Comments 123

Re: Five Years On, Xbox Series S Is Still A Fantastic Place For Current-Gen Gaming

Westernwolf4

I purchased an S during Covid because it was the only Xbox to be found in my area at the time. I have thought about switching to the X for a few years, but honestly I am happy with my purchase. Games run on it just fine-I play on multiple platforms, and there are not big enough differences between the S and the others to be very concerned.

I will say-I am playing Outer Worlds 2 on it right now, and it runs fine. But the loading screens take FOREVER. I just played Yotei on my PS5 with no loading screens to speak of in the whole game, and it is a little jarring.

Also: I would not buy the S at the current price. But I have certainly enjoyed the console, and it was a big bargain at the time.

Re: Talking Point: After Almost Two Years, How Do You Feel About Xbox's Starfield In 2025?

Westernwolf4

I still love it. I was looking for some creative Bethesda quests in a space setting, and that is what I got. So I was very happy.

I was not expecting No Man’s Sky type exploration plus an RPG. I think it was kind of marketed that way, and that led to some understandable disappointment for people. The game also had a very uncomfortable start-new systems are not introduced well, and the first hours of the game are a real slog.

However: once I got past all that, it was a great space adventure. One of my favorites of 2023.

Re: Pick One: What Was Your Favourite Xbox Game Pass Game In May 2025?

Westernwolf4

I have said this before, but allow me to keep repeating myself: Gamepass has been amazing in 2025. My Xbox is my Gamepass machine, and I turned it on to play a grand total of three games in 2024. And one of those was Indy at the very end of the year.

This year, the trick is to get to all the good games before they leave the service. It is going to be impossible. And with The Alters, Moonlighter 2, and Outer Worlds 2 still to come. GP is on a real roll this year.

Re: Eight Games Are Leaving Xbox Game Pass In Early May 2025

Westernwolf4

My youngest son and I had a ball playing Little Kitty Big City.

I randomly played The Big Con a few weeks ago while I was looking for something short to play while waiting for South of Midnight to drop. Not much to it game play wise, but very charming. I recommend if someone is looking for a game you can roll credits on on a sitting or two.

Re: Digital Foundry Impressed With Oblivion Remastered, But Xbox Series S 'Takes A Hit'

Westernwolf4

@Kaloudz This happens to me all the time on my S-Digital Foundry and everyone is all dire about every game that comes out, and then it runs fine. I play games on PS5 and S, and I have fun and don’t have glaringly different experiences.

I guess I just don’t pay enough attention to the finer details. When you start your gaming on the Atari 2600 watching dots wander around the screen, I guess everything in 2025 looks and plays amazing. 😃

Re: Opinion: Xbox Game Pass Is On A Ridiculous Hot Streak Right Now

Westernwolf4

Yeah, Gamepass really deserves its flowers in 2025. I have multiple consoles at home, and I barely turned on the ol Xbox last year. I played a game or two early in the year and played Indy in December, and the rest of the time it collected dust while I gamed elsewhere (my son still made good use of our GP subscription!).

But 2025 has just been hit after hit. So far I have already played through Avowed (great!), Citizen Sleeper 2 (great!) South of Midnight (Great!) and Atomfall (meh). Expedition 33 is loaded and ready to go for the weekend. And then we have stuff like Doom, Outer Worlds 2, Moonlighter 2, The Alters on the way. Oh yeah, and a hidden gem no one has heard of called Oblivion or something.

The biggest problem in 2025 with GP is there are too many great games to play. Which is an amazing problem to have!

Re: PSA: Xbox Game Pass Gets Another Huge Day One Release This Week

Westernwolf4

@Lup This is exactly where I am. Very excited to play 33, but I got hooked by South of Midnight. I think I was on track to finish it in time, but then I spent time with my family and went to bed early last night like a FOOL (jk), so now I am behind. I may have to wait till the weekend to start my Expedition-South of Midnight is really good and I want to see the end of Hazel's journey.

