Comments 521

Re: Poll: How Would You Grade Xbox's Tokyo Game Show 2025 Event?

Questionable_Duck

Compared to other Xbox Tokyo Game Show events, it really wasn't as bad as people are saying here. Maybe a solid C+. Xbox TGS events never have major new game announcements, so I wasn't expecting anything crazy. Plus, MS doesn't normally announce new first-party titles at these events, so FH6 being revealed here is a plus.

I would say it was slightly better than the awful State of Play yesterday, as I was expecting a lot more from that one. Romancing Saga 2, FH6, and Monster Hunter Stories 1+2 got me excited way more than anything from the SoP, so there's that.

If you want to see what a bad Xbox TGS event looks like, you should've seen the one in 2023. They announced literally nothing there, aside from like Octopath Traveler 2 on Xbox and some Yakuza games on Game Pass.

Re: Forza Horizon 6 Heads To Japan In 2026, Day One On Xbox Game Pass

Questionable_Duck

@Nintendo4Sonic Kinda agreed. Knowing MS, the timed exclusivity probably wasn't intentional, but I think it's a good idea to keep timed exclusivity for the new installments in its long-running Xbox exclusive franchises.

I think it's good that they got the PS5 port speculation out of the way by announcing it now, and it's also good that it's coming to Xbox and PC first.

To date, Microsoft has yet to announce a new entry in one of its major Xbox exclusive franchises that's launching on PS5 day-and-date, so I'm curious when they'll make that jump.

Re: Hideo Kojima Shows Off Xbox Game OD, And It Looks Insane

Questionable_Duck

@Fiendish-Beaver Only think I can think may cause OD to be a timed exclusive is if they aren't able to get the cloud streaming stuff working on PS as well as they can on Xbox.

While I think the game will most likely be multiplatform (which makes Physint being a PS exclusive all the more disappointing), I don't think the "For All Players and Screamers" tagline has anything to do with the game being on PlayStation. It's most likely referring to OD's Social Scream System, whatever that is, and the fact that it will utilize the cloud somehow.

Re: Hideo Kojima Shows Off Xbox Game OD, And It Looks Insane

Questionable_Duck

From what I can tell, it seems OD is going to be an anthology game, and that OD: Knock is the name of the section of the game that was directed by Kojima himself. There are probably going to be other sections within OD that will be directed by other famous directors, like Jordan Peele.

So Jordan Peele's OD will probably be called OD: [insert name here] or something like that. Maybe the name of each section of the game is meant to represent the fear that it plays off of. OD: Knock is about the fear of knocking, OD: Water or something is about the fear of drowning, etc.

Re: Microsoft Flight Simulator 2024 Could Be Xbox's Next PS5 Conversion

Questionable_Duck

@FrenchVaniIIuxe They never said that, though? If you're referring to the Push Square article where it says that Sony removed game revenue beyond console from its list of strategically emphasized indicators, I highly doubt that means anything.

The very top of that same list says that Sony is emphasizing "continued expansion of user base and multi device ecosystem," which may be referring to multiplatform, as well. That, of course, isn't even mentioning the whole multiplatform job listing that PlayStation posted a few weeks ago.

Either way, NateTheHate - the guy who's claiming that Flight Sim is coming to PS5 - has already said that PlayStation is working on bringing more of their first-party titles to Xbox. In other words, Helldivers 2 certainly won't be the last PlayStation-published Xbox game.

Re: These 13 Games Are Coming To Xbox Game Pass (September 17 - October 7)

Questionable_Duck

@AlwaysPlaying Visions of Mana was never in Game Pass, this is the first time it's been added to the service.

Before Visions of Mana was released, Microsoft falsely labeled it as a Game Pass title on the Xbox website, but they removed that label shortly after people started to notice it.

Trials of Mana and Legend of Mana were both released on Xbox and Game Pass at the same time during last year's Tokyo Game Show Xbox presentation.

Re: Final Fantasy 7 Remake Finally Heads To Xbox In January 2026

Questionable_Duck

@andrewsqual I agree with you on one thing. FF7 Remake is an amazing game, and despite what some people say, it's easily the best FF game Square Enix has released in the last decade.

However, there is no reason to believe that FF7 Remake's quality is due to its exclusivity. Something tells me you will call FF7 Remake Part 3 a trash game just because it'll launch on Xbox day-one.

Re: Square Enix Confirms That Final Fantasy 7 Rebirth & Part 3 Are Coming To Xbox

Questionable_Duck

@TrollOfWar They never had a deal for the entire trilogy, that was something that people on the internet made up for some reason.

If there was an exclusivity deal for the entire trilogy, it would have made no sense for FF7 Remake and FF7 Rebirth to have exclusivity deals with different lengths. Remake was a 1-year exclusive (with Intergrade being exclusive for an extra 3 or so months), while Rebirth was a 3-month exclusive.

Re: Talking Point: It's Not On Xbox Game Pass, So Will You Be Buying The Indiana Jones DLC?

Questionable_Duck

@johnedwin @Trmn8r That's not the cost of the DLC, that's the cost of the Digital Premium Edition upgrade. That includes/included the DLC, along with the 3-day early access, art book, etc.

The DLC should be less than $35.

@SMJ Yes, it is free if you got the Premium Edition. I got the upgrade at launch to play three days early and, because of it, I don't have to pay extra for the DLC.

Re: Black Myth: Wukong Analysis Shows Completely Different Visuals On Xbox Compared To PS5

Questionable_Duck

@Weebleman Yes, but they never commented on the exclusivity deal rumors. All they have to do is answer a simple "yes or no" question, but to this day, they still haven't responded.

Also, technically speaking, both things can be true at the same time. Game Science struggling to get Wukong running on Xbox could be the reason why they took a deal with Sony at the last minute. This is all just speculation, of course, but still.

Re: Black Myth: Wukong Analysis Shows Completely Different Visuals On Xbox Compared To PS5

Questionable_Duck

@Weebleman If there was no exclusivity deal, the devs at Game Science could have simply just come out and said, "no, we didn't sign an exclusivity deal with Sony." But, in spite of the fact that many outlets have repeatedly asked them this question, they have refused to respond.

Whether they actually signed a deal or not, Game Science is to blame for not shedding light on the matter.

Re: These 30+ Games Are Coming To Xbox Next Week (August 25-29)

Questionable_Duck

So many games that interest me in both this week and last.

I've already pre-ordered Helldivers 2 (and I got a free code for Gears of War: Reloaded), but I'll sadly be waiting for a sale for both Shinobi and MGS Delta.

Believe it or not, I've never actually played Gears of War 1 or MGS 3, so when I do eventually check those games out, they'll be new experiences for me.

Re: Official PlayStation Website Adds Big Xbox Advertisement For Helldivers 2

Questionable_Duck

@TrollOfWar The Fire Emblem games are also all developed by a third-party company: Intelligent Systems. Yet, no one ever considers the Fire Emblem games as second-party or third-party exclusives (even though second-party would probably be the more proper term), because Nintendo owns the Fire Emblem IP.

Also, Intelligent Systems has, to my knowledge, never developed a game for a non-Nintendo platform before, despite not even being owned by Nintendo.