Comments 3,939

Re: Talking Point: What Should Xbox Call Its 'Project Helix' Console?

MinervaX76

@Banjo- No management can spin a ship this large around that fast. My bet is this stuff was all lined up and ready to go forth. All we seeing is stuff that has been years in the making. Even the Helix name is something I bet was already decided.

All the stuff that is being talked about now are just confirmations on rumors we been hearing for years. Only thing I **might** give the new management would be a choice to toss the Helix name out there a week earlier instead of dropping the news at GDC. But I'm nearly 99% certain this was the plan.

I even argue that the whole "everything is an Xbox" strategy is going forward, simply rebranded. Note how "full screen experience" was renamed "Xbox mode", more literally turning anything running the mode into an "Xbox". Only thing they doing is removing the marketing line, not the strategy.

Re: Microsoft's 'This Is An Xbox' Post Taken Down As Fans Wonder If The Controversial Ad Is No More

MinervaX76

The campaign might be gone but not it's spirit. Yea many users hated it, but the core idea that you can play Xbox on any device that can host their ecosystem is very much still there.

Proof? Look at their announcement of their full screen experience rolling out publicly next month. It's literally being renamed to Xbox Mode. They are doubling down on their strategy, just acknowledging the messaging for it failed. They as hell are not backing down from the strategy, though.

Re: Data Firm Predicts PC Revenue Will Soon Surpass Console As Xbox Prepares To Bridge The Gap

MinervaX76

Capcom already stated recently that half their sales come from PC. No math needed to note this means PC platforms combined outsell every individual console. This mostly means Steam, Capcom has very few games listed in gog or epic and don't sell games directly.

For me, the main reason I preferred consoles is that playing with keyboard is just impossible due to accessibility issues. Gamepads work perfectly with my needs. Since their first attempt at a Steam Machine, Valve has worked hard to make gamepad usage on PC as smooth if not smoother than on console. They even make sure any console controller is fully supported. Want to use a Dual Shock 4 or a Nintendo Switch Pro controller? Steam got you covered!

Their system is also becoming more and more TV friendly, and I think it will just blow up when the Steam Machine finally lands. Especially if they finally truly open up the OS for anyone to install without pursuing forks. In the meantime, big picture mode on a windows PC works wonders.

Re: 'We Will See More Games Come To Xbox Quicker' - Microsoft Exec Talks Plans For The Future

MinervaX76

@themightyant My perspective as an indie that is diving back into it after a decade of just doing the standard corporate thing (not stopping that, just deciding to spend some of my free time relearning the indie curve) supporting the Xbox PC store is not exactly something you do with the push of a button.

As far as I understand, engines like Godot don't directly let you do that because of closed APIs that require being part of something like id@xbox. One ends up having to use middleware solutions that have additional costs to be able to push indie projects into Xbox, even just the Xbox PC game store (not exactly the same as the Microsoft Store for apps.)

I am not sure if what they are talking about here is going to fix this, but if they open up more, actually allowing anyone to use their achievements APIs and all that mumbo jumbo in a way that allows Godot and other engines to just push to Xbox out of the box, you might see more indie games hit Xbox PC day and date instead of only happening after they see enough success in Steam.

As an indie dev, I have zero reason to not target a platform other than contractual and financial barriers.

Re: Xbox Says Backwards Compatibility Program Will Be Revived For 25th Anniversary

MinervaX76

If I recall correctly, the BC program was ended because it reached the limits of what was possible due to licensing or technical limitations.

However, this was before MS acquired ABK and at a point where any new addition had to work on Xbox One.

ABK ownership opens up their options for licensing as MS might be very willing to secure IP needed for re-listing the games. On the technical front, the program could reopen with a caveat that new titles might not work on Xbox one, maybe not even on Series X|S and be available only on Helix.

Re: Xbox's 'Pivot Away From Console' Had Been Failing And Questioned At Microsoft, Claims Report

MinervaX76

Personally I think Steam’s SteamDeck has shown us what Xbox should have always been. I don’t care much for Bill Gates, but the whole point of Xbox from the get go was to bring Windows and Microsoft to the living-room.

