Talking Point: What Was The Greatest Xbox 360 Game Of All Time?

There's no doubt that many Xbox fans consider the Xbox 360 era to be the greatest in the history of the brand, and a large part of that is due to how many incredible games the console received in the late 2000s and early 2010s.

But out of the thousands of titles released on the Xbox 360, which was the very best? Metacritic seems to think it was Grand Theft Auto 4, which sits at the peak of the top ten with an incredible 98 average rating:

  1. Grand Theft Auto 4 (98)
  2. Grand Theft Auto 5 (97)
  3. BioShock (96)
  4. The Orange Box (96)
  5. Mass Effect 2 (96)
  6. The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim (96)
  7. Red Dead Redemption (95)
  8. Portal 2 (95)
  9. Batman: Arkham City (94)
  10. Gears of War (94)

Of course, Metacritic ratings don't always tell the full story, so we need to consider some others as well. Halo 3 is an obvious candidate, as are the likes of Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare, Fallout 3, Left 4 Dead, Dead Space, Fable 2, Dark Souls, Alan Wake, Oblivion and so many others. Seriously, what a generation this was!

We know it's going to be tough, but we want you to try and whittle down the list of 2154 Xbox 360 games into just one winner! Does Halo take the crown for you? How about Gears of War? Come and tell us in the comments below.

What was the greatest Xbox 360 game of all time? We're looking forward to these responses!