If your games don’t sell, you don’t survive. Pretty simple. All three of these studios have made incredible games, in my opinion, but seriously, who actually bought them? Who actually played them? Not a lot of people.
Eh. I gave my Steam Deck to my stepson about 2 years ago because it wasn't doing anyone any good sitting around and collecting dust. It was a competent machine for indie games but I prefer doing that sort of thing on Switch 2. My OG ROG Ally is in much the same spot only my stepson doesn't really need/want it.
I loved this game. Games that don't take me months to finish that recall the good old 360 days are what Game Pass is made for. It absolutely deserved some recognition.
I've never NOT bought the ultimate version of Forza Horizon, whatever it might have been called at the time. I wasn't about to skip 6, so yeah, I have early access, but that wasn't why I bought it. I bought it because I've got thousands of hours into the franchise so far. Early access is just icing on the cake for me.
@DarkRula I'm with you. I'd sell a kid or two for new entries in the Midtown Madness, PGR, Crimson Skies, etc. series. Honestly I couldn't care less about Banjo - blasphemy, I know - but show me some new takes on older Xbox/MS IP and I'm absolutely down. Amped maybe?
But more than anything I just want Perfect Dark to get finished.
Doom 3 came out in 2004, not "sometime around the 2010's" - I only mention this because I read that and thought my entire sense of the past two decades was WAY off.
Swap the pricing. Keep the current highest tier price with CoD day one (and add all legacy CoD games + give some monthly bonuses) - then, drop the price of the next tier down. Easy.
I'll keep my ultimate subscription and everyone that isn't into CoD can pay less.
I still don't get why there's no MP component. I mean, I love the campaign and I've played through it 2-3x now, but multiplayer is really what Halo is about once you've put in the 5-6 hours.
Xbox One, and in particular the Xbox One X, aged the best for me. To have began life as the massive negative that it was, I think Phil & Co really turned it around, and if I'm being honest, I'm not seeing a whole lot of improvement in this current generation. I love my XSX, but it wasn't until 2024 or so that I could really tell the difference between them.
@Herna The Wii U is still legendary in my mind. The nights we (me and three kids) spent playing Super Mario U multiplayer will always be some of my favorite gaming memories.
Though I'm old enough to have been an Atari kid, I didn't start buying consoles day one until the Genesis/SNES era when I bought the first SNES from my local store. Since then I've pretty much bought everything on launch day.
Along the way I've had mixed experiences but honestly, some of the highlights for me have been Sega Saturn and Dreamcast, 3DO, Xbox 360, and PS3.
It wasn't until this latest generation that I've been disappointed - the Switch 2 hasn't AT ALL lived up to my expectations, mostly due to its lack of games, and both the PS5 and Xbox Series consoles didn't do much to differentiate themselves from the prior generation until several years later.
All of that said, I'm in for a PC-ish Xbox in the future. I feel like that's the way the industry is headed. I couldn't care less about PS6, Switch 3, or whatever else comes around.
It’s a testament to just how awful the Xbox one launch was that this game, Ryse, and Sunset Overdrive are “cult” games and not modern classics. All are five star games in my opinion, but Quantum Break is still Remedy’s finest.
@SigmaTheDJ yeah but sadly the Sony solution has its own issues. I've had 3 of them across a PS5 (1) and now a PS5 Pro (2) that have failed on me within 30-45 days of purchase. Pure junk.
"Build Your Own Game Pass" will never work because the math doesn't math. Each GP title, including Xbox Studios games, has a dollar amount attached to it. You'd wind up with pricing that scales up and down depending on what you 'rent' and that'd lead to nothing but confusion.
It is funny to me though that everyone that doesn't play Fortnite assumes that they're the majority, or that people aren't finding value in Ubisoft or EA titles on GamePass when Fortnite continues to be the number one game on most platforms and Ubi/EA stuff is always ranked fairly highly among Game Pass games when released to the service.
Even though I 'got' what they were shooting for with that campaign, I can't help but notice the timing between its release and the heavy decline in Xbox console sales. A lot of that is probably coincidence, but still.
@TrollOfWar I took the comment as "we won't be releasing 2 BlackOps games in a row" or similar, not that there wouldn't still be another CoD this year.
Congratulations, Internet! You've once again killed something without ever even trying it. You've been complaining forever that no one tries anything new, and then when they do, you turn to your favorite clickbait YouTuber for their "thoughts," then spew them out tenfold into the void.
