Comments 681

Re: Larian Teases Four Major New Features Coming To Baldur's Gate 3

GeeEssEff

Future Crossplay support is excellent news. I will probably get it on Steamdeck at some point anyway but not being able to play with my friends on PC has been a bit of a downer. Looking forward to seeing what the modding tools bring as well if it does indeed come to console. Larian truly are one in a million.

Re: These Six Games Are Coming To Xbox Game Pass (April 17-30)

GeeEssEff

This is quite a good drop. I want to play Another Crabs Treasure, I am intrigued by Eiyuden and Orcs Must Die looks like a bit of silly fun.

@Foxx_64740 I bought Have a nice death on PS on release and dropped off it pretty quick. It’s not a bad game it just didn’t seem to do anything new or different to previous roguelites/metroidvanias. Hope you enjoy it though!

Re: Microsoft Rewards Fans Are Preparing For A New Era On Xbox This Week

GeeEssEff

@IOI That’s why I said “if you buy most of your games digitally” right at the start of my comment.

@Rodimusprime13 See those ratios are actually pretty good. However I did some googling and you only get the 20 points per £/$ if you are on GPU and are earning 400 points per month. If you’re not on GPU it’s 1 point hence my 53 points for DD2. I also don’t understand why credit in UK costs so much more points.

Like I said in my first comment in this thread, any company willing to do a half decent reward programme is good. Ms rewards is good if you play your console daily, are willing to do little tasks daily on various different apps and it’s significantly better if your subbed to GPU and play GP games. PS stars is good if you have PS plus and buy games digitally. They have both, unsurprisingly, built their reward programmes around what their core demographics are doing.

Personally I don’t play games every day, i subscribe to GPU intermittently but PS plus a year at a time, I buy most of my games digitally, 95% them are on PS and I’d rather put pins in my eyes then use Bing. It’s not rocket science which one I am going to get more value out of. I’m absolutely not crapping on MS rewards here either I’m just saying for certain things they are comparable and one of those things is purchase to credit conversion….at least in the UK where MS credit seems to cost 4.5 times as much as PS

Re: Microsoft Rewards Fans Are Preparing For A New Era On Xbox This Week

GeeEssEff

@Rodimusprime13 Honestly I think compared to MS rewards, PS stars is as good if not better if you buy most of your games digitally. It might be different in Canada but in UK I get 10 points for every pound spent so a £70 gets me 700 points (if it’s one of the selected games of the month I might get an extra 50 which I think is what you were alluding to). £5 credit is indeed 1250 points but on Xbox it’s at least 5900 points…nearly five times as much. At the end of the day whichever store front you use the most is going to give you the most value but the credit system on stars is certainly not to be sniffed at. I don’t really understand the level system on MS rewards (apparently I’m only level 1?!) but I bought Dragon's Dogma 2 on Xbox and only got 53 points for it. That would have been 530 on PS and nearly half way to a £5 credit.

Re: Former Xbox Exec Likes The Idea Of 'Tipping' Developers After Beating Their Games

GeeEssEff

I would consider a small tip for true indie games I love like Balatro and Incsryption. The prospect of tipping for a game made by the likes of EA, Ubisoft or Blizzard just seems mad to me. For starters I have absolutely zero trust that any developers would ever see any of that money. Secondly I imagine a fairly significant chunk of Devs creating these games are contractors so would be working for a completely different company by the time I come to tip them.

Re: Talking Point: Will Hellblade 2 Be A Genuine Game Of The Year Contender This Year?

GeeEssEff

@RIghteousNixon Ok I will remember to take what looks for all the world like a statement of fact to be an opinion in future. I still think that for something you believe to be so prevalent and obvious you would be able to provide at least one example though. Even if it’s off the top of your head. I can provide examples of non anti-Xbox bias off the top of my head as I have done previously in this comment section: hi fi rush, psychonauts 2, every Forza Horizon, Flight simulator, Gears 1-3, Halo 1-5, Age of Empires 1-4, all reviewed and were received well because they are interesting or did something different or had a solid story but most importantly because they are fun.

I’ve lost track of how many times I have said this in response to the ridiculous Xbox tax conspiracy theory but: When MS make good/fun games they get good reviews. It really is as simple as that. There’s no media cabal out to get the poor little trillion dollar company, they just haven’t been showered with praise recently because they haven’t deserved it. And when I say they haven’t deserved it I mean that in both the quality and quantity of output. If they hadn’t bought Bethesda the only first party games they would have released so far this gen are Halo Infinite, Forza Horizon 5, Forza Motorsport and Pentiment. That’s a truly pathetic offering nearly 4 years in but by all means let’s keep pretending it’s the media who are being overly mean to MS and not just MS being a terrible games publisher.

Re: Talking Point: Will Hellblade 2 Be A Genuine Game Of The Year Contender This Year?

