Comments 581

Re: Halo Fan Game To Release On Xbox After Microsoft & Halo Studios Give Approval

Elbow

@Questionable_Duck That is both surprising and unsurprising. Activision despising their community is nothing new... but I would have thought for sure that some knock on effects of being owned by Xbox now would trickle down.

Sucks to be wrong on that one. Even EA is nicer than Acti. (EA has granted fan projects the green light to completely recreate old games for free in modern engines, like Renegade X.)

Re: Halo Fan Game To Release On Xbox After Microsoft & Halo Studios Give Approval

Elbow

Cool. Microsoft and Sega are both really good when it comes to fan games, they don't really strike anyone down, which is good.

But, Mojang, hear me out... I'd love a Minecraft Survivors game. You can get real weird with it, Frank Reynolds-tier weird. Creeper crossbows, milk machine guns, cat claymores (kitty ears on the mines, I'm not a monster)....

There's a lot of untapped potential in it, for real.

Re: Xbox Journalist Denies Report About Backwards Compatibility Plans For 2026

Elbow

Regardless on the leaks and who is trustworthy or not... the big takeaway should be that nothing is confirmed until you hear it from Xbox themselves. Hope for it if you'd like (I would like it!) but don't actually expect anything until you see an official confirmation.

Or some crazy in depth leak that Xbox inadvertently confirms in their rush to get the leak taken down. You know. Either or.

Re: Next-Gen Xbox Partnership Will 'Push The Boundaries Of What's Possible', Says AMD Exec

Elbow

A lot of this feels like Xbox just trying to toss a hail mary throw to save themselves. I really want to be optimistic about this but I can't tell how this is meant to work with a potential price being enormous, lacking exclusives that will now be available on cheaper competitor hardware (at least PS5 for a few years more after all this) while also skewering their profits further with potentially allowing other storefronts to be accessed.

Will Game Pass be required to even play Steam games online on this device? If not, how will the community take it when they can either buy a game on the Xbox store and be stuck paying to access online, or can just get it on Steam without that extra hassle?

I can't wrap my head around dozens of problem points with this potential console.

Edit: Adding late, however, that Xbox still making hardware is good. They're... some sort of competition still, but I just can't see how this works out. With that said, I very much hope I am proven wrong. I WANT to be wrong about this.

Re: Roundup: Here's What The Reviews Are Saying About The Gex Trilogy

Elbow

I'm very let down that game wise, this seems to be the bare minimum effort. PS1 only? No N64 versions? They're missing out on exclusive levels... not to mention the massive delay from announce to release.

Why did it take so long when it was bare bones? At least they added in the PAL region with an update... but that not even being ready for release is pathetic.

Re: Xbox Has Started Giving Out Free Gears Of War: Reloaded Codes To 'Ultimate Edition' Owners

Elbow

@Nintendo4Sonic Unfortunately I think you'll see less and less support as time goes on. This will likely be the last generation with a disc drive, with a possible (but VERY slim chance of) disc drive add-on like the PS5... but likely with the same PS5 caveat that it'll need an internet connection to authorize. Xbox shuttered their physical division already and all this stuff is being done by third parties. It's been over.

Re: Reaction: Xbox Games Showcase 2025 Was Just OK, But Next Year Should Be Amazing

Elbow

It was pretty decent overall. I liked it, but let's be honest.. the ending was so stupid it actually hurt the rating.

Phil grins as he as reveals the last surprise for the showcase... it's just the yearly COD. OMG NO WAY WHAT!!!!!!

There are three constants in life: Death, taxes, and COD. The surprise would have been no COD. Ending the show with that, treating it like some major unbelievable reveal, was damn stupid. Clockwork Revolution being the show closer would have been the smart play. (It looks SO good.)

I'm saying this as someone who does play Blops 6 and likes COD. Come on, now.

Re: Romeo Is A Dead Man's Xbox Release Date Is 'TBD' Because Of GTA 6, Says Developer

Elbow

I'm a Suda51 diehard, this is the only game that grabbed my interest yesterday. I actually skipped it until someone told me "hey that developer you like had a thing on this showcase" and knowing my shortlist is basically just Suda51 I zoomed to the showcase to watch.