Re: After Three Months, These Are The Top 10 Xbox Games Of 2025

Westernwolf4

@Fiendish-Beaver I think it is really cool that your son got to play it, and I hope you enjoy the game when you do!

My youngest son is the other gamer in our family, and I tried to get him to play Avowed so that we could discuss. But I can't tear him away from Flight Simulator right now. I am glad he is enjoying himself, but no one at home will talk Avowed with me!

Re: After Three Months, These Are The Top 10 Xbox Games Of 2025

Westernwolf4

@Fiendish-Beaver I know you were not talking to me, so I apologize for jumping in. But my playstyle is similar to yours. In this game I played on the hard difficulty, explored heavily, did every side quest and completed all the stuff like treasure maps and bounties. I think my final hour count was 78, if that helps.

I agree with others in the thread about Avowed. I figured I would enjoy it as an Obsidian fan, but I was surprised by how much I liked it. The main story didn't really hook me until near the end. But it did get me eventually, and the combat and side quests are really great throughout. I am a big fan of the game.

Re: Poll: What Score Would You Give Atomfall On Xbox Game Pass So Far?

Westernwolf4

@Dalamar73 “I didn’t say he called me a liar. I just implied he was going to if he dared to post more evidence that ran contrary to my opinion.”

Don’t you understand that your opinion about Eurogamer’s coverage is not a fact, no matter how strongly you feel about it? It is an opinion that can be supported by facts, and is open for debate just like every other opinion.

Re: Poll: What Score Would You Give Atomfall On Xbox Game Pass So Far?

Westernwolf4

@Dalamar73 Respectfully, he was not calling you a liar. He disagreed with your opinion that EG has given KCD2 no coverage and provided evidence with links. He then asserted his own opinion that EG reviewer can have a different opinion than others about the game.

There is a post above this one that came in with some good data to back your opinion. It is a discussion. No one was being insulting to anyone else.

Re: Poll: What Score Would You Give Atomfall On Xbox Game Pass So Far?

Westernwolf4

@gravelmonkey I was worried about the free form stuff, but so far I am solving a lot of leads pretty organically just by exploring a lot. That could change, but so far so good.

The melee combat feels kind of weightless to me, and it annoys me there is no dodge (walking backward during a fight is the best you can do). But it is not a deal breaker for me. Movement seems fine generally. I wish you could sprint more in the game without the heart rate stuff kicking in, because there is a lot of backtracking and no fast travel. But there is something to explore over every hill, so that hasn’t bothered me much either.

Re: Poll: What Score Would You Give Atomfall On Xbox Game Pass So Far?

Westernwolf4

@LaurenceJ1987 I am playing on Survivor (recommended difficulty), and I am having a pretty easy time sneaking around outlaws I don’t want to fight. And I am leaving resources behind because I am finding so many.

Not trying to tell you what to do or suggest I am good at this game (I am not). Just suggesting that you sneak around more and explore every corner if you aren’t doing that already!

I am having fun with the exploration, which is what the game does best. 8/10 for me about 4 hours in. The character models are a little dated and the combat is only fair so far, but it doesn’t really bother me.

Re: These Six Games Are Coming To Xbox Game Pass (March 18-27)

Westernwolf4

@Titntin That is so cool! My wife and I share a lot of hobbies, but gaming is not one of them. She is very supportive of my gaming habits, but is not very interested herself. Although-she has put a lot of time into Hello Kitty Island Adventure, the first game she has spent any time with in our whole 25 year marriage. Maybe the tide is turning!

I hope you and your wife enjoy many many years of happy gaming!

Re: 10 Games Will Leave Xbox Game Pass In Late March 2025

Westernwolf4

@AlwaysPlaying Such a shame that this happened to us and @jesse_dylan. I thought the idea for this game was really cool. I hope if any of you do go back to play you find a playable game, but I have not seen anything to show that the updates helped much. What a shame. Thanks for the responses!

Re: One Of 2024's Best Games Is Heading To Xbox Game Pass Today

Westernwolf4

My Xbox is my GamePass machine, and I barely used it last year. I played a few games on the Xbox in parts of March and April, and then it lay dormant until Indy came out in December. Most of my time was on PS5.