GeeEssEff

@IOI Agree it will get hate for being digital only exactly like Alan Wake 2 did. It will get hate for being short exactly like Spiderman 2 did. It will not however get hate just for being an Xbox game. Psychonauts 2, hi fi rush, Forza Horizon 5 are just a few examples of Xbox studio games that are adored by critics and players alike. When Xbox delivers it is acknowledged. The Xbox Tax conspiracy has gained traction recently after a year of hugely hyped but fairly average games in Redfall, Starfield and Forza Motorsport. The media wasn’t underwhelmed by these because of bias, they were underwhelmed because they are underwhelming games.

Plus I’m pretty sure the Starfield on PS5 rumours were started by Jez Corden and that guy from XboxEra, who for the most part are known for being pretty pro Xbox. The media train ran with it because it was a huge story in the gaming world and it gained clicks and engagement. If you want to read less stuff about the doom of Xbox stop clicking on the articles and engaging. Enough people do that and the sites will realise the console war content isn’t driving the ad revenue and fingers crossed we see less of it.

Re: Xbox Doubles Down On Highly Ambitious Plans For Next-Gen Hardware

GeeEssEff

@Grumblevolcano Yep I agree with that to some extent but I think they could have the desired effect just by confirming that they are 100% going to still be releasing future gen hardware which they did already. It’s pretty much a given that the next Xbox will be the most powerful hardware available as it has been for the past two generations so either tell us what is going to be so great about this new console so we know why we should be hyped or shut up till it’s ready to show. With the amount of times they have made promises like this that they haven’t delivered on this gen I can’t see it making a blind bit of difference to most people’s hardware choices. The Xbox players are going to continue Xboxing, the PS players will continue playstationing and the Switch players Switching. In my mind all they are doing is setting themselves up for the usual eye rolls when they release something that, in actual fact, is not the best thing since sliced bread that revolutionises gaming.

It would be cool if I’m wrong but I lost all my trust in the Xbox hype train after the mediocre run of Redfall, Starfield and Forza Motorsport and the June 2022 “everything you see here will release in the next 12 months” showcase.

Re: Talking Point: Do You Prefer Shorter Or Longer Games In General?

GeeEssEff

No preference really. My favourite game is Elden Ring but arcadey games like Tekken, FIFA and CoD will get most hours out of me overall because they are easy to dip in and out of.it completely depends on the game genre, how much it costs and whether it outstays its welcome by the end. I wouldn’t feel I was getting my moneys worth for a £50 digital game I couldn’t resell if I complete it in 8 hours.

Re: Xbox Series X|S Versions Of Hellblade 2 Confirmed To Run At 30FPS

GeeEssEff

I’m not really much of a framerate snob but this seems a bit weird. It’s not a massive open world game with vast amounts of moving parts; items that need to stay where they should after being moved, branching quests and NPCs that need to be kept track of etc. I’m absolutely not an expert on any of this stuff but I would have thought if there’s one game where you would be able to squeeze out 60fps it’s an 8 hour linear narrative adventure. Not sure how it can be lauded as a true next gen technical marvel and be running at 30fps tbh.

Re: Hellblade 2 Sounds Like A True Next-Gen Showcase In First Xbox Previews

GeeEssEff

I found the first pretty boring. I can see why people enjoyed it but I am a gameplay over narrative type of player and walking through pretty environments with the odd bit of basic combat and puzzling doesn’t do it for me. I will try it next time I’m subbed to GP, mainly to ogle the graphics but can’t see myself getting very far before getting bored.

Re: Rumour: Microsoft Is Apparently Prototyping Xbox Handheld Hardware

GeeEssEff

If MS get a handheld right it could be a game changer. They will be entering the market at a time where they have a fair amount of competitors to draw inspiration from and mistakes to learn from as well. They may be on to a winner if they can combine Steamdeck’s user friendliness with the Ally/LegionGo’s adaptability, all wrapped up in a more powerful but affordable package. It is quite a risky move though. No guarantee it will sell well outside the hardcore fans and it would need to be pretty special to tempt people into trading in their current handhelds. Interesting times!

Re: Hi-Fi RUSH Is One Of PS5's Best-Rated Games Of 2024 So Far

GeeEssEff

The salty comments here are really sad. If it had scored lower overall everyone would be saying “All the PS sites are scoring it badly because it’s an Xbox studios game 😭” and it still would have been classed as “Xbox Tax”. It was never going to get the exact same score because different sites are reviewing it and it has over a years worth of gameplay updates under its belt.

The fact of the matter is there is no journalistic conspiracy against Xbox. Their best games (Forza Horizons, Gears, most Halos, Flight simulator etc) have reviewed exceptionally well and arguably some of their mid games have reviewed better than they should….looking at you Starfield. Also worth pointing out that multiplat games often score higher on Xbox on Metacritic with Dead Island 2, Diablo 4, Alan wake 2, Balatro and new Prince of persia being some recent examples. “Xbox Tax” is nothing more than a justification fanboys came up with for Microsoft’s spell of bang average games. Journalists have proven over and over again when an Xbox game deserves praise it will get it

Re: Talking Point: In Your Opinion, What Made The Xbox 360 Era So Incredible?