In your next social post after that you'll complain that too many devs are left unemployed.
Seamus Blackley hasn't been a part of the gaming industry for years. Who cares what he thinks about anything? Well, except bread. I follow him for bread. Other than that? I put about as much weight into his gaming/Xbox thoughts as I do Don Mattrick. We all look at the OG Xbox era through rose-colored glasses. It wasn't really a success so much as a proof of concept.
Leaks suck. I miss the days where we were all pleasantly surprised by official announcements about games, tech, etc. vs. this non-stop cloud of disappointment when all this hard work sees the light of day and we all collectively go "ok, meh, that's old news - what else ya got?"
@sixrings I can assure you that 99% of the Fortniting Minecrafters out there couldn't care less what they're playing on. My teens still don't understand console exclusivity and get frustrated when they can't play Spider-Man: Miles Morales on a phone.
Moore is a class act, and while it will take a bit more than his wisdom to quell the negativity around all of this, I feel a little better that he sees some good in all of it.
Phil was the high bar for gaming CEOs when you think about it, up until MS got AI-hungry. From that point on he has been completely ineffective. I think anyone would have been.
@BacklogBrad Eh, I'll formulate an opinion about her based on having interviewed her at a pair of conventions when she was at both Meta and Instacart. I mean, if you're going to do the "the 1 trillion dollar company ALWAYS knows better" d*** on the table, hurray for you having no real opinion other than fanboyism I guess?
And I respectfully say all that as a long-time MS and Xbox fanboy. This won't end well.
@BacklogBrad yup, about 6 months ago - almost to the day. Doesn't mean she's been following Phil around like a puppy for 180 days. She has all the qualifications - used to run product at Meta, spent some time at instacart, moonlights as a home depot board member. All the ingredients necessary to ensure Xbox is well and truly run into the ground.
She literally was head of their enterprise AI division just yesterday. I have a hard time believing she's written an email, memo, or press release since chatgpt took over. This won't end well for anyone but shareholders.
Zero interest in this now. Had GTA V been better and had there been more follow up in the years since GTA IV, maybe. I was an OG GTA player a long, long time ago on PS and have played them all since. I'm sort of bored with the whole thing.
That and it all just reminds me of a bad Pitbull (Mr worldwide, not the dog breed) fever dream. Zzzz.
Just give me lots more overhyped single-player open world adventure games where I’m staring at the back of my character doing fetch quests on a huge map and I’m ready to go!!!
Meh. I've moved entirely to PC for the multiplayer stuff I play (CoD, Battlefield, etc.) and my Series X is fine for FF and all of the single player games. I'll probably never buy another console again anyway unless MS really nails the Windows-On-a-TV interface for the next Xbox.
My Switch 2 is my biggest gaming regret of the past 5 years (possibly more) - consoles are just boring these days.
I'd love to get an Elite 3 before my Elite 2 finally dies, but seeing as how its well on its way, I doubt that's going to happen. Elite 3 will undoubtedly come out a week after I spring for another Elite 2.
Comments 432
Re: Report: Multiple Xbox Studios In 'Active Negotiations' With Microsoft To Avoid Closure
If your games don’t sell, you don’t survive. Pretty simple. All three of these studios have made incredible games, in my opinion, but seriously, who actually bought them? Who actually played them? Not a lot of people.
Re: Xbox CCO Explains Why Marvel's Blade & Elder Scrolls 6 Didn't Appear At The Showcase
Forgot about Blade, which is strange considering it's one of the few Marvelverse characters I even find interesting to begin with.
Re: Xbox Is Gaining Momentum With US Gamers, As Highlighted In New YouGov Report
Whine whine whine... exclusives! whine whine.... antiquated discs whine whine... I want to pretend it's still 1998 whine whine.
Re: Steam Deck Has Gone Up In Price Massively, And It Makes ROG Xbox Ally Look Great Value In 2026
Eh. I gave my Steam Deck to my stepson about 2 years ago because it wasn't doing anyone any good sitting around and collecting dust. It was a competent machine for indie games but I prefer doing that sort of thing on Switch 2. My OG ROG Ally is in much the same spot only my stepson doesn't really need/want it.
Re: Call Of Duty: Modern Warfare 4 Launches This October, And It Won't Be On Xbox One
Day One buy here.
Re: 'We Don't Want It At All' - Playasia Hates The Idea Of An Xbox Disc-To-Digital Program
@kmtrain83 Give your kids your Steam, Xbox, PS, etc. passwords. Problem solved.
