Comments 320

Re: Asha Sharma Comments On Xbox Revenue Loss For Q3 2026

kmtrain83

@TrollOfWar
I've said this before but I feel like because it's Microsoft which is a multi-trillion dollar behemoth, unless they can dominate this space, they'd rather pack up and reinvest in AI and whatnot. If they'd settle for running 3rd and keeping an underdog attitude, that's still a bronze medal in gaming, and we could continue to have nice things from them. I don't think Nadella has it in him to settle though.

Re: Asha Sharma Comments On Xbox Revenue Loss For Q3 2026

kmtrain83

@Skinny-Pete
I love that Scarface analogy.
Sharma has brought positive energy to the brand, which is a good thing.
It's hard to arrive on the scene nearly six years into a console lifecycle, when sales will be in decline -> that's not her fault, it's just the natural order of things.
The next console launch will be her time to shine.

Re: Asha Sharma Says Xbox Is Investing To Make Series X|S Consoles A 'First-Class Experience Again'

kmtrain83

I think they need to slow down the constant messaging at this point and maybe sit tight until they have something more substantive to relay. This corporate lingo is getting a bit irritating.
“We’re going to lead because that’s what leaders do.”
“We’re going to put gamers first because we’re a gamers first company.”
I could probably use AI to make a lot more of these statements if anyone is interested.

Re: Xbox Is Officially 'Reevaluating' What To Do About Exclusivity

kmtrain83

I’m not sure if they have the goods in terms of exclusives. I don’t see Fable as a system seller even if it’s a good game. Starfield didn’t get the job done, and by the time the sequel to Skyrim comes out will anyone care. Many of the original Morrowind fans like me will be in a nursing home, playing Wii Sports.

Re: Xbox Boss Wants A 'Chat' With Ex-PlayStation Exec Over Criticisms Of Game Pass

kmtrain83

@darylb24
We will probably never know the full numbers, because it is a trade secret. What we can infer from them raising the price from $20 to $30 for the highest tier, is that they made a calculated risk that it would be more profitable to get more from existing subscribers then try to grow the base with a lower entry cost. Netflix has raised their prices multiple times in the past several years. Is that "good" or "bad" IDK?

Re: Former Xbox Exec Says Project Helix Is 'Very Similar' To Microsoft's Plan For The OG Xbox

kmtrain83

@Millionski
I have not seen any rumors or announcements on how they will convert what in some cases could be 25 years and hundreds of physical discs in the hard-core fan collection to this future potentially disc-free PC first platform.
My guess it would come in the form of a detachable disc reader connected by USB, but whether you need to insert the disc each time to play, or have a one time conversion to digital is unclear. The latter would be bad for the environment and flood the market with useless discs.

Re: With 2025's GOTY Now In The Library, Xbox Game Pass Premium Is Becoming Too Good To Ignore

kmtrain83

Of all the options out there, including mobile PC console streaming buying new buying used buying on sale, I wonder what percent of gamers want to pay $30 a month for unlimited rentals? Like many people on this forum, I have a huge backlog of owned digital and physical games on multiple platforms, so paying additional $30 monthly for that one other game as a rental will just bump down the backlog.

Re: 'We're Just Getting Started' - Xbox Employee Hypes Up 'Momentum' Of 2026 So Far

kmtrain83

Just like with a sports club sometimes you just need a new manager to turn around the season even if the players are the same.
It is very unlikely I will get the next generation of PlayStation at the rate that things are going in terms of price and must play games in relationship to my backlog. We still love enough of the Nintendo IP to invest in Switch 2 games, and that can be easily passed around among family members.
I would likely need to upgrade my aging desktop PC and that is where Project Helix may find a home however, I don’t think most people on this site are looking at that for a desktop PC replacement but rather a console evolution

Re: Talking Point: Do You Think Project Helix Will Support Physical Xbox Games?

kmtrain83

If this is a PC, you probably could just plug in a CD player using a USB connector to install games onto the internal drive. You should be able to do that on any PC. The drive just has to be able to read Xbox discs. They already make these drives for the series X, so why not just make a detachable version?

The bigger question will be if that drive does a single digital conversion or you will have to reinsert it each time to run the game.

If they do the digital conversion, there will be a whole lot of useless plastic all of a sudden, and this could get dumped into the donation centers

Re: Talking Point: What Do You 'Expect' From Xbox Over The Next Five Years?

kmtrain83

@cragis0001
This is kind of what happened already in the 1980s. Microsoft cut a deal with IBM, and slowly at first but then suddenly with the burst of PC clones, they found a way to get their OS onto tons of computers, thereby crowding out the likes of Apple, Commodore/Amiga, and Atari in the PC gaming space. The circumstances are different now, in that Steam gets a bigger cut of PC game than Microsoft (Windows itself generates a bit), and of course mobile gaming, which outpaces both console and PC. Microsoft has some mobile assets in King (of Candy Crush fame), but I don't hear much about if they are trying to push mobile, nor do I care, as I more or less dropped those kinds of games several years ago.

Re: According To Metacritic, These Are The 10 Best Xbox Games Of 2026 So Far

kmtrain83

Why would a fairly well known game like Dragon Quest VII Reimagined not have four reviews yet? It would easily be in the top 10. Nothing on this list screams "You must get an Xbox," and that is part of the problem. Meanwhile for Switch 2 on Metacritic the Monster Hunter Stories 3 lands all the way down at 12th place with an 82 (ie "great.") NSW2 is still being criticized as heavy a mediocre 1st year lineup, but it has the added elements of Pokekmon Pokopia, Animal Crossing update, Ys X Proud Nordics, Mario Tennis, and Xenoblade X update.

Re: 'We Will See More Games Come To Xbox Quicker' - Microsoft Exec Talks Plans For The Future

kmtrain83

@Cakefish

I was also wondering about the fate of Play Anywhere. Furthermore, I believe the Game Pass PC vs Ultimate tiers need to be consolidated, and lowered in price to match the PC edition, forgoing significant revenue.

I’m still struggling to find a reason for Helix to exist, and to differentiate itself from any other mini desktop gaming PC. If it comes down to things like Achievements and Quick Resume, do we assume these are Xbox exclusive, and could never be replicated by the likes of other Steam, Sony, Nintendo, etc? So many questions!

Re: 'Xbox Mode' For Windows 11 Is Progress, And It Could Shape Microsoft's Project Helix Console

kmtrain83

I forgot Xbox "app" on Windows 11 is a thing, so I'm trying it out. The first thing that happened is a pop up window (love them pop ups when I'm on my work PC) saying their is misalignment between my Microsoft account, and my son's account for the Windows store. I have to choose. He's the one with the Game Pass, so I picked his. Then I clicked on Minecraft launcher, which said "Recently updated." It proceeded to install another update, which was admittedly fairly quick. Then I got a splash screen telling me to "Sign In With Microsoft." -> Didn't I just do that with the first pop up? Okay, forget Minecraft. Then I went to an oldie but goodie that I sunk many hours into back in the day: Age of Empires II. It's not installed, but I can "Play with Cloud With your Subscription." Okay, great let's get to it -> only now it says "Let's get ready... Controller disconnected." ... I seem to recall playing this with mouse and keyboard all those times. Why would I use a controller for the "best play experience?" .... Meanwhile, in the time spent, I could have likely completed an entire run on Hades 2, Switch edition.