Theory: XBox game studios for exclusives, whatever that means.
Activision etc: multiplatform by default.
Update - I had missed that Activision is making the next halo. That theory feels like it might actually be on the money especially with Microsoft saying it's about publishing expertise.
Update 2: a bit of research and it looks like this is the case. I didn't realise there was hardly any XGS left now. Like 3.
GP is currently going to cost a person between 130 and 200 a year.
I think where the pro argument falls down is just because someone played something on GP doesn't mean they would have purchased it otherwise.
Given much of GP is cheaper titles. Based on the average price someone would need to have hand on heart said they would have purchased 9 or 10+ of those titles outright a year. For some here that could be true. For the majority of casual owners that is far, far from true.
I think the fundamental problem is that the potential Game Pass market was probably overestimated. The gaming market is enormous, but a huge proportion of it consists of people who spend most of their time in a handful of games — Fortnite, Roblox, Call of Duty, EA Sports FC etc. For someone who plays a free-to-play game most evenings and buys one or two big releases a year, a permanent games subscription simply doesn't represent particularly good value. Game Pass makes much more sense for enthusiasts who regularly play lots of different games, but that is a considerably smaller audience. So the Netflix comparison was always flawed: Netflix serves normal viewing behaviour, whereas Game Pass arguably monetises a relatively hardcore style of consuming games.
Just make smaller, more sustainable games that can turn a profit. Nintendo understand this.
AAA games used to need 2 to 3m full price sales to break even that's now about 8 to 12m. Basically the hits are subsiding the misses and they will be trying to leverage that ratio better.
Around the year 2000 a typical AAA game cost 1 to 4m to develop.
2023 onward this is regularly 200 to 300m
These figures don't include marketing.
The total "addressable market" i.e. the game buying audience has increased 2 to 3x in that period but development cost is 10 to 30x.
The most conservative of those figures that would make a game £133 today taking into account the development cost and the market size.
You cannot have a modest hit in that environment and be sustainable.
*I would also note that while the total addressable market is 2 to 3x bigger the dynamics have changed to. I don't have any hard facts on it so won't provide any numbers but I suspect the ratio of games to cod/FIFA/fortnite type owners had changed over the years so for most games the audience isn't even bigger as those newer audiences were never buying anything outside of that mainstream trio anyway.
I need to wait for the reviews and more info on this one. There is a very real chance this won't be the game people are expecting based on shifts at Rockstar and the more recent GTA online weak characters etc.
Comments 8
Re: Report: Xbox Studio 'Rare' Working On Various Projects, But Activision Will Decide Their Future
Theory: XBox game studios for exclusives, whatever that means.
Activision etc: multiplatform by default.
Update - I had missed that Activision is making the next halo. That theory feels like it might actually be on the money especially with Microsoft saying it's about publishing expertise.
Update 2: a bit of research and it looks like this is the case. I didn't realise there was hardly any XGS left now. Like 3.
Re: Tim Schafer Talks 'Great Experience' At Xbox, But Questions Why Game Pass Wasn't More Successful
GP is currently going to cost a person between 130 and 200 a year.
I think where the pro argument falls down is just because someone played something on GP doesn't mean they would have purchased it otherwise.
Given much of GP is cheaper titles. Based on the average price someone would need to have hand on heart said they would have purchased 9 or 10+ of those titles outright a year. For some here that could be true. For the majority of casual owners that is far, far from true.
Re: Tim Schafer Talks 'Great Experience' At Xbox, But Questions Why Game Pass Wasn't More Successful
I think the fundamental problem is that the potential Game Pass market was probably overestimated. The gaming market is enormous, but a huge proportion of it consists of people who spend most of their time in a handful of games — Fortnite, Roblox, Call of Duty, EA Sports FC etc. For someone who plays a free-to-play game most evenings and buys one or two big releases a year, a permanent games subscription simply doesn't represent particularly good value. Game Pass makes much more sense for enthusiasts who regularly play lots of different games, but that is a considerably smaller audience. So the Netflix comparison was always flawed: Netflix serves normal viewing behaviour, whereas Game Pass arguably monetises a relatively hardcore style of consuming games.
Re: Rumour: Xbox Still Evaluating Whether Project Helix Will Support Physical Discs
@themightyant keep in mind backwards compatible for games and backwards compatible for media are two different features.
Re: Rumour: Xbox Still Evaluating Whether Project Helix Will Support Physical Discs
Not confirmed but we are introducing a way to digitise your old discs... You know it's coming. Let's get real here.
Re: Marvel's Blade Reportedly In Danger As Xbox Considers Shutting Arkane Studios
Just make smaller, more sustainable games that can turn a profit. Nintendo understand this.
AAA games used to need 2 to 3m full price sales to break even that's now about 8 to 12m. Basically the hits are subsiding the misses and they will be trying to leverage that ratio better.
Re: Marvel's Blade Reportedly In Danger As Xbox Considers Shutting Arkane Studios
AAA has become largely unsustainable
Around the year 2000 a typical AAA game cost 1 to 4m to develop.
2023 onward this is regularly 200 to 300m
These figures don't include marketing.
The total "addressable market" i.e. the game buying audience has increased 2 to 3x in that period but development cost is 10 to 30x.
The most conservative of those figures that would make a game £133 today taking into account the development cost and the market size.
You cannot have a modest hit in that environment and be sustainable.
*I would also note that while the total addressable market is 2 to 3x bigger the dynamics have changed to. I don't have any hard facts on it so won't provide any numbers but I suspect the ratio of games to cod/FIFA/fortnite type owners had changed over the years so for most games the audience isn't even bigger as those newer audiences were never buying anything outside of that mainstream trio anyway.
Re: Poll: If You're Buying GTA 6, Are You Getting The Standard Or Ultimate Edition?
I need to wait for the reviews and more info on this one. There is a very real chance this won't be the game people are expecting based on shifts at Rockstar and the more recent GTA online weak characters etc.