Re: 'We Don't Want It At All' - Playasia Hates The Idea Of An Xbox Disc-To-Digital Program
Playasia is almost as crap as LRG. Who cares what they think about anything at this point?
Re: Xbox's South Of Midnight Wins Big At CGA 2026 Following PS5 & Switch 2 Release
I loved this game. Games that don't take me months to finish that recall the good old 360 days are what Game Pass is made for. It absolutely deserved some recognition.
Re: Xbox's New Chief Strategy Officer Is Planning To 'Revive Storied Franchises'
Banjo
Crimson Skies
Perfect Dark ( i know )
Blast Corps
Brute Force
Kameo
Shadowrun
Blinx
Conker
Crackdown
PGR
Amped
and that barely scratches the surface
Re: Xbox Execs Congratulate Forza Horizon 6 Dev On 'Exceptionally Rare' Success
Worthy praise for sure. Brilliant set of games and the newest one is no exception.
Re: Talking Point: So, Did You Cave And Buy Early Access For Forza Horizon 6?
I've never NOT bought the ultimate version of Forza Horizon, whatever it might have been called at the time. I wasn't about to skip 6, so yeah, I have early access, but that wasn't why I bought it. I bought it because I've got thousands of hours into the franchise so far. Early access is just icing on the cake for me.
Re: Talking Point: What Dream Reveal Would You Like To See At The Xbox Games Showcase 2026?
@eduscxbox Hell yes. This.
Re: Talking Point: What Dream Reveal Would You Like To See At The Xbox Games Showcase 2026?
@DarkRula I'm with you. I'd sell a kid or two for new entries in the Midtown Madness, PGR, Crimson Skies, etc. series. Honestly I couldn't care less about Banjo - blasphemy, I know - but show me some new takes on older Xbox/MS IP and I'm absolutely down. Amped maybe?
But more than anything I just want Perfect Dark to get finished.
Re: Talking Point: 10 Years Ago, Bethesda Released One Of The Best Shooters Ever To Grace Xbox
Doom 3 came out in 2004, not "sometime around the 2010's" - I only mention this because I read that and thought my entire sense of the past two decades was WAY off.
Re: Report: Halo 2 & 3 Remakes Are In 'Active Development' At Halo Studios
I'm going to wait for the 2038 Halo CE RE-RE-REMAKE Remastered.
Seriously, make new games or GTFO.
Re: Xbox Boss Declares Game Pass Is 'Too Expensive' And Needs A 'Better Value Equation'
Swap the pricing. Keep the current highest tier price with CoD day one (and add all legacy CoD games + give some monthly bonuses) - then, drop the price of the next tier down. Easy.
I'll keep my ultimate subscription and everyone that isn't into CoD can pay less.
Re: 'What Do You Want Added?' - Xbox Engineer Requests Ideas For New Console Features
The ability to record game footage indefinitely to a usb drive. Why am I capped? It’s MY drive!
Re: Rumour: Xbox To Release Halo: Campaign Evolved In July 2026, Early Access Included
I still don't get why there's no MP component. I mean, I love the campaign and I've played through it 2-3x now, but multiplayer is really what Halo is about once you've put in the 5-6 hours.
Re: Talking Point: Which Xbox Console Do You Think Has Aged The Best?
Xbox One, and in particular the Xbox One X, aged the best for me. To have began life as the massive negative that it was, I think Phil & Co really turned it around, and if I'm being honest, I'm not seeing a whole lot of improvement in this current generation. I love my XSX, but it wasn't until 2024 or so that I could really tell the difference between them.
Re: Talking Point: How Many Consoles Have You Bought At Launch, And Were They Worth It?
@Herna The Wii U is still legendary in my mind. The nights we (me and three kids) spent playing Super Mario U multiplayer will always be some of my favorite gaming memories.
Re: Talking Point: How Many Consoles Have You Bought At Launch, And Were They Worth It?
Though I'm old enough to have been an Atari kid, I didn't start buying consoles day one until the Genesis/SNES era when I bought the first SNES from my local store. Since then I've pretty much bought everything on launch day.
Along the way I've had mixed experiences but honestly, some of the highlights for me have been Sega Saturn and Dreamcast, 3DO, Xbox 360, and PS3.
It wasn't until this latest generation that I've been disappointed - the Switch 2 hasn't AT ALL lived up to my expectations, mostly due to its lack of games, and both the PS5 and Xbox Series consoles didn't do much to differentiate themselves from the prior generation until several years later.
