Not sure why they wouldn't just reboot Quake as everything seemed to point to...but yeah I'll take anything Doom and be happy with it, I'm just curious and unsure about the direction they're gonna take it in after TAG2's ending seemed like a send-off for the Slayer and the series for the time being.
Nope. I'll only be interested if they add meaningful interactivity with the world, the controls don't suck, and the mission design isn't pulled straight from 25 years ago.
Doom is one of my favourite series ever, so don't get me wrong I'm super excited, but I thought it was a given we would get a Quake reboot next, after the remasters, the story of Doom being complete after TAG 1&2, and comments byHugo himself that suggested they'd move away from it for the time being.
@Traygor same, and I'm a bit ashamed of confessing that it's basically the only game I've played since it launched lol I've always been a single player guy, never been into online multiplayer, but man is this game something else entirely. The mechanics, the aesthetics, the lore... everything's just so well made and polished, not even mentioning how innovative it is. I've always hated the F2P model, but Embark being an independent studio I can totally see why they went that route, and it's that exact reason that compelled me to buy some currency (never bought any micro transactions ever before), because they are independent and honestly deserve all the success and money they can get. The way they constantly update the game weekly based on player feedback is just the icing on top of an absolutely delicious cake.
Nah, I dropped it ages ago. Halo is not my thing in the first place, but I had decent fun at the beginning. But with The Finals out now and Embark doing basically everything right, I can't see myself playing any other multiplayer FPS for a very long time, aside from maybe trying out XDefiant when (if?) it launches.
@NintendoByNature because some opinions simply have no merit by not being based in reality: opinions are not created equal. Also, noone is name calling anyone, people here are attacking the GOP's draconian political agenda (and rightly so), not individuals.
I always prefer physical when it's an option (and not a super expensive limited edition), so even with my Series X being my first ever Xbox, I have amassed something like 40 physical games.
I really really do hope they're working on a new Quake, a reboot of 1 in particular. And I really really do hope they're not working on a licensed game as some have rumoured.
@Banjo- never said they're bad, they aren't. They're boring, but the actual fundamentals of moving and shooting are top-notch. It's just that the level design is basically non-existant, and the games quickly devolve in a mindless shoot fest without much engagement on my part.
@themcnoisy I'll just say that if I had to be there to get how good they were, they were not that great in the first place, cause quality tends to resist the passing of time. Idk, Halo apologists are the only fans that insist on this notion of "you had to be there", and I don't get why. Is it a way to admit that today those games are just boring and bland?
@Zochmenos ok dude, it's impossible talking to you cause you're fixated on this mentality in which you're right and everyone else is wrong. Ok, games cannot be evaluated if not the second they come out, noted. Have a nice day.
All these comments saying playing on normal is wrong...my dudes, if the Devs intended the game to be experienced like that it's on them to either make the standard difficulty higher, or making normal difficulty more engaging. Again, just goes to prove my point that they're not that well designed.
@Baler wow, calling someone a fool just because I criticized something you like. Very mature.
Also I played half of 1-4, all of Reach, and replayed the whole of CE with my brother to see if co-op would finally make it fun. It didn't.
Edit: I can name you a bunch of FPS that Halo doesn't even hold a candle to.
@ParsnipHero I'm referring to the campaigns, they're dreadful.
@Zochmenos dude, I said I get it.
It's just they were not that good to begin with.
Doom 1993 I played for the first time in 2020, and it became my most played game that year.
So yeah, you can definitely decouple a game from its context and evaluate it on its own merits.
@Zochmenos yeah I know that, but the difference is I can have a whale of a time with Doom 1993 or Goldeneye 007 even in 2024, while Halo just bores me to tears. I appreciate the impact the series (and the original in particular) had at the time, but none of the games in the series hold a candle to the best in the genre, even contemporaries like Timesplitters 2.
Honestly it was one of the biggest disappointments I've ever felt in my gaming life. Not for the collection itself (I played it a couple of years ago as my first Halo experience), but for the individual games. Despite being very keen on finally trying out these legendary games, I just found them boring, bland and unengaging, and I still to this day don't understand how they're held in such high regard.