GeeEssEff

While it was undoubtedly an amazing generation I do wonder if a lot of people look back with rose tinted glasses due to the time in their life rather than the console and games themselves. Personally for me the 360 generation represents just starting uni, discovering adult freedom while still having very little responsibility, regularly playing online with a group of friends and just having massive amounts of time to devote to gaming. I genuinely believe games nowadays are of a higher quality but nothing will beat that generation for sheer fun…despite 2 red rings of death.

Re: Helldivers 2 Dev Urges More 'Compassion' In Response To Negative Xbox Tweet

GeeEssEff

@jedinite the narrative that the game is “yesterday’s news”. Personally I think Helldivers 2 has been such a success so far because it’s not competing with some of the best FPS ever made. For starters it’s pure coop which is pretty rare for a half decent shooter nowadays. Secondly nothing new or decent with universal appeal has released in ages. Reskinned CoD aside if you look at steam top played games it’s the same games that have been there for years: counterstrike, PUBG, team fortress 2, overwatch 2, Warframe, Rainbow Six Siege, Battlefield, Destiny 2.

I have absolutely no doubt that Helldivers 2 player count will drop off a cliff when the hype dies down. The question is by how much because at the moment it’s genuinely offering something that not many games are offering, a fun, pure co op, live service experience where everything is unlockable without microtransactions. If Arrowhead can support it in meaningful ways it might actually be around for years just like all the games I listed above. The very fact you mention that you still play Helldivers 1 shows the IP has legs.

Re: Helldivers 2 Dev Urges More 'Compassion' In Response To Negative Xbox Tweet

GeeEssEff

@jedinite I’m sorry did you check Steam concurrent player stats at 4.30am GMT on a Tuesday morning when the entirety of Europe is in bed, Asia are in the middle of a working day and it’s averaging about 11pm in US and expect it to be booming?! If that’s live numbers I would say that actually completely disproves the point you’re trying to make as those are incredible stats for an obscure time on a Monday/Tuesday. If you’d checked 2 hours earlier you would have seen 350,000 but really If you want to accurately compare current against all time concurrent at least be reasonable and do it on a Saturday or Sunday where you would have found a peak of 430,000 this weekend just gone….but that might not fit the narrative eh?

Re: Xbox Cloud Gaming Now Accounts For At Least 10% Of Overall Xbox Playtime

GeeEssEff

@Krydle I dunno what deals with the devil people are making to get xcloud working but every time I have tried it’s unplayable. Remote play on Xbox and PS works a bit better but I can still only play strategy/turn based type games that don’t require quick reactions.

I desperately hope we don’t go down the all cloud route in the future. I just don’t see it working for regular people who don’t want to pay for the highest tier fibre optic broadband and be tinkering in their router settings to get the lowest latency. The joy of consoles is turning it on and everything working out the box.

Re: Xbox Petition For Helldivers 2 Goes Viral Overnight, Aims To 'Redefine The Console Wars'

GeeEssEff

@GeorgeKal Maybe, that’s why I said it would be interesting to see after the hype has died down. I think Helldivers has probably resonated more than SOT with a certain age group though. You don’t need to regularly get a group of friends together to have fun on it, you can just dive (yay pun) in for a quick 20 minute session or play solidly for 3 hours.

You are right though the ongoing success of Helldivers will depend entirely on its future support but it’s got excellent core gameplay, nothing is locked behind a paywall and it has an interesting global objective system. While you seem to think it’s bad, many gamers and critics are really enjoying it.

Re: Xbox Petition For Helldivers 2 Goes Viral Overnight, Aims To 'Redefine The Console Wars'

GeeEssEff

@GeorgeKal SOT is a 6 year old game that has HAD 30million players log into it at some point. Comparing those numbers with a game that has been out for 2 weeks is just plain silly. It would be more interesting to see the concurrent players of both in a few months time when the hype has died down a bit but the wording of your comment makes it sound like 30million people are logging into SOT regularly which just isn’t the case.

@Stocksy Yeh it’s not that he doesn’t like live service or grindy games…he doesn’t like games that are on PS.

Re: Forza Motorsport Update 5 Out Today, Here Are The Full Patch Notes

GeeEssEff

Looks like a solid update. I will be hopping back in more regularly when they change the car upgrade system next month. I’m also hopping they leave the featured career events live a bit longer or release more at the same time. At the moment it feels like I complete the open races, then do one of the featured events and then don’t play it for another week until a new feature event is released. It just feels very sparse for single player content and as you said @BBB multiplayer is basically a write off atm because it essentially boils down to who can survive the first corner without being rammed off the road.