All of that said, I'm in for a PC-ish Xbox in the future. I feel like that's the way the industry is headed. I couldn't care less about PS6, Switch 3, or whatever else comes around.
Re: Quantum Break Actor Celebrates 10th Anniversary Of The 2016 Xbox Console Exclusive
It’s a testament to just how awful the Xbox one launch was that this game, Ryse, and Sunset Overdrive are “cult” games and not modern classics. All are five star games in my opinion, but Quantum Break is still Remedy’s finest.
Re: Talking Point: Do You Think Project Helix Will Support Physical Xbox Games?
@SigmaTheDJ yeah but sadly the Sony solution has its own issues. I've had 3 of them across a PS5 (1) and now a PS5 Pro (2) that have failed on me within 30-45 days of purchase. Pure junk.
Re: Talking Point: Do You Think Project Helix Will Support Physical Xbox Games?
The Xbox Back Compat Kit will become a thing. It'll be an optical disc drive. The physical media people will whine regardless.
Re: New Xbox Boss Has Considered 'Pricing Revamp' For Game Pass, Claims Report
"Build Your Own Game Pass" will never work because the math doesn't math. Each GP title, including Xbox Studios games, has a dollar amount attached to it. You'd wind up with pricing that scales up and down depending on what you 'rent' and that'd lead to nothing but confusion.
It is funny to me though that everyone that doesn't play Fortnite assumes that they're the majority, or that people aren't finding value in Ubisoft or EA titles on GamePass when Fortnite continues to be the number one game on most platforms and Ubi/EA stuff is always ranked fairly highly among Game Pass games when released to the service.
Re: 'I'm Of Two Minds' - Todd Howard Gives His Thoughts On Xbox's Leadership Changes
@NeoRatt Absolutely no one is going to miss Sarah Bond.
Sarah Bond's best friend at Xbox was...Sarah Bond.
Re: Microsoft's 'This Is An Xbox' Post Taken Down As Fans Wonder If The Controversial Ad Is No More
Even though I 'got' what they were shooting for with that campaign, I can't help but notice the timing between its release and the heavy decline in Xbox console sales. A lot of that is probably coincidence, but still.
Goodbye Sarah Bond, you won't be missed.
Re: 'Xbox 25' Fanta Collab Hints At What We Might Be Getting With Call Of Duty 2026
@TrollOfWar I took the comment as "we won't be releasing 2 BlackOps games in a row" or similar, not that there wouldn't still be another CoD this year.
Re: Xbox Announces New 'Project Helix' Console, Says It Will Play PC Games
day. one.
that's all i have to say about that.
Re: Resident Evil Requiem Hits Incredible Sales Milestone In Less Than A Week
Huh. After the abysmal Silent Hill f(orgettable) I sort of swore off the whole genre. Looks like that was a bad idea.
Re: Highguard Goes Offline Next Week As Failed Online Shooter Officially Shuts Down
Congratulations, Internet! You've once again killed something without ever even trying it. You've been complaining forever that no one tries anything new, and then when they do, you turn to your favorite clickbait YouTuber for their "thoughts," then spew them out tenfold into the void.
In your next social post after that you'll complain that too many devs are left unemployed.
Maybe it's not them, it's you?
Re: 'Is Xbox Ending?' - The Official Answer Is No, But A Recent Interview Clearly Caused Panic
Seamus Blackley hasn't been a part of the gaming industry for years. Who cares what he thinks about anything? Well, except bread. I follow him for bread. Other than that? I put about as much weight into his gaming/Xbox thoughts as I do Don Mattrick. We all look at the OG Xbox era through rose-colored glasses. It wasn't really a success so much as a proof of concept.
Re: 'They Hurt People Building The Game' - Activision Takes Legal Action Against Call Of Duty Leaker
Leaks suck. I miss the days where we were all pleasantly surprised by official announcements about games, tech, etc. vs. this non-stop cloud of disappointment when all this hard work sees the light of day and we all collectively go "ok, meh, that's old news - what else ya got?"
Re: Xbox Head Doubles Down On The Importance Of Console, Says It's A 'Reference Experience'
@sixrings I can assure you that 99% of the Fortniting Minecrafters out there couldn't care less what they're playing on. My teens still don't understand console exclusivity and get frustrated when they can't play Spider-Man: Miles Morales on a phone.