This was such a rollercoaster. As soon as I saw Arkane Lyon I audibly gasped, as it's one of my all time favourite studios. Then I saw it's yet another Marvel tie-in and lost interest. I hate superheroes, I hate Marvel, I hate licensed games, and especially licensed games that take time and resources away from an incredible studio like Arkane. It's time to stop with all these crossovers and cross-media crap. Hell, if there's one studio that's capable of creating interesting, detailed new worlds every single time, that's Arkane. After Redfall I was waiting to see if Lyon would go back to its roots and deliver us another masterpiece, but it seems that Arkane doesn't exist anymore. Honestly, nothing could've let me down more than this. Between this and Machine Games developing Indiana Jones (another IP I despise), I'm not really that happy with MS's output in the next few years. Let's hope Clockwork Revolution delivers at least!
Certainly Rollerdrome, since it launched more than a year ago on PS and now it's on Xbox with no fanfare. It's an amazing, tight game, and it's even 50% off at the moment!
@Kezelpaso do you know how big the file size is for the Beta on Series X? I'd like to try it but I'm afraid I don't have enough room on my console and external memory lol
@Jonnybekeww are you really making fun of the author for being more excited at the prospect of a new game compared to remasters of super old games? Really? Shake my head.
Zero hype for the next installment of the most overrated gaming franchise ever. The 6th gen games were revolutionary, sure, but I've never seen a franchise coasting on past success as much as GTA does. Having recently replayed V and the Trilogy, well, these games never had good gameplay, and even the writing is seriously overrated. The satire was always overplayed by fans, and the stories and character leave a lot to be desired. I get why the old games had the success they had, but after refusing to evolve for so long, I don't understand why GTA is still relevant. GTA VI will certainly not be an exception: I predict it will be a very pretty game with a lot of graphical detail and that's it; the gameplay will still suck like it always has, and the open world will be just as non-interactive as usual.
@Widey85 wow, I usually get dogpiled when I criticize GTA, thanks lol Yeah R* was never good at gameplay, and I get excusing that fact for a couple of PS2 games, but even by the time San Andreas was released it was high time they made some improvements, which they kept not making with IV and V.
I'm hoping that for once people will not give R* a pass and actually criticize GTAVI, instead of shilling it to no end like everyone did with V, which was outdated the day it came out. I mean, they could surprise me and overhaul the gameplay and mission design, but who's expecting that? If they don't seriously fix the formula, it'll be an incredibly outdated game, but we all know it'll sell and review very well based on name alone.
Well, I for one agree with SkillUp that Redfall is unsalvageable, and would rather see Arkane Austin move on to their next (hopefully single player, Arkane-style) game, than watch them bleed resources and staff just to try and steer a boat that's doomed to sink.
@Tharsman as @themightyant rightly suggests, Zelda is way more sophisticated in its approach, even if some of those thousands pieces of content are not all unique. For one, the ways in which you can interact with the environment make every challenge sort of new, as there isn't just one solution intended by the Devs. Secondly, Zelda takes a "world first" approach, while Ubi games are "map first", in the sense that yes, both feature towers to climb, but only the latter tells you where anything and everything of interest is. In Zelda you must find stuff on your own and are guided by your curiosity (which is always rewarded), making even reaching a mountaintop (or a Shrine, or a tower, etc.) a challenge in and of itself: do I have enough stamina? Should I climb or go the other way around? Are there enemies? And with TOTK, things have become exponentially more complex and sophisticated, giving player the chance to MacGyver up any solutions you might think.
So yeah, I think these 2 Zelda games are absolutely in a league of their own, and no Ubi open world game can even think of coming close. The former are a gourmet meal, the latter is comfort food. Tasty and likeable all you want, but not really high quality or nutritious.
@Tharsman "I’m curious why no one ever complains (that I heard of) about Breath of the Wild or Tears of the Kingdom being too long…"
Certainly you can see the difference between a systemic open world with emergent gameplay and handcrafted challenges on the one hand, and a smattering of copy-pasted outpost on a non-interactive stretch of land.
That's what kept me playing for 150+ hours in BOTW and has me bored after 15 hours with any Ubisoft game.
Soooo, am I dumb or is the title misleading? Because the two "modes of play" referenced here are 2 player co-op versus 4 player co-op. Nothing was said about single player.