At the time, the distinct console made sense but today, a unified streamlined OS is a lot more logical. We just need that Gaming Mode to feel more like a console (as Steam Big Picture does) than a maximized PC app (sadly how Xbox Full Screen Experience feels).

The whole “everything is an Xbox” relied heavily on GamePass growth and adoption of game streaming turning any device into an Xbox client, but I think that path died when GamePass growth died down.

Re: Poll: As Things Stand, Will You Be Buying GTA 6 On Xbox This November?

MinervaX76

I bought a Xbox 360 for GTAV and loved it. GTAV was also great but then they shifted to maintaining an online game and I lost all interest in the franchise.

It’s obviously working for them, but as far as I expect GTA6 is just a Trojan horse into yet another whale fishing online game.

Maybe I’m wrong, but I got plenty else to play. If I ever buy it, it’s because it went on a deep discount.

Re: Insomniac Shares Cold-Hearted Response To The Chances Of Spider-Man 2 Coming To Xbox

MinervaX76

It will be on Xbox one way or another, sooner or later, unless they decide to stop selling games on PC.

I'm indifferent either way, I jumped into to the My Windows PC is My Xbox back when Starfield launched with 30fps on Series X and am very unlikely to go back for anything but a few old exclusives. Even that might eventually phase out if the rumors of software backwards compatibility end up being true.

Re: Report: Microsoft Is In The Early Stages Of 'Expanding' Xbox Game Pass

MinervaX76

Doesn't Game Pass Premium already give some access to PC Gamepass? Because due to crossplay for me all that sounds like is not expanding GP but limiting/removing PC Game Pass and forcing PC users into either the limited Premium tier or the Ultimate one, both being more expensive/limited paths.

I also do wonder what any of this would mean in a future where the next Xbox is simply a PC [with potentially console BC]...

Re: Obsidian Says Two Of Its 2025 Titles Didn't Meet Sales Targets, Vows To Learn For The Future

MinervaX76

This comment section is sure full of some... wild opinions.

The key issue was noted in the article: these games took 6 years to build. IMO they were solid games but spending 6 years in a game balloon both the budget and the expectations.

As a new IP (despite being tied to Pillars, for most Avowed is a new IP) they might had invested too much into it. And they could had gotten away with a game half the size of OW2 for the sequel.

I think both these games are suffering that they were designed and greenlit at a time where Game Pass was growing like crazy and apparently would keep on going. As soon as that slowed down, they should have either scaled the projects down or pursue a multi-platform release.

But honestly, the entire industry needs to stop this 6-10 year dev cycles. They are ridiculous, the games over engineered, and anything other than wild success can doom whole studios or even entire publishers. We need to go back to the days of 3 year dev cycles.

Make a game and release at least 2 sequels that are mostly iterative. Stop trying to remake every single asset for every sequel!!!

Can you imagine if every movie ever produced insisted on re-buying every single prop used on set???

Re: Helldivers 2 Xbox Vs. PS5 Sales Data Shared As Game Reportedly Hits 20 Million Copies Sold

MinervaX76

I know a lot of people will be resistant to changes, but classic consoles are on their way out and that graph shows it.

I been a hardcore console gamer for decades, I'm one of the people that resisted PC and vouched for consoles simplicity but truth is PC is changing, and it's all thanks to Steam.

Since it's first failed attempt at a steam machine, Valve has been working hard to make PC gaming have more and more of the perks of playing on console: more compatibility, game controller support, attempting to fix shade compilation stutter by cache and sharing them. This at the same time that console launches become more unstable and require hotfixes.

For the last year, I been almost exclusively a PC gamer. I still love consoles, for nostalgic reasons, but most those perks are gone for newer releases (and by newer, I mean the last decade worth.)

Re: Talking Point: As Xbox Celebrates 25 Years, What's Your First Ever Xbox Memory?

MinervaX76

I remember my brother getting the Xbox Live kit for his Xbox. Until then I was not really into Xbox but the concept of playing games online fascinated me.

Sadly I was instantly harassed by men and quickly learned to detest online play because it was a perpetual pattern.

