Comments 172

Re: Gears Of War: E-Day Dev Is 'Not Retreating' From The Modern Gears Saga

stinkyx

@Fiendish-Beaver Yep. I think they should've made Gears 6 and started the game with E-Day (to please nostalgic fans), and then did a story act before Gears 4 with Marcus and younger JD where something happens to JD like he inhales a Locust spore or something (alternate chapter for Del where something similar happens, maybe he is exposed to spore while dying?).

Then it fast forwards to after Gears 5 and the spore causes JD/Del to survive his death by crystallizing. Then someone figures out a way to reverse Locust back to humans, but it requires a super rare mineral (maybe a scientist in act 1 was working on something?) , and so Kait has to decide whether to reverse JD/Del or her mother.

Re: 'Gears Of War: E-Day' Is The Next Instalment In Xbox's Famous Franchise

stinkyx

@JokerBoy422 Halo Reach at least came out after Halo's 1-3 story arch, just like Gears of War Judgement came out after the OG trilogy. The E-Day story has already been told via books too. IDK, I always make the mistake of taking the story seriously in games and getting personally invested, so I was really expecting Gears 6. Anyway, I'll get over it. Multiplayer is what I like best anyway.

Re: 'Gears Of War: E-Day' Is The Next Instalment In Xbox's Famous Franchise

stinkyx

This is just like the next Mass Effect game. The old story is OVER. IDK why we need to go back. I loved it too but it's time to move on. The Coalition could take the Gears 6 story into whatever direction they want...they could have another "war" easily. They can have flashbacks where you play as old characters. There's no excuse for this laziness. Ugh.

Re: Xbox Is Reportedly 'Considering' Hellblade 2 For PlayStation 5

stinkyx

Gamers need Xbox and Playstation to compete with each other. If there's only one console (Playstation), Sony has no reason to make any first party IP games and can just rely on 3rd party support.

Case in-point: Steam. Valve stopped making games long ago.

The opposite would be Nintendo, who's console is so weak that third party support is horrendous and they NEED to crank out high quality first party games on a consistent basis to maintain business.

Re: Xbox Game Pass: All Games Coming Soon In February 2024

stinkyx

@rustyduck Probably because of the game selection? It's definitely not for everyone.

I only have Ultimate to play Gears and Guilty Gear on my phone. Otherwise, I'd rather just buy the games I really want to play instead of feeling like I need to play all the third-party mid-tier titles we seem to get every month just to feel like I didn't waste my money.

MS needs more first party games BADLY, IMHO.

Re: Gears Of War Creator Voices Interest In Returning To The Series (Again)

stinkyx

Just finished 4's campaign after owning it since launch. Loved the gameplay, but didn't connect with the new characters (I couldn't tell you anything about them other than they live outside the COG settlements).

Hopefully 5 won't take me 8 years too. I already know about "the choice" at the end, and I'd like to think The Coalition wouldn't have done that without an idea for the sequel. Good or bad, I think they need to execute on their vision and not cater to the section of the fanbase that probably wouldn't like the story regardless (and would probably love scrapping all the new characters and focusing on the old ones). It's too late for them to back out now.

Cliff as a consultant would be amazing. Living legend.

Re: Hi-Fi RUSH Celebrates First Anniversary With A Free Bundle

stinkyx

Is it bad that I've been boycotting this game? I wanted The Evil Within 3, and I know that most studios nowadays hardly ever work on more than one IP every console generation, let alone release more than one game every ~5 years.

Well, with Shinji Mikami gone and Hi-Fi Rush erasing The Evil Within in terms of acclaim, I guess all hope for me is lost!

Re: Microsoft Hits Historic $3 Trillion Valuation On Same Day Of Xbox Layoffs

stinkyx

@Kienda Yessss, exactly. People forget that corporations are beholden to their shareholders, aka if you own stock, you only care about how much more money the company can make you.

If replacing everyone with AI and leaning on subscriptions instead of new products is the easiest, fastest path forward, of course the shareholders will want that.

The question is....what do we do? It affects me because I want new games (Gears, Halo, all the Rare IPs and all the studios bought up by MS) instead of Game Pass with 1 new first-party game every 5 years and 1 Forza game every other year. I guess all I can do is buy premium titles to support new content.

Re: Apple Opens The Door For Xbox Cloud Gaming App On Its Devices

stinkyx

GeForce Now, hahahaha...now matter how late at night I try to get on their servers, there's at least 200 people queued in front of me (and ticks down like one person every 5 minutes), and the $10 monthly premium subs are sold out. Not to mention you have to own the games you want to play, and despite the hundreds and hundreds of games they support, they still somehow manage to NOT have any of the main games I want to play. And when an update rolls out, games sometimes just won't work because the host computer didn't download the update yet.

Game Pass Ultimate is a miracle by comparison.

Re: Talking Point: Has Xbox Done A Good Job With Gears Of War So Far?

stinkyx

@Gamer83 Hmmm, you think they wrote themselves into a corner and that's what's causing the delay? God, I hope this isn't one of those trilogies that's just made-up as it goes along.

Cliffy B recently tweeted on 11/28/2023 for Microsoft to call him about Gears 6, along with a pretty unique idea he had. Cliff seems to be doing just a bunch of random small non-gaming projects recently, so a design consultant for Gears 6 would be a nice return to bookend the second trilogy.

Re: Xbox's Phil Spencer Knows How Much We Want A New Banjo-Kazooie Game

stinkyx

What about a co-op puzzle-platformer (like It Takes Two or Unravel 2) where one person is Banjo and the other is Kazooie? And Mumbo can have a son who rides around in Banjo's backpack and learns spells to transform each of them at-will into different things to solve puzzles? It can be called Banjo-Threeie since there's 3 characters palling around.

Re: Talking Point: What Would Convince You To Use Xbox Cloud Gaming More Often?

stinkyx

Protip: I called my ISP asking for a new modem and router and they sent me one for free (well, $20 service fee). Ever since then, ALL game stream services and in-home streaming have been working soooo good.

It's not perfect, but definitely stable, consistent, and more than suitable for everything short of super-sweaty-zero-ping-tryharding. Highly recommended. Makes Xcloud amazing since you don't have to actually install anything, just boot up games instantly.