Yeah, the setting is great, but also a big pile of wasted potential. This game is the prime example of a mess born of too many ideas, all at once, with the final result being a thoroughly unfocused and lesser experience, compared to the Rapture duology. The plot is all over the place, the gameplay is watered down to an incredible extent, and the themes...well, better not even touch those with a ten foot pole. Oh and the retcons in the DLC are absolutely dreadful.
@Baler @nomither6 Again with the silly "you played it wrong" angle! If a game offers multiple difficulties, why the hell would you shift the blame on me for playing the recommended normal difficulty. If Bungie/343i didn't want that, they could've just gone the Fromsoft route and made one singular difficulty setting for everyone. I'm sorry but that's a terrible argument to defend a game. Even if it weren't, a higher difficulty wouldn't increase the number of different enemies, nor fix the abysmal level design and signposting, so no, playing on Legendary or whatever won't fix what are glaring flaws in this series.
Also Baler mentioned stuff like the atmosphere, which just doesn't change with difficulty.
Comments 180
Re: DOOM: The Dark Ages To Be Announced At Xbox's Showcase, Claims New 'Exclusive'
Not sure why they wouldn't just reboot Quake as everything seemed to point to...but yeah I'll take anything Doom and be happy with it, I'm just curious and unsure about the direction they're gonna take it in after TAG2's ending seemed like a send-off for the Slayer and the series for the time being.
Re: Review: XDefiant (Xbox) - Classic COD In A Current-Gen Frock
Another mention of The Finals and still no review, just like PS 😭
That game is so freaking awesome!
Re: Talking Point: Rockstar Fans, How Hyped Are You For GTA 6?
Nope.
I'll only be interested if they add meaningful interactivity with the world, the controls don't suck, and the mission design isn't pulled straight from 25 years ago.
Re: Bethesda Trademark Hints At New DOOM Announcement For Xbox Games Showcase
Doom is one of my favourite series ever, so don't get me wrong I'm super excited, but I thought it was a given we would get a Quake reboot next, after the remasters, the story of Doom being complete after TAG 1&2, and comments byHugo himself that suggested they'd move away from it for the time being.
Re: Best Xbox Crossplay Games
@Traygor same, and I'm a bit ashamed of confessing that it's basically the only game I've played since it launched lol
I've always been a single player guy, never been into online multiplayer, but man is this game something else entirely.
The mechanics, the aesthetics, the lore... everything's just so well made and polished, not even mentioning how innovative it is.
I've always hated the F2P model, but Embark being an independent studio I can totally see why they went that route, and it's that exact reason that compelled me to buy some currency (never bought any micro transactions ever before), because they are independent and honestly deserve all the success and money they can get.
The way they constantly update the game weekly based on player feedback is just the icing on top of an absolutely delicious cake.
Re: Best Xbox Crossplay Games
No The Finals. Shame on you.
Re: Xbox Is Shutting Four Studios, Including Arkane Austin And Tango Gameworks
The makers of Prey. One of the best games ever made, probably the best immersive SIM ever.
Shut down, like this.
I'm speechless.
Re: Talking Point: Xbox Fans, Are You Still Enjoying Halo Infinite In 2024?
Nah, I dropped it ages ago.
Halo is not my thing in the first place, but I had decent fun at the beginning.
But with The Finals out now and Embark doing basically everything right, I can't see myself playing any other multiplayer FPS for a very long time, aside from maybe trying out XDefiant when (if?) it launches.
Re: Talking Point: Which Backwards Compatible Xbox Games Still Hold Up In 2024?
No One mentioning Timesplitters? That's a real shame lol
Re: Halo's Legendary Composer Marty O'Donnell Announces Political Career Switch
Removed
Re: Halo's Legendary Composer Marty O'Donnell Announces Political Career Switch
Removed
Re: Halo's Legendary Composer Marty O'Donnell Announces Political Career Switch
Removed
Re: Halo's Legendary Composer Marty O'Donnell Announces Political Career Switch
@NintendoByNature because some opinions simply have no merit by not being based in reality: opinions are not created equal.
Also, noone is name calling anyone, people here are attacking the GOP's draconian political agenda (and rightly so), not individuals.
