Comments 389

Re: Xbox Co-Creator Calls VR 'Disappointing' As Sony Slashes Price Of PSVR2

ilyn

I would say he is way out of touch, VR has been pretty successful overall when you take into account all different headsets for PS, Quest or PC. There are also loads of killer apps for it

No Mans Sky
GT7
Half Life Alyx
Resident Evil
Walkabout Mini Golf

Even the smaller little puzzle games are massively enhanced by exploring in a proper 3d space.

Re: Roundup: All The Reveals From February 2025's Xbox Indie Showcase

ilyn

@Weebleman Gamepass is still clearly bringing money in, but the 1 billion a quarter is revenue that doesn't deduct costs. Would be interesting to see what the actual figure is with development costs, etc... deducted.

The cost is often ignored when it suits, its similar to the 70/30 split when games are released on PS / Switch etc. People focus on MS making 70% and don't factor in that they also have to foot all the Dev and publishing costs. It would be interesting to see how muh of that 70% is profit.

Obviously this works both way, its just more a MS issue currently as they move towards a more multiplatform soltuion.

Re: Silent Hill 2 Dev's Next Konami Game Is Coming To Xbox Series X|S

ilyn

@fatpunkslim And what about PS? Nothing!

Days Gone Remastered, The Midnight Walk, Lost Soul Aside, Death Stranding 2, Ghost of Yotei. So I count 5 that we know of so far, and I wouldn't be surprised if another 1 or 2 get announced later in the year. And at least 8 more games on the way after that for 2026.

So a deecent amount of nothing apparently.

Re: Xbox Has Officially Delayed Fable Into 2026

ilyn

Was always pretty obvious this was unlikely to land in 2025. Its never felt like it was close to being ready which is why we only saw cinematics and looks at this celeb we have in the game. 2026 is fine, there are loads of game this year anyway across the various platforms, more than most could play.

@Fiendish-Beaver I still doubt the Next / Prime will be a 2026 lauch, 2027 at the earliest would be my guess and I would bet the PS6 won't be to far behind it.

Re: 'Mecha BREAK' Dev Talks Xbox Console Exclusivity & Future Game Pass Plans

ilyn

When I asked Kwok why the team decided to do timed exclusivity with Xbox over PlayStation, he stated, "Because they are more aggressive than Sony." After a laugh, he clarified that he believed it was a mutually beneficial arrangement with Microsoft since mech games are already saturated in the Japanese market. As such, bringing a mech game exclusively to the Western market via Xbox was less risky.

Full quote to give more context.

Re: Poll: How Would You Grade The February 2025 Xbox Indie Showcase?

ilyn

@YeyoFairy I went with E as I mentioned above and was in no way trolling, or impossible to please. I imagine others are the same if the show just did nothing for them. Its not that unusual as indies are generally more hit and miss for people.

For me rating the show as a whole includes rating the hosts, which i though were very poor, they just lacked chemistry. It also means rating the way it was presented and it was a glorified IGN advert with some trailers inbetween, It really didn't need an advert break every 10m just to shill IGN services.

As for the games only two caught my eye. Blue Prince which we saw last week, but i liked how this trailer showed us a bit more. The other game was Lies of P but i think last weeks trailer was far better overall as it showed proper gameplay, this one was just artsy and did nothing for me. The others just did nothing for me either because they are not my style, or i had not played the originals so no hype.

So E seems fair, it did very little that I had not already seen.

Re: Xbox RPG Avowed Seemingly Sold Well Despite Being In Game Pass

ilyn

@GamingFan4Lyf I guess, in some ways, it's interesting to see if it's super popular for a snapshot in time, but I don't think it's any actual gauge of a single player game's success.

Exactly that, its great for showing how popular a game is at launch where you have a high peak showing who jumped in. Like you could see BG3 popping off in real time with a peak of 875k just on steam. But for other games the numbers are usually a fraction of that so outside of genre defining games everything else is similar.

Re: Poll: How Would You Grade The February 2025 Xbox Indie Showcase?

ilyn

E for myself, The only game that really stood out was Blue Prince. Lies of P should be good but I thought the Trailer was very poor.

As for the show it was an awful presentation, the presenters were poor and it just felt like a gloried ad for IGN with the amount of breaks just pushing their services.