Re: Six Games Are Leaving Xbox Game Pass In Early March 2026
Ah man, when will I have time to finish Bratz before it leaves?
Re: Opinion: Xbox Should Consider Cancelling Halo: Campaign Evolved For PS5
Or just give them a taste with Halo and keep the MCC and all future Halo games as Xbox/PC exclusives.
Re: 'I Think She'll Be Fine' - Xbox Legend Peter Moore Reveals His Advice For Asha Sharma
Moore is a class act, and while it will take a bit more than his wisdom to quell the negativity around all of this, I feel a little better that he sees some good in all of it.
I'm still gonna miss Phil.
Re: Seven Amazing Things Phil Spencer Did During His Reign As Head Of Xbox
Phil was the high bar for gaming CEOs when you think about it, up until MS got AI-hungry. From that point on he has been completely ineffective. I think anyone would have been.
Re: 'Return To Our Roots' - Xbox CEO Reiterates Her Goals For The Future
Cool. Let’s start with an OG Xbox mini console like what Nintendo did a few years back. I’ve got up to $149 burning a hole in my pocket for it.
Re: New Xbox Boss Makes Official Statement As She Takes Over From Phil Spencer
@BacklogBrad Eh, I'll formulate an opinion about her based on having interviewed her at a pair of conventions when she was at both Meta and Instacart. I mean, if you're going to do the "the 1 trillion dollar company ALWAYS knows better" d*** on the table, hurray for you having no real opinion other than fanboyism I guess?
And I respectfully say all that as a long-time MS and Xbox fanboy. This won't end well.
Re: New Xbox Boss Makes Official Statement As She Takes Over From Phil Spencer
@BacklogBrad yup, about 6 months ago - almost to the day. Doesn't mean she's been following Phil around like a puppy for 180 days. She has all the qualifications - used to run product at Meta, spent some time at instacart, moonlights as a home depot board member. All the ingredients necessary to ensure Xbox is well and truly run into the ground.
Re: New Xbox Boss Makes Official Statement As She Takes Over From Phil Spencer
She literally was head of their enterprise AI division just yesterday. I have a hard time believing she's written an email, memo, or press release since chatgpt took over. This won't end well for anyone but shareholders.
Re: Phil Spencer Announces That He's Retiring From Xbox
Phil was amazing. He got a lot of bad press but he’s kept this garbage afloat for a long time. Xbox is now well and truly dead.
Re: Poll: As Things Stand, Will You Be Buying GTA 6 On Xbox This November?
Zero interest in this now. Had GTA V been better and had there been more follow up in the years since GTA IV, maybe. I was an OG GTA player a long, long time ago on PS and have played them all since. I'm sort of bored with the whole thing.
That and it all just reminds me of a bad Pitbull (Mr worldwide, not the dog breed) fever dream. Zzzz.
Re: Microsoft Rewards Quietly Increases Its Prices For Xbox Gift Cards
Once upon a time, the BEST Rewards system in all of console gaming.
Microsoft: "Hold my beer."
Re: MGS4 To Make Its Xbox Debut In Metal Gear Solid: Master Collection Vol. 2 This August
Merry Christmas AT LAST! MGS4, and I don't even have to burn up my Waffle Iron PS3 to play it!
Re: Sony Is Hosting A Huge State Of Play This Week, Do You Think We'll Get Any Big Xbox Reveals?
Just give me lots more overhyped single-player open world adventure games where I’m staring at the back of my character doing fetch quests on a huge map and I’m ready to go!!!
Re: Microsoft Apparently 'Expects' The Xbox Series Era To Last, Despite Next-Gen Plans
Meh. I've moved entirely to PC for the multiplayer stuff I play (CoD, Battlefield, etc.) and my Series X is fine for FF and all of the single player games. I'll probably never buy another console again anyway unless MS really nails the Windows-On-a-TV interface for the next Xbox.
My Switch 2 is my biggest gaming regret of the past 5 years (possibly more) - consoles are just boring these days.
Re: Report: Next Year Is 'Best Case Scenario' For New Xbox Console, Microsoft Still Unsure On Price
I can’t wait to use copilot on my new Xbox!! And excel!
Re: Xbox Is Reportedly Releasing A Brand-New Controller Revision In 2026
I'd love to get an Elite 3 before my Elite 2 finally dies, but seeing as how its well on its way, I doubt that's going to happen. Elite 3 will undoubtedly come out a week after I spring for another Elite 2.