Re: Poll: How Many Physical Xbox Games Do You Have In Your Collection?
I always prefer physical when it's an option (and not a super expensive limited edition), so even with my Series X being my first ever Xbox, I have amassed something like 40 physical games.
Re: 'Turbo Overkill' Is A Bonkers Cyberpunk FPS In Development For Xbox
@PhilKenSebben that is saying something indeed!
Can't wait for this to drop on consoles!
Re: 'Quake 6' Was Teased At Xbox Developer Direct, And We Didn't Even Spot It
I really really do hope they're working on a new Quake, a reboot of 1 in particular.
And I really really do hope they're not working on a licensed game as some have rumoured.
Re: Talking Point: 10 Years Later, What Do You Think Of 'The Master Chief Collection' In 2024?
@smoreon wow, someone who finally respects my attempts at getting into it instead of piling on me like a bunch of fanboys, thank you!
Re: Talking Point: 10 Years Later, What Do You Think Of 'The Master Chief Collection' In 2024?
@Banjo- never said they're bad, they aren't. They're boring, but the actual fundamentals of moving and shooting are top-notch.
It's just that the level design is basically non-existant, and the games quickly devolve in a mindless shoot fest without much engagement on my part.
Re: Talking Point: 10 Years Later, What Do You Think Of 'The Master Chief Collection' In 2024?
@themcnoisy I'll just say that if I had to be there to get how good they were, they were not that great in the first place, cause quality tends to resist the passing of time.
Idk, Halo apologists are the only fans that insist on this notion of "you had to be there", and I don't get why. Is it a way to admit that today those games are just boring and bland?
Re: Talking Point: 10 Years Later, What Do You Think Of 'The Master Chief Collection' In 2024?
@Zochmenos ok dude, it's impossible talking to you cause you're fixated on this mentality in which you're right and everyone else is wrong.
Ok, games cannot be evaluated if not the second they come out, noted.
Have a nice day.
Re: Talking Point: 10 Years Later, What Do You Think Of 'The Master Chief Collection' In 2024?
All these comments saying playing on normal is wrong...my dudes, if the Devs intended the game to be experienced like that it's on them to either make the standard difficulty higher, or making normal difficulty more engaging.
Again, just goes to prove my point that they're not that well designed.
Re: Talking Point: 10 Years Later, What Do You Think Of 'The Master Chief Collection' In 2024?
@Baler wow, calling someone a fool just because I criticized something you like. Very mature.
Also I played half of 1-4, all of Reach, and replayed the whole of CE with my brother to see if co-op would finally make it fun. It didn't.
Edit: I can name you a bunch of FPS that Halo doesn't even hold a candle to.
@ParsnipHero I'm referring to the campaigns, they're dreadful.
@Zochmenos dude, I said I get it.
It's just they were not that good to begin with.
Doom 1993 I played for the first time in 2020, and it became my most played game that year.
So yeah, you can definitely decouple a game from its context and evaluate it on its own merits.
Re: Talking Point: 10 Years Later, What Do You Think Of 'The Master Chief Collection' In 2024?
@Zochmenos yeah I know that, but the difference is I can have a whale of a time with Doom 1993 or Goldeneye 007 even in 2024, while Halo just bores me to tears.
I appreciate the impact the series (and the original in particular) had at the time, but none of the games in the series hold a candle to the best in the genre, even contemporaries like Timesplitters 2.
Re: Talking Point: 10 Years Later, What Do You Think Of 'The Master Chief Collection' In 2024?
Honestly it was one of the biggest disappointments I've ever felt in my gaming life.
Not for the collection itself (I played it a couple of years ago as my first Halo experience), but for the individual games.
Despite being very keen on finally trying out these legendary games, I just found them boring, bland and unengaging, and I still to this day don't understand how they're held in such high regard.
Re: Talking Point: What Are You Playing This Weekend? (December 30-31)
I'll definitely be playing some more The Finals and Cyberpunk if I find the time.
Re: Xbox Studio Arkane Is Officially Making A Marvel's Blade Game
This was such a rollercoaster.
As soon as I saw Arkane Lyon I audibly gasped, as it's one of my all time favourite studios.
