Comments 135

Re: Roundup: Here's What The Critics Are Saying About The Ascent

MattWithoutFear

@Fenbops but GP's big USP over, say, Sony's offering, is the Day 1 release. If it's attracting buggy games though, that lessens the appeal. Just think, if Death's Door had come to GP instead of the Ascent, we'd all be talking about how GP had succeeded in its promise of delivering great games "for free" on launch, rather than this narrative of "another buggy Day 1 GP release".

Re: Roundup: Here's What The Critics Are Saying About The Ascent

MattWithoutFear

@SplooshDmg different strokes for different folks I guess. This is the 3rd hyped co-op title that's come to GP and has been buggy at launch - Outriders, Dark Alliance and now this. @LtSarge isn't wrong when he talks about damage to the brand. GP is meant to be this ultimate service for gamers but it's in danger of turning into something like a bargain bin - instead of it delivering the next big thing, people (myself increasingly so) will start to think "OK it's not great but it was "free" so can I compain?". I'm certainly going to be tempering expectations for 3rd party releases moving forward, along the lines of "you get what you pay for", and I'm not sure that's the direction that MS wants to take it in.

Re: Roundup: Here's What The Critics Are Saying About The Ascent

MattWithoutFear

Played it online last night with my brother, good gameplay but ran into more than a few bugs and had to put it down - one or both of us getting stuck in dialogue loops, some side-quests not being be added to one of us, problems inviting him back in when we had to crash out, not being able to exit the game through the menu (literally nothing happened, had to quit to Xbox home). It's a shame because the gameplay was really solid but it we had to crash out several times in a 4 hour session, hope it gets sorted with a few patches.

Re: Xbox Announces Cloud Gaming Streaming Sticks, TV Integration

MattWithoutFear

@uptownsoul And that's fine, and if it was profit per console that was the deciding factor then I might agree that they might wind down. But there so many more factors that go into, like:

  • people like consoles, they just do
  • console performance > streaming performance; it's not apples to apples comparing the two and that matters to people.
  • consoles have other benefits that a streaming stick likely wouldn't have (apps, party etc) assuming the stick is a streaming library only
  • more Xboxes out means more games purchases (people with game pass spend more on games and/or doc for their consoles, this have been evidenced over and over).
    So there are intangibles that suggest that MS is in fact reliant on consoles for it's games model. They can afford not to make a profit because the overall ROI is there.

Re: Xbox Announces Cloud Gaming Streaming Sticks, TV Integration

MattWithoutFear

@uptownsoul That's not "the fact" and you know it, you're jumping through hoops to avoid what I mean. The "fact" I was referring to is just the act of them just saying it; the fact is they're saying they're committed to consoles. I'm fully open to the possibility that you might be right, however in this case the evidence doesn't support your claim that MS will be winding down on consoles.

Re: Xbox Announces Cloud Gaming Streaming Sticks, TV Integration

MattWithoutFear

@uptownsoul "I think this means Microsoft might start pulling away from the console space"
Microsoft: don't worry this doesn't mean we're pulling away from the console space
"Yeah but that's BS"

You can't point to the few times Microsoft said something was coming and it didn't happen, in the face of all the things they said would happen and those did, as if that proves your point. It gets to the point where you're just being obtuse in the face of facts and can't accept that your opinion might have been wrong. Just be a big boy, accept it and move on.

Re: Xbox Announces Cloud Gaming Streaming Sticks, TV Integration

MattWithoutFear

@uptownsoul this site literally just published an article highlighting that MS have said they're not abandoning consoles. Give it a rest, mate.
"Cloud is key to our hardware and Game Pass roadmaps, but no one should think we're slowing down on our core console engineering. In fact, we're accelerating it."
https://www.purexbox.com/news/2021/06/microsoft_is_already_working_on_new_xbox_consoles_but_dont_expect_to_see_them_soon

Re: Xbox Announces Cloud Gaming Streaming Sticks, TV Integration

MattWithoutFear

@uptownsoul Microsoft just produced the most powerful console ever and it defo wasn't a swansong. Until streaming tech can match console performance, people won't accept that as the only platform, and MS know that. If you think otherwise, you're kidding yourself. This is just about getting the Xbox platform in front of as many people as possible because that all equals GP revenue.

And Microsoft binned Mixed because they realised they weren't gonna compete with Twitch. Not that that's got anything to do with this conversation; sounds like a sore spot of yours though.

Re: Xbox Announces Cloud Gaming Streaming Sticks, TV Integration

MattWithoutFear

@uptownsoul they've never had good ROI on their consoles. The reason the 360 came out before the PS3 is because they rushed the production because they were losing so much on the OG Xbox. They stated in the Epic trial that they've never made a profit on console sales. MS is a trillion (TRILLION!) dollar company, they don't care about ROI on consoles. This GP streaming device would just be another revenue stream to target people who don't want to, or can't, buy a second console but still want to play all the Xbox exclusives (Bethesda et al). For Playstation folks who want to play Elder Scrolls, this could be a great "in".

Re: Xbox Announces Cloud Gaming Streaming Sticks, TV Integration

MattWithoutFear

@uptownsoul I don't think consoles are going away any time soon. So many people love owning physical consoles and the performace will still beat average streaming for years to come; fibre internet rollout hasn't even cracked the US or the UK, let alone globally. The world you're dreaming of will happen, eventually, but I don't think it'll be this decade.