So, despite how much I love my Xbox, my earliest Xbox memory is not exactly a very positive one. To this day I refuse to play online with strangers.

First Xbox I owned myself was a 360 Elite model that I bought to play GTAIV.

Re: Xbox Fan Thinks They've Discovered More 'Play Anywhere' Titles Being Added Soon

MinervaX76

I'm with @BAMozzy. The volatility of the console market future makes me very unlikely to buy anything for consoles right now unless it's Play Anywhere. If it's not Xbox play anywhere, I'll get it on Steam. I am downscaling my console purchases to exclusives only, and even with Sony now I feel I'm better off waiting for the PC release 6/12 months later.

My current preference of purchases:

Xbox Play Anywhere > Steam > Nintendo Switch > PS > Xbox

That said, if I already have an entry in a series on Steam, I'm likely to prefer the sequels there because I can be twitchy about some game's achievement tracking.

Re: Poll: What Are Your Plans For Xbox Game Pass After This Week's News?

MinervaX76

I canceled. My renewal was today. With that timing I could had stuck to the current rate for the rest of the year but I don’t see a reason to keep giving them my money when chances are I won’t have time to take advantage of it anyways.

This is also making me reconsider my Rog Xbox Ally X preorder. There are still some advantages but without gamepass… it’s way less appealing since I can play most things on my steam deck, and those I can’t I can play on my PC.

I’ll still pick it up but chances are high I’ll return it.

Re: Talking Point: So, Did You End Up Pre-Ordering The ROG Xbox Ally?

MinervaX76

Preordered the X for mostly the same reasons @BAMozzy noted.

I have a SteamDeck and wish I could play PC GP games natively on it. There are still many games that just don't run on the SteamDeck. Having a steam big picture like UI AND being able to run games from any PC storefront sounds perfect to me.

It's expensive, I'll give you that, but I'm lucky I can afford it.

Re: The ROG Xbox Ally Is Rapidly Selling Out At Retailers Around The World

MinervaX76

Managed to get my BestBuy preorder through. I just happened to be on my phone when the email that the preorders went live popped and I immediately hopped in to get mine.

I originally was thinking to just get the white model but thoughts of storage alone made me hop on the X.

A lot of people are going on how this will be a failure and the truth is this does not need to be a huge success. It's just some branded hardware for MS. It's also a test bed for their new handheld focused Windows version. No dev is going to have to specifically target this device, I imagine even pre-configured handheld options will just be the same setting template used on the SteamDeck for many games.

What is important here is the evolution of windows for gaming focused devices.

The price, honestly, is not terrible. Yes, it's a high number and not going to become a mainstream device, but it is very competitive with similarly specked handhelds.

Main reason I am getting it is because I still bump into games that just are not compatible with Steam's compatibility layer. It does not hurt that MS is also pushing a lot more aggressively on the Play Anywhere program, with many new announcements going into it now. Wish they could make that retroactive, though.

Re: Talking Point: Would You Play An Assassin's Creed: Black Flag Remake?

MinervaX76

100% yes. It would not be my top pick for a full-on remake (Ezio Trilogy as a remake would be ideal, or a big rewriting and expansion on AC 1...) but I still would play the hell out of it.

Heck I think AC3 would also make a way better remake, with expanded open world and finally properly making justice to the civil war battles with hundreads of NPCs battling it out....

But yes yes yes I would jump on AC4 remake.

Just ignore all the voices saying the Animus stuff has to be removed... my biggest complaint with Shadows was the Animus stuff was basically not there at all.

Re: Report: Ubisoft Founders Considering A New Business 'Venture' Using Certain Franchises

MinervaX76

Sounds like an attempt to spin off profitable IPs and studios to a new entity that has outside investors while leaving the core company in financial trouble so it can eventually file for whatever the equivalent of chapter 11 bankruptcy is in France and potentially liquidate those assets without losing control of the viable business.

As for Ubisoft games, I personally have not been disappointed on any Far Cry or Assassin's Creed game (ok maybe Unity was a bit disappointing). Never understood why so many hate the games.