Then I saw it's yet another Marvel tie-in and lost interest. I hate superheroes, I hate Marvel, I hate licensed games, and especially licensed games that take time and resources away from an incredible studio like Arkane. It's time to stop with all these crossovers and cross-media crap. Hell, if there's one studio that's capable of creating interesting, detailed new worlds every single time, that's Arkane.
After Redfall I was waiting to see if Lyon would go back to its roots and deliver us another masterpiece, but it seems that Arkane doesn't exist anymore.
Honestly, nothing could've let me down more than this.
Between this and Machine Games developing Indiana Jones (another IP I despise), I'm not really that happy with MS's output in the next few years.
Let's hope Clockwork Revolution delivers at least!
Re: Talking Point: What Are The Most Underrated Xbox Games Of This Year?
Certainly Rollerdrome, since it launched more than a year ago on PS and now it's on Xbox with no fanfare.
It's an amazing, tight game, and it's even 50% off at the moment!
Re: Hands On: Call Of Duty Modern Warfare 3 Feels Like DLC Of The Nostalgic Kind
@Kezelpaso thanks!
Re: Hands On: Call Of Duty Modern Warfare 3 Feels Like DLC Of The Nostalgic Kind
@ZuneTattooGuy thanks, but I don't have that cause I don't play Warzone!
Re: Hands On: Call Of Duty Modern Warfare 3 Feels Like DLC Of The Nostalgic Kind
@Kezelpaso do you know how big the file size is for the Beta on Series X? I'd like to try it but I'm afraid I don't have enough room on my console and external memory lol
Re: Soapbox: After Redfall's Reception, I Really Hope The Dishonored 3 Leak Is Real
@Jonnybekeww are you really making fun of the author for being more excited at the prospect of a new game compared to remasters of super old games? Really? Shake my head.
Re: Soapbox: After Redfall's Reception, I Really Hope The Dishonored 3 Leak Is Real
Agreed. Dishonored is one of the best series around.
Re: Talking Point: It's Now Been Over 10 Years Since Rockstar Launched A New Grand Theft Auto
Zero hype for the next installment of the most overrated gaming franchise ever.
The 6th gen games were revolutionary, sure, but I've never seen a franchise coasting on past success as much as GTA does.
Having recently replayed V and the Trilogy, well, these games never had good gameplay, and even the writing is seriously overrated.
The satire was always overplayed by fans, and the stories and character leave a lot to be desired.
I get why the old games had the success they had, but after refusing to evolve for so long, I don't understand why GTA is still relevant.
GTA VI will certainly not be an exception: I predict it will be a very pretty game with a lot of graphical detail and that's it; the gameplay will still suck like it always has, and the open world will be just as non-interactive as usual.
Re: Talking Point: What Are You Playing This Weekend? (September 9-10)
Can't wait to get home from work and finally start Starfield! I'm so hyped!
Re: Starfield 'Children Of The Sky' Music Video Is Here, And It's Giving Us The Chills
Boy do I despise Imagine Dragons.
Re: GTA Owner Expecting 'New Record Levels' For 2025 Financial Year
@Widey85 wow, I usually get dogpiled when I criticize GTA, thanks lol
Yeah R* was never good at gameplay, and I get excusing that fact for a couple of PS2 games, but even by the time San Andreas was released it was high time they made some improvements, which they kept not making with IV and V.
Re: GTA Owner Expecting 'New Record Levels' For 2025 Financial Year
I'm hoping that for once people will not give R* a pass and actually criticize GTAVI, instead of shilling it to no end like everyone did with V, which was outdated the day it came out.
I mean, they could surprise me and overhaul the gameplay and mission design, but who's expecting that?
If they don't seriously fix the formula, it'll be an incredibly outdated game, but we all know it'll sell and review very well based on name alone.
Re: Deals: All 30+ Backwards Compatible Games In This Week's Xbox Sales (August 1-8)
Definitely gonna grab Far Cry Classic and Instincts Predator, as I've been meaning to play all FC games lately.
Re: Xbox's Redfall Plan 'Right Now' Is To Keep The Studio Open & Working On Updates
Well, I for one agree with SkillUp that Redfall is unsalvageable, and would rather see Arkane Austin move on to their next (hopefully single player, Arkane-style) game, than watch them bleed resources and staff just to try and steer a boat that's doomed to sink.