That is not going to be the case in 2025. Avowed. Atomfall. Expedition 33. Rogue Trader. Outer Worlds 2. Star Citizen 2. Now Balatro? Dang, there isn't even going to be time to play it all!

Re: Poll: Xbox Fans, What Review Score Would You Give Avowed So Far?

Westernwolf4

I am only 5ish hours in, so too early for a rating. I am having fun.

I will say: I have a strong feeling that Avowed is very similar to every RPG I have ever played. That is not really a bad thing-part of the reason I wanted to play this is because I love games from Obsidian, and these type of games in general. But I have rarely had such a strong vibe in the first few hours that zero new ground will be explored here.

Even if that is true, I will finish the game and have fun. I just find my initial reaction interesting, as it is not one I usually have with a new game.

Re: Xbox Has 'Right Approach' To Exclusives & PlayStation May Follow, Suggests Ori Dev

Westernwolf4

I have a all the major consoles, including Xbox, PS5 and Switch, so I have zero side to take in any console war. I agree with a lot of others. I think exclusivity dying out would be beneficial for gamers. But Sony has zero incentive to do this when they have such a big lead in hardware sales. I am not holding my breath for Sony exclusives going to Xbox, that is for sure. If it happens, it is going to be a long time from now.

Re: Xbox First-Party RPG Avowed Reportedly Delayed Until Early 2025

Westernwolf4

If Indy doesn't come out this year for whatever reason, then my Xbox won't be turned on again until 2025. I haven't used it since April.

There is just not much I want to play on the console atm (I was really looking forward to Avowed), especially with raised prices for gamepass. I am not trying to be a hater-this is just where I am at right now.

Re: Xbox Game Pass Gets Price Increases And New 'Standard' Subscription Tier

Westernwolf4

1.Most of us expected this for quite some time.

2. I will continue to sub to Gamepass (and PS Plus too).

3. I do think this is going to go badly for Xbox. Lots of posts here saying that this is still good value (true), but that is only part of the point. Xbox has been marketing exclusives day one as a huge part of this service. Now that is no longer completely true, and people are either going to be less interested or annoyed that the service they are locked into is not really what they were promised. Most of us here are really into this hobby, but more casual gamers may have a harder time accepting this.

4.A few posts here telling people they are overreacting. I find that strange. I have never understood the need of some people to police the reactions of others, especially when it is comments under a piece asking for opinions, and especially when it comes to how people spend their money. Gamepass still holds value for me, but it doesn’t surprise me that a price increase makes it less valuable to others.

Re: Xbox Studio Shutdowns Are A 'F***ing Gut Stab', Says Arkane Lyon Boss

Westernwolf4

@EvenStephen7 Sadly, I think this is always what you are going to get with gaming development budgets so high and development taking so long. I hate it that Arkane Austin is closing-Prey is one of my all time favorite games-but when you make one game every seven years for millions and millions, each one better hit. Again, I hate it, but I actually thought Redfall doomed them a long time ago.

I think the industry we all enjoy needs to think about changing its model from 10 year huge game development cycles to 2-3 year smaller game cycles. I would rather have these studios stay open and together making high quality smaller games than releasing a huge game every decade that HAS to hit or else.

I hope all impacted find new jobs soon, but from a gaming perspective the closing of Tango hurts me the most. To me, Evil Within, Ghostwire and Hi-Fi were all spectacular, and they still get closed. I was expecting Austin to close, as messed up as the model is. But I was expecting lots more good stuff from Tango.

Re: Max Payne 1+2 Remake About To Enter Full Production At Remedy

Westernwolf4

I took a video game hiatus for three years because of my brand new marriage, moving to a new city, and law school all at once. There were two games that pulled me back in-Fallout 3 and Max Payne. I am very grateful to those games for reigniting one of my favorite hobbies, and so I am unreasonably excited for the remakes.

I just really hope they use the James McCaffrey voice work. Those games would not be be the same without his excellent portrayal of Max Payne.