Re: Poll: How Much Would You Pay For An Xbox Series X Pro?

MinervaX76

I never bought a PS4 pro.
I bought an XOX because I saw it for a deep discount on ebay that was under the MSRP of the Xbox One S.

TLDR: not much really. I think it would have to hit under $400-$450 for me to be interested. I already treat my PC as my "Xbox Pro".

Since Play Everywhere, every single first party game ends up having cross-buy and cross-save.

MS biggest achievement would be to lure more third party developers to adopt the Play Anywhere scheme where you can buy a game on XBox and also download it on PC.

Re: Reaction: PS5 Pro's Extortionate Price Justifies Xbox's Lack Of A New Console

MinervaX76

@Bobobiwan I was a PS4 fan girl, and I never got myself a Pro. I rocked my fat PS4 to its end.

I dont see the need for the increased visuals, honestly.

The video showcase actually stated that 3/4ths of players don't seem to care either, opting for performance modes over quality.

My biggest annoyance out of these mid-gen consoles are reviewers. I had to stop trusting reviewers because every reviewer would play the games on PS4 Pro and Xbox One X, rarely bothering to test the performance of the games on the baseline (and most sold) models.

I was afraid xbox reviewers would do the same this gen but was glad they tend to at least try including notes on Series S performance. I fear starting next year, PlayStation reviews will become worthless, once again.

Re: Sony's PS5 Pro Seems Unlikely To Get An Xbox Equivalent This Holiday

MinervaX76

@Ilyn Posted an updated price list here

It includes percentage increases that show how high a tax would have to be to get the price there.

There are 5 states that have a 0% sales tax (Alaska, Delaware, Montana, New Hampshire, and Oregon)

Highest state-level sales tax in the us is 7.25% (California). If you count local taxes, highest sales tax is 9.55% (some areas of Tennessee)

So cant see sales taxes having to do with the huge discrepancy.

I think it has more to do with the US being the one competitive battleground for Xbox. They may not be neck and neck, but they are strong enough that they need to actually compete.

Re: Reaction: PS5 Pro's Extortionate Price Justifies Xbox's Lack Of A New Console

MinervaX76

Reposting here since its relevant, the regional pricing is out of wack!

€799 = $880.98 (+26%)
₤699 = $913.10 (+30%)
¥119,980 = $841.66 (+20%)

$699.99 is already crazy expensive, but why those insane fluctuations by country?

Add the disk drive for anyone with a back catalog that still wants access to their disk media:

$779.99
€919 = $1,013 (+30%)
₤799 = $1,043.49 (+34%)
¥131960 = $926.89 (+19%)

There is a sales tax in the US to keep in mind, but adding the percentage increase in parenthesis above to show how high a regional tax would have to be to make that break even.

Re: Sony's PS5 Pro Seems Unlikely To Get An Xbox Equivalent This Holiday

MinervaX76

@FraserG I think there is a good article hidden in this announcement about how 3/4th of players opt for performance modes over quality modes.

Even Sony's own video seems to say (ironically paraphrased) "you can get the performance you want and already get but the devs get to be happy because you see the pixels they want you to see"

I dont think we ever seen any platform holder or dev give us any stats on how many players pick performance modes over quality.

Re: Sony's PS5 Pro Seems Unlikely To Get An Xbox Equivalent This Holiday

MinervaX76

OH my what is it with those prices???

€799 = $880.98
₤699 = $913.10
¥119,980 = $841.66

$699 is already crazy expensive, but why those insane fluctuations by country?

edit to add estimate with the disk drive attachment bought separately

$779
€919 = $1,013
₤799 = $1,043.49
¥131960 = $926.89

And these costs are all without the disk drive!!! I have not seen enough but I will assume the new disk attachment for the new PS5 will work with this, thats another $79 in the US for anyone with a disk library like me.

The most telling bit of all of this, for me, is that in the video they themselves admit that 3/4ths of players opt to performance modes. I think that shows how little the bulk of the player base cares for the extra pixels. We don't need this. I will likely own one, in 10 years when I can get a used one.

Xbox does not need to chase this, there is next to no point on doing that.