Re: How Microsoft Managed Xbox Brand 'Is Not My F**king Fault', Says OG Xbox Creator

ilyn

@Cakefish Largest Technical Leap has always been such a silly statement as it has no real measurable meaning as you can flip it any way you choose.

If they add in something like PSSR / DLSS and Ai for the next box, and PS6 also adds Ai they could still feasibly state its the largest leap in a generation as PS added PSSR during this gen. Its really just meaningless marketting speech which will mean what they want it to mean and nothing else.

Re: Nine Games Will Leave Xbox Game Pass In Late February 2025

ilyn

@RBRTMNZ I just found the actual combat in Nioh to be more my style. Both very good games I just prefer the stances, skills and dodge from Nioh over martial arts and parry style of Wo Long.

Being able to upgrade gear with items was a nice change, but capping your gear in the base game and the dlc having no real upgrades felt off. That was something I felt Nioh did better by having divine gear only drop from the end boss and then all the dlcs increasing on it.

Re: Nine Games Will Leave Xbox Game Pass In Late February 2025

ilyn

Wo-Long is a bit of a shame for anyone who had not tried it yet. It was not as good as Nioh but it still held its own as a fun action game.

The only real drop off was DLC3 final boss being overly tuned. It basically required a NG++ character playing on NG difficulty which was a stupid decision.

Re: Here's A Look At The Updated Xbox Studios Roadmap For 2025 & Beyond

ilyn

Nothing masively of interest this year, Fable might have legs but I can't see it landing in 2015 and I would still say its a coin toss as to if the game is any good. F1 was average But I personally felt the sequels lost interest as the time period moved forward. I have enjoyed the comedic tone of these trailers tho so hoping it lands on the side of decent.

For future releases Blade should be succesful providing its done well, it has the marvel tag whic will help but I worry it will land before the MCU film which would limited how aware of the character younger fans are. Elder Scrolls 6 is still probably a few years out but I am not convinced Todd has the ability to create something thats hold up to the earlier games.

The main "MS" game on the horizon for myself is WoW: Mist of Pandaria Classic but im not sure you can call anything pre War Within MS, even if they do now own Blizzard.

Re: Just One Game Is Confirmed For Xbox Game Pass In March 2025 So Far

ilyn

I can see GP having less and less Third Party games as they are replaced with First Party from the studios they now own, and it would make sense. If they slower filter it down to first party then they get it to a point where GP can be made available for all platforms, and the perk of it on Xbox is just some additional functionality.

Re: Phil Spencer Says Xbox Is Done Trying To Convince PS5 & Switch Players To Move Over

ilyn

@fatpunkslim he repeatedly emphasizes that their priority is above all on the cloud and PC, and on their own ecosystem: "Not every screen is equal", because that's where it brings in the most.

As usual I feel you are reaching hard to simply have the statement mean only what you want it to mean, and not read it in the more realistic light. He mentions cloud once in that full statement and immediately follows up with "But games should be the thing that we’re focused on." They will always support their own platform and you may get some additional benefits on that platform, but in Phil's own words the focus is on the games.

People picked up on the transition to Publisher first, Hardware second a long time ago and everything continues to point in this direction. Its the tactic that has gotten MS where they are today, and the bean counters will not treat their gaming division any differently.

You keep mentioning this 4 year rule because it fits the narrative you are telling yourself, but its only applicable to one game that was most likely held on to longer because is was a tentpole IP. Hifi-Rush was 14m, Pentiment was 15m, Indy will be around 6m, plenty of future games are Day 1.. there are no red lines. Add in that they are now going to include all logos for transparency. Do you honestly believe that when they stick a PS logo on FH6 they are doing it to say this will arrive 4 years in the future.

Re: Avowed Review Roundup: Here's What The Critics Think So Far

ilyn

@Banjo- but that also works both ways such as when multiple versions of IGN rate a game higher. You can't just complain when it doesnt go your way.

I was expecting 80-85 and its currrently sitting at 80 which is a perfectly good score, so the game has done well. No need to tarnish the success with conspiracy theories about review taxes

Re: Roundup: All The Xbox Reveals From February 2025's State Of Play

ilyn

@Coletrain The thing is who are you to decide if the game needs it or not. You can decide that for yourself but not for the entire industry.

