You might remember that back in January, the NRDC (Natural Resources Defense Council) published a report about the energy consumption of next-gen consoles, sharing a fair few concerns in the process.
Since then, a representative of the NRDC has been talking to GamesRadar, notably highlighting the 'Instant On' mode of the Xbox Series X. The NRDC's biggest concern with 'Instant-On' is that it's "pre-selected in everywhere except Europe", which could lead to a lot of unnecessary energy wastage.
Here's what the NRDC's Noah Horowitz had to say about the issue:
"Game consoles around the world consume well over a billion dollar worth of electricity and cause millions of tons of carbon emissions annually. Given all the millions of game consoles installed, any energy savings measures they take can really add up."
"[If Microsoft switched the Xbox Series X's default energy mode around, it could] "save the equivalent of a large coal burning power plant’s worth of electricity."
If you're confused about what this actually means, Horowitz is referring to the standby mode you select when setting up the console for the first time, with 'Instant-On' promising quick start-ups and features such as Remote Play, while 'Energy Saving' removes your ability to access these luxuries in return for significantly less energy usage.
It remains to be seen whether Microsoft will choose to make the 'Energy Saving' mode the default option in the future, but ultimately it seems like it shouldn't be too difficult to put in place with an update.
Here's what Dr. Ben Abraham of the Sydney's University of Technology had to say on the matter:
"To make these consoles more sustainable, I would want to see commitments from both Microsoft and Sony to make this the last console generation, at least for a long time, or until a completely carbon neutral, environmentally responsible production process is in place."
What do you think about this? Give us your thoughts down in the comments below.
[source gamesradar.com]
Comments 23
Considering how fast Series X boots up and how well Quick Resume works, I prefer to use energy-saving power mode.
I’m gonna happily keep using instant on mode knowing it annoys people like him.
And how much energy is saved, while people stay at thome gaming instead of driving somewhere to the disco, bar, restaurant, football game etc.?
That cell phones last roughly 1-2 years until replaced is ok, but a console which lasts 7 years is not enough? Strange people.
People freaking out about how much electricity a console is using. 🙄 Will be interesting when they have pushed everyone to having electric cars. Will have loads to whine about then.
I have mine on Energy Saving Mode, simply because it boots up so fast compared to the Xbox One X. Also still keeps games in Quick Resume.
Only negatives are you can't automatically gets updates downloaded and installed and I don't think you can remotely install games using the app either.
@Nexozi The logics of these groups sometimes blows my mind.
At launch Energy Saving Mode was terrible, at least for me, because it took more than minute to connect to wifi internet. It seems it was fixed with some patch since now it connects really fast so I don't need Instant-On at all.
Lack of auto updates and remote install is kind of a deal killer for me.
I don't believe climate scientists..
I have mine (XSX) in “instant on” mode, mainly for the updates. There’s nothing worse than going to play a game only to be told an update is required, and even worse if it’s a big update.
@BlueOcean while i agree if energy saver would use the Ethernet and update my games. Then i would use it... till the instant on cause i hate waiting for my games to update, i don’t have more then a hour or two a night to play and the last thing i need to be doing is updating games.....that is the only reason i use instant on is for the background updating.
I use energy saving mode; I don't want unnecessary electricity causing unnecessary wear on the electrical components inside the Series X I paid a premium for.
@BlueOcean true. But then the downside is if you want to launch a game, and then it needs an update.
I would just turn it back on, I like the instant on feature, I want my game updates to download and install without me needing to know. I also see zero difference in my electric bill. So seems like he just likes to hear himself talk.
If Microsoft really wanted to save energy, they'd call the setting what it sounds like it actually is - "Always On" instead of "Instant On." Selling consumers a naming fantasy that their system is going from absolute zero to full throttle at the flip of a switch doesn't give them any compelling reason not to choose it; making it clear that they're actively choosing to waste energy would at least catch the momentary attention of anyone who bothers to turn the lights off when they leave a room.
Not that I'm one to talk; I tend to leave even the consoles I don't play for months or years at a time in similar states. Hmm. Maybe I should revisit that myself.
@Carck The guy the story quotes is literally doing exactly what you complain people don't do, and putting the responsibility for broadly shaping aggregate consumer decisions on the big company here - Microsoft - instead of trying to blame individual consumers.
Instant-on stays on, I want my games to be up to date if I have time to sit down to play a game. Also, use the download feature in the game pass app frequently. Start the download whilst working. When you're home the game is ready to play.
I don’t use this feature because I might save 0.01p on my energy bills.
I just don’t need anything that quickly anyway, I’m happy to pick up the controller, press the on button and then... wait.
Especially when it comes to my PS5. Even in standby that thing constantly hums. It’s maddening.
Nope, turn the lot off and save pennies.
Like many others, auto updates and at some point remote play are the only reasons I use it. If they had it power up periodically to check updates even once daily, or wouldn't be needed.
PS5 still needs it though to remember game states.
@Fath "always on"
All modes are really always on, it's just different degrees of power state. Power saver of technically still "on" otherwise it couldn't be turned on remotely. It's just powering less components in lower power states. Instant on basically keeps memory and networking (and ssd) powered on lower power states. Neither is full on.
Technically they're blaming the big company for not sufficiently shifting responsibility to the consumer though...
Of course, I see why some people would choose instant-on and there are worse things that people and companies could do. I just said my preference because, finally, my area got optical fibre so games update quickly while I play others. The only reason left would be remote install but I barely use it. The good thing is that we have a choice, what I wanted to point out is how fast Series X boots up compared to Xbox One and Xbox One X and how wonderful Quick Resume is!
This guy goes after everything. Doesn't take much Googling to see Noah launched previous attacks against Cable Modems and Routers, TVs, printers, cell phone chargers, Roomba charger, etc. Anything you typically leave plugged in. He hates energy vampires.
What I find funny is his January complaints were directed at the PS5 too, yet combing around I only ever see the media direct the outrage at the XBox.
If you use Gamepass/Gamepass Ultimate a lot you need the instant on to install the games from afar. If the XBox is off-off, then you can't communicate with the it.
Edit: Meanwhile owning an XBox with instant on makes me a bad guy, but the fella who lives up the road from me blazes 22 individual outdoor lights every night, 365 days a year. It's like daylight up there.
@Trainer Yeah they always put the blame on little people like you and me but never big companies or countries like China who are literally destroying the environment.
Seems a pretty reasonable request TBH. If people change it that’s up to then but makes sense for MS to set the systems to energy-saving as default.
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...