbers for Gears even before its launch. Until he reveals his methodology for estimating sales figures and Game Pass player counts, he’s just a fraud getting attention from the media. Even Circana no longer has sales figures for Xbox games.

Re: Gears Of War E-Day Release Date, Release Times & Everything You Need To Know On Xbox & PC

Shinato2024

@AI-Generation Most of these critics barely play the games—or don't play them at all—and to make matters worse, one guy called it an "alien invasion," meaning he had no clue what he was actually playing. Nowadays, critic scores are purely subjective; there’s nothing technical about them—it’s just their personal opinion. In the past, scores were based on technical aspects: you had separate ratings for specific categories like graphics, sound, and story, with each one getting a score before the final average was calculated. I wish it would go back to being like that—a truly technical analysis.

Re: Xbox Confirms Activision Will Develop The Next Halo Title

Shinato2024

@Gabrie 343 has made good Halo games, but they don't know how to manage projects. Halo Infinite suffered a lot of cuts in the final product due to management errors; I liked Halo Infinite, but it’s infuriating to see what was cut from the final project because of poor management.

Re: Fable Gets Another 30 Minutes Of Raw Gameplay Footage In New Combat Video

Shinato2024

@oopsiezz It seems like you have no idea who is working on the narrative side of Fable. You should look it up; even though Fable is being developed by Playground, the team working on it has almost nothing to do with the Forza Horizon team. The combat director, for instance, is ex-CD Projekt Red, and the people handling the narrative and character creation have also worked on major RPGs.

Re: Two Former Xbox Studios Confirm Their Independence And Plans For The Future

Shinato2024

Double Fine didn't capitalize on the chance to make bigger games; they focused solely on tiny titles with no commercial appeal. They could have made those small games while simultaneously developing and announcing a larger project, but they just focused on what they wanted to do. When they were acquired, I thought they’d work on Rare IPs like Banjo and Conker—which fit the studio perfectly—but Tim made it very clear they had no interest in those franchises. It’s a shame; they missed a huge opportunity.

As for Compulsion Games, it was a lost cause; it took them years to release a game, and when they finally did, it was a reasonably fun AA-level title—but with a AAA budget of $100 million.

Re: Xbox Boss Reveals Brief Thoughts On Elder Scrolls 6 After Seeing A 'Live Playthrough'

Shinato2024

@Dodoo @Dodoo Just so you know, Starfield was the least buggy game Bethesda has released in the 3D era to date.
Buggy games are an industry-wide problem affecting every company these days. I’m curious to see if GTA 6 will launch without issues. I’ve already said that, regarding bugs, AI could really help with development by running various tests and flagging problems for the developers.

Re: Halo Studios Suffers Job Losses Shortly After Campaign Evolved Launch

Shinato2024

@IllusiveMan So, for you, 90% of the big-budget gaming industry is incompetent? Because the performance issues you pointed out in Halo are common in most releases. I could list several games where the media turned a blind eye to technical flaws and gave very high scores—titles like Elden Ring, Hogwarts Legacy, Baldur’s Gate 3, Black Myth: Wukong, and many others. I mention these because they were highly hyped; they were all patched over time, though some still have issues to this day. This is an area where I think AI could help in the future—by running various performance tests on games and flagging issues for developers.

Re: Roundup: Here's What The Critics Are Saying About Halo: Campaign Evolved

Shinato2024

It is striking how much effort the media puts into influencing Xbox game scores. You only have to read the reviews to see them criticizing games for features they don't have—and never promised to include—while also docking points for frame rate issues in a way they don't with other games. That’s why you need to choose reliable reviewers instead of relying on scores from Metacritic and other aggregators.