Its a £10 upgrade for those who already own the game so if they want to buy it they can, if not they are not being forced to. This is not the Warcraft 3 scenario where the remaster actually bricked the original games functionality.

I see this a bit like The Last of US. I played 1 years back on the PS3 but never got around to number 2 as my backlog was huge. Now my backlog is clearer and I wanted to play the game, ahead of season 2, and I appreciated that as a new player I was able to buy TLoU 2 remastered as its the latest version.

Thats the whole point, if you have played the game you can choose to upgrade or ignore it, you lose nothing. If you haven't you can get the most current version, or if you really want the old version just grab a disc copy since their are plenty available.

The only thing that is questionable is removing the old version from the digital stores completely in favour of the latest version. Just leave both versions up and let people choose.

Re: Roundup: All The Xbox Reveals From February 2025's State Of Play

ilyn

Not sure why this is being compared to the Dev Direct as they are completely different types of show. One is a deep dive into games and the other is rapid fire trailer trailers with maybe an extra minute of talking.

Personally I though this was very good and there was 8-10 games shown that I am interested in so good times all round for the future of gaming.

@Coletrain And a days gone remaster? Who's that for?

You can insert any game title you want into that comment. Just because you are not interested doesn't mean no one is.

Re: Poll: What Kind Of Review Scores Are You Predicting For Avowed?

ilyn

@PsBoxSwitchOwner I think you need to upgrade it to a complete set of Tinfoil Armour with the level of absurdity going on about Xbox taxes.

Clearly every reviewer, including the reviewers right here at PX, are part of some global conspiracy to knock 2 points off every xbox review score. Even Wikipedia are in on the action now 😂

Re: Microsoft Is Assisting Development On Xbox Console Launch Exclusive 'Mecha BREAK'

ilyn

Game looks interesting, just a shame its such a blatent Gundam rip off. Having built Gun-Pla and looking at the mechs you can see elements of them are basically identical. No issue with drawing inspiration but they should have probably blended it with other sources like Evangelion / Kuromukuro / Front Mission for a more unique look.

Now lets just see if this gets the same sort of feedback here that Black Myth Wukong got. Something tells me there will be far less conspiracy theories this time around.

Re: Avowed: Release Date, Release Times, Early Access Details For Xbox & PC

ilyn

@Isolte Exactly this, its the precedent behind the behaviour. If it was 1 month early, with limited access for testing at a reduced price then thats okay. This 5 day EA fomo however is no different than microtransactions, looot boxes or any other shady practice to just designed to get more money out of consumers.

If GTA6 decided to launch at £100 for the standard edition and have microtransactions galore in the store for skins and vehicles it would still sell loads. People can choose how they spend their money, but that in no way means we shouldn't also be calling out companies for bad practices.

Re: Avowed Has A 60FPS Mode On Xbox Series X, Confirms Obsidian

ilyn

@Dimey They kinda confirmed it with the cheeky smile imo, it will be out soon. I think the only reason we are getting slight delays at the moment is they have a large back catalogue to port and and by spreading it out they generate regular revenue throughout the year. Its the smart move for now.

Re: Talking Point: It's Been A Year Since Phil Spencer Announced The 'Xbox Business Update' Event

ilyn

@K1LLEGAL Thats a really good point you make about Deathloop. Between Betheda and the ABK merger they are seeing just how much more they make on PS than they do on their own platform. When you factor in that they are last place for console sales, and that nearly all PC users use steam not a MS platform for games its a no brainer as what they gain selling everywhere vastly outweight any negatives or upset caused to their fanbase.

As for the other guy I would just ignore him in future as he insists on stating his opinions as fact, whilst telling everyone else their opinions are just that.

Re: Two More Xbox First-Party Games Are Moving To PS5 In 2025

ilyn

@Isolte @Titntin Im in a similar boat of having a good pc, but find myself gravitating more and more to the console. For me its the C3 OLED thats making the difference as it really changes games up in such a major way.

Currently replaying TLoU Part 1 and the dark areas on an OLED panel make the whole experience so much better. If steam make a nice small PC console that I can stick under the TV then that will probably be the best of both worlds.