Comments 142

Re: New Report Delves Into The History Of Xbox Disc To Digital, And Why PlayStation Can't Copy It

Lanmanna

@EvenStephen7 All the consoles have taken a step back when it comes to the all-in-one box. Many streaming apps aren't supported now. Features like Xbox Snap, party mode (watching shows together), OneGuide, picture-in-picture, HDMI TV pass-through were discontinued. Some level of browser support is still available on all consoles but you have to find janky workarounds to make it work. I'd say all the consoles are in a worse place when it comes to an all-in-one device.

Re: New Report Delves Into The History Of Xbox Disc To Digital, And Why PlayStation Can't Copy It

Lanmanna

@nomither6
A lot of that is giving Xbox credit for inventing things it mostly standardized or popularized. For someone with a Sonic pic, I thought you'd acknowledge everything Dreamcast did first.

Dreamcast already had online multiplayer, matchmaking, messaging/chat, and even voice chat before Xbox Live. PS2 had an optional hard drive before Xbox launched, and PS2 games were installing data from discs to the HDD years before the Xbox 360 added full disc installs. Let's ignore Playstation popularizing dual analog/DualShock controller standard, remote play, share button/system-level capture, and cross-buy/cross-save functionality.

Xbox absolutely deserves credit for making things like a unified friends list, Gamertag, matchmaking, voice, achievements, and HDD-based features feel like standard platform-level features instead of separate game-by-game implementations. But “Xbox gave us all of this” is stretching it. Also, Xbox did CD ripping, not CD burning.

Re: Xbox Announces 3,200 Job Losses And Four Studio Departures

Lanmanna

@Tdx What a wild take. "This is good news! Less games means you won't complain about your backlog anymore! Who cares if people are losing their livelihood!"

A majority of these studios weren't releasing big budget AAA titles. I also like how you threw out "7/10" as if that's suddenly a bad thing. Plenty of great 7/10 games, which is entirely subjective btw.

Re: Halo Studios Makes A Point Of Highlighting 'Physical Discs' For Campaign Evolved

Lanmanna

@NeoRatt Music and movies haven't gone digital only. You literally mention vinyl. And console games are proprietary, so it's a bad comparison to other media. You don't hear cinemaphiles and audiophiles complaining because they have options. They can even rip their media if they want a digital copy. There's no option to buy different formats of a PS5/Xbox disc. When Sony ends disc manufacturing, no one else can pick it up.

And you really compared physical game collectors to being a flat earther? Really? You can push the "erm, it's only a license" narrative as much as you want, but the fact of the matter is that you can sell, trade, rent discs. It doesn't matter if you don't really "own" it. It's a cop-out argument. I don't get people who are apathetic or outright defending this decision. This will direct all purchases through console storefronts. There's no alternatives to a closed ecosystem. Despite PC going digital, you still have options by way of various storefronts and key sites like Humble.

Your "pros" to digital don't make sense. Steam and PS Store take 30% of each sale, so publishers/developers aren't getting the whole pie.

Re: Marvel's Blade Reportedly In Danger As Xbox Considers Shutting Arkane Studios

Lanmanna

@ilyn I don't agree with people not caring about lesser known characters. People need a reason to care and the Eternals wasn't it. Look how the movie was received, regardless of how known the characters were beforehand. The Avengers weren't super well known. Characters like Iron Man, Captain America, and Thor were C-tier at best. An even better example is Guardians of the Galaxy, which wasn't known by the general audience at all. Look at it now.

Re: Xbox Announces Worldwide Price Increases For Series X|S Consoles

Lanmanna

@BacklogBrad @Millionski I think people will buy at the current PS5 price. Sony will try to hold off raising the price before end of the year, so they can grab all those prospective customers who want to buy a PS5 and GTA at launch + Christmas. Sony is advertising GTA more than they've ever done for their first party games. Lol