But can't blame him. His games are pretty niche. There's no way they'd stand up to GTA6, but very very few games could... if any even could. Not sure.

Re: Talking Point: Will This Lost Xbox Game Studios Title Appear At Microsoft's 2025 Showcase?

Elbow

@Kaloudz I'd actually be surprised if FF7R is a day one gamepass add. It's very possible but I just remember Sony making demands of third parties to not release games like RE8 on Gamepass. I would be surprised if they've relaxed on this, even if FF7R is "old news" to them.

Edit: Not a demand but a "payment blockage" so basically a bribe, and I'd be shocked if they didn't try that with FF7R

Also I've only played Persona 4 but it's a killer game. It's very much all the strengths of a JRPG, and the cast being high-schoolers (roughly) doesn't actually hurt it. They're just likable students caught up in a crazy situation trying their best to help put a stop to it. Also the music is SICK. I'd recommend at least giving 4 (maybe 5, have heard great things there too) a shot. I played P4 in my late 20s and still connected with the cast. They're not any longer than FF games.

Re: Six Xbox Games Are Shutting Down Their Servers In June 2025

Elbow

@Kaloudz This is what I never understood about Capcom... they slap the RE name on anything MP related, good or not, when they already had a winning formula. Why not remake Outbreak games and massively expand the amount of randomization in missions to make it truly replayable?

Even if not.. Mercenaries co-op and Versus was great. They have two proven ideas already but refuse them. I don't get it.

Also RIP Xbone First Descendant. Was playing that casually, but must've been just me doing so. ;_;7

Re: Review: DOOM: The Dark Ages (Xbox) - Puts The Finishing Touches On A Masterful Trilogy

Elbow

Gameplay wise, I'm glad none of the three new-era Doom games play the same. It's good to experiment and make sure the games don't just feel like expansion packs to what came before. I say that as someone who didn't care for 2016 (imo felt too sterile and bland), loved Eternal, but am not sold on Dark Ages.

Each one having a unique identity and formula is great. People may not remember now but Doom 2 was heavily criticized for just being an expansion pack to Doom but with the super shotgun... glad that hasn't been repeated.

Re: Xbox Game Pass Gets Four Additions Today (May 7)

Elbow

Xenoverse 2 will NEVER die. It's the game that will keep going despite all odds. When the earth is destroyed by nuclear warfare in the far future, there will only be cockroaches and an Xbox hooked up to a TV somewhere with the Xenoverse 2 main menu theme blaring.

Re: Xbox Developer Insists Generative AI Is 'Not Mandated' At Microsoft

Elbow

AI still isn't perfect. I throw math questions at it (I'm 33, not in education, just testing AI for fun) and it frequently gets more complicated ones wrong, at least on the first few tries. If they plan to use it to ease up on complex tasks, they're asking for a world of hurt when it inevitably starts falling apart at the seams. It's really not foolproof or completely trustworthy.

AI hallucinates, misreads things, or spits up garbage in the interest of giving you what you want, not what might be accurate.

Re: Xbox Owners Fed Up With 'Outbreak' Spam On The Microsoft Store

Elbow

These practices actually make me ashamed to say that I've purchased some of their games. They're not awful if you're into that old RE style done by a small/tiny budget team, but this business practice is scummy and Xbox do need to crack down on stuff like this.

@Utena-mobile An ignore feature is essentially mandatory nowadays with how much junk can flood stores. Trying to browse the Switch eShop is nightmarish... but I probably don't need to tell you/anyone else that.

Re: Nintendo's Doug Bowser Just Channelled One Of The Most Infamous Xbox Quotes Ever

Elbow

@EdgarTheBug There is a chance it ends up biting them. The 3DS-- ended its run as an incredible handheld-- started on a terrible foot and had to be slashed in price along with Nintendo eating a massive slice of humble pie.

The Nintendo fans didn't save them during that, nor did they with the Wii U. Of course I'm not saying "guaranteed nintendo flop OMG", just that there's a very real 50/50 shot of either outcome happening-- where it's a success or a vast under-performer that causes them to repeat what they did with the 3DS.