Re: inXile Studio Head Shares More Details On First-Person RPG 'Clockwork Revolution'
Game of the show for me.
Everything from the aesthetics to the genre to.. basically everything else speaks to me on a deep level lol
Can't wait!
Re: Xbox Boss Phil Spencer Seems Extremely Excited About id Software's Next Game
Quake 1 reboot all the way, please!
It was my most anticipated announcement but unfortunately it didn't materialize 😥
Re: Our Predictions For The 2023 Xbox Games Showcase
I just want a Quake reboot by id Software 😭
Please Hugo, please!
Re: Xbox Games With Gold For June 2023 Announced
Adios is great, by all means try it! It's very short too.
Re: Talking Point: What 'Dream' Reveal Would You Like To See At The Xbox Games Showcase 2023?
Pie in the sky: a new Banjo and/or Dishonored 3.
Realistic: a Quake reboot.
Re: Soapbox: Go Buy The Best Console Version Of Far Cry 3 While It's Cheap On Xbox
@Tharsman as @themightyant rightly suggests, Zelda is way more sophisticated in its approach, even if some of those thousands pieces of content are not all unique.
For one, the ways in which you can interact with the environment make every challenge sort of new, as there isn't just one solution intended by the Devs.
Secondly, Zelda takes a "world first" approach, while Ubi games are "map first", in the sense that yes, both feature towers to climb, but only the latter tells you where anything and everything of interest is.
In Zelda you must find stuff on your own and are guided by your curiosity (which is always rewarded), making even reaching a mountaintop (or a Shrine, or a tower, etc.) a challenge in and of itself: do I have enough stamina? Should I climb or go the other way around? Are there enemies?
And with TOTK, things have become exponentially more complex and sophisticated, giving player the chance to MacGyver up any solutions you might think.
So yeah, I think these 2 Zelda games are absolutely in a league of their own, and no Ubi open world game can even think of coming close.
The former are a gourmet meal, the latter is comfort food. Tasty and likeable all you want, but not really high quality or nutritious.
Re: Soapbox: Go Buy The Best Console Version Of Far Cry 3 While It's Cheap On Xbox
@Tharsman "I’m curious why no one ever complains (that I heard of) about Breath of the Wild or Tears of the Kingdom being too long…"
Certainly you can see the difference between a systemic open world with emergent gameplay and handcrafted challenges on the one hand, and a smattering of copy-pasted outpost on a non-interactive stretch of land.
That's what kept me playing for 150+ hours in BOTW and has me bored after 15 hours with any Ubisoft game.
Re: Redfall Final Preview Shows Huge Differences Between Solo And Co-Op Play
Soooo, am I dumb or is the title misleading? Because the two "modes of play" referenced here are 2 player co-op versus 4 player co-op.
Nothing was said about single player.
Re: Xbox Console Exclusive Wins BAFTA 'Best Game' Award, Beating Elden Ring And God Of War
Was hoping for it to be Immortality honestly.
Re: BioShock Infinite's 'Columbia' Is One Of The Best Game Worlds Ever To Grace Xbox
Yeah, the setting is great, but also a big pile of wasted potential.
This game is the prime example of a mess born of too many ideas, all at once, with the final result being a thoroughly unfocused and lesser experience, compared to the Rapture duology.
The plot is all over the place, the gameplay is watered down to an incredible extent, and the themes...well, better not even touch those with a ten foot pole.
Oh and the retcons in the DLC are absolutely dreadful.
Re: Pick One: Which Is Your Favourite Halo Game?
@Baler @nomither6 Again with the silly "you played it wrong" angle!
If a game offers multiple difficulties, why the hell would you shift the blame on me for playing the recommended normal difficulty.
If Bungie/343i didn't want that, they could've just gone the Fromsoft route and made one singular difficulty setting for everyone.
I'm sorry but that's a terrible argument to defend a game.
Even if it weren't, a higher difficulty wouldn't increase the number of different enemies, nor fix the abysmal level design and signposting, so no, playing on Legendary or whatever won't fix what are glaring flaws in this series.
Also Baler mentioned stuff like the atmosphere, which just doesn't change with difficulty.