Much has been made of how Cyberpunk 2077 is running very poorly on base Xbox One, but for the most part (aside from bugs), it seems to be working very well on both the Xbox Series X and Xbox Series S.
In an analysis from Digital Foundry, the outlet found that the Series X actually offers "arguably the best console experience right now" for the game, thanks to its 30FPS Quality Mode which isn't present on PS5.
"Arguably the best console experience right now is Series X's quality mode, which caps output frame-rate to 30 frames per second but increases resolution dramatically - it's dynamic and floats around 1512p in the city, but can be reach beyond 1728p in simpler scenes (1800p looks like the absolute upper bounds)."
"There are further enhancements too, such as ambient occlusion, which is not present in performance mode, nor is it present in the PS5 build."
Interestingly though, the Xbox Series X falls a little short of the PS5 when it comes to Performance Mode, dropping frames more regularly than Sony's console, although the Series X appears to run with higher city density settings.
The other key takeaway is that the Xbox Series S also does a fantastic job of running Cyberpunk 2077, delivering a consistent 30FPS while still boasting the likes of ambient occlusion and higher city density.
"In fact, Series S at 30fps seems to be a touch more consistent overall than Series X but the key takeaway here is that in terms of PlayStation and Xbox consoles - and even PC - it's difficult to imagine hardware that could deliver a Cyberpunk experience as decent as this for anything like the same money."
Of course, the "right now" aspect of this analysis relates to the fact that all next-gen consoles are still running the backwards compatible versions of Cyberpunk 2077 for the time being, with a proper upgrade set to arrive for Xbox Series X, Xbox Series S and PS5 next year. That'll be the true test for these systems, but nevertheless this is an intriguing analysis that suggests playing on Quality Mode is a good visual experience in the interim.
What do you make of this? Give us your thoughts down in the comments below.
[source eurogamer.net]
Comments 40
That's saying nothing, given what all consoles and all modes are turning in. Kinda embarrassing they have to resort to this as their only semblance of a win in power.
It's especially funny after CDPR's new comments that the actual current gen patch might not even release in 2021.
Reminder: Xbox Series X
PC
Mess of game really, but good to know that the series x, mainly thanks to Microsoft backwards compatible programme runs ok ish.
If you purchased a product say TV and it acted like this game does you would take it back a get a full refund. I would be seriously pissed had I purchased this game.
I really hope the game flops sales wise as this could set a bad president for maybe others to follow. I know let’s sell an unfinished product and farm it out to those gullible gamers.
Everyone should ask for a full refund.
We deserve better than this.
@Dezzy70 It already sold 8 million copies before launch, recouping every single cent of development and advertising costs and became profitable instantly.
@Menchi
I know I did read that.
Let’s hope everyone is a bit more cautious
In the future, I know I have been for a while now.
The thing is, I think not many people jumped on The Witcher 3 at launch, because that was just as buggy and eventually sorted after many patches.
Same thing here with Cyberpunk, apart from now they have 2 generations of hardware to work with, so even more issues.
@Dezzy70 I personally cancelled my preorder a few days after the most recent delay as they mentioned the PC version was done (debatably a lie) but it was delayed because of the consoles, and look how that turned out. They'll get my money next year when it's dirt cheap on a steam sale and finally finished development.
@blinx01 I heard as much. I didn't play it back then but have a disk version so guess I could install and test to experience it, if I wanted.
My memory is vague but wasn't there a small controversy around then because some CDPR dev said something akin to consoles being third class or something and PC being the only true way to play/make games?
@Tharsman The Witcher 3 producer said he'd rather play on PC on the lowest settings than Xbox One.
@Menchi
I will probably not play it until series x version out and only because I have the game from when I purchased an Xbox one x cyberpunk console.
Sold that now and got a series x.
The first game I bought day one at full price in 15yrs. Never again.
@Carck haha me too. It was that series X / PC comparison that killed any desire to play it till a next gen patch.
Mine has ran fine on the series x, only issue is the occasional freeze for a few seconds a couple of times, no crashes or other bugs so far.. Played about 12 hours.. I haven't touched the main yet really though just been doing the side stuff in Watson (first area)
@Tharsman
Yeah. CD Project Red have always been a PC developer first and foremost.
I think they've only done Witcher 2 on Xbox 360, and Witcher 3 on Xbox One and PS4 before this, so their console experience isn't exactly top notch.
I think that's the issue with Cyberpunk. It's been developed for PC as the main target and then just ported to consoles, whereas with most blockbuster games, it's the other way round. Normally one console is the actual lead development.
I highly doubt the game will be in an acceptable state until January, as you'd think the team will be breaking up for the Christmas holidays soon.
So much for being the 'most powerful console' when it drops more frames compared to the Ps5 versions of games. And I'm an Xbox main.
@Menchi Thanks. You've made the waiting for the next gen patch even easier now with those screenshots. Glad I held off buying it.
If it's only topped at 1728p max on Series X with stock Xbox One graphical settings then i wonder what will be the sacrifices in the next gen patch ...
@Menchi
This is misleading. XSX' quality mode with HDR on looks much more like the second screenshot. Wonder why you try to badmouth it.
@Menchi I've just done this exact part of the game and it looks almost as good as the pc photo so stop talking crap
@DannyP80
I second that. HDR works fine for the most part, but black needs some work as it's grey in some areas. Not as bad as the OP would have us believe with these screenshots, though.
@JON22 the XSX version actually has more “density” and “detail” than the PS5 version. It’s at the 7:04 mark. This would account for the slightly more dropped frames. In other words, it’s not the exact same version like Valhalla is. It’s not a direct apples to apples comparison.
@lokozar I was gonna say, this is a screenshot from my Series S
Looks like i'll be playing in quality mode..
@StylesT Nice, If only i find one to buy a XSX somewhere in the UK
@Dezzy70 Too late, the game was in profit after day 1.
@DannyP80 Photographic evidence says otherwise
@Menchi no playing it on a series x does you idiot
@JON22 Probably because the series x version is more busy with things going on according to digital foundry.. More npc etc for whatever reason
@carlos82
Which still is a lot better than Menchi wants to make people believe. Dunno why people do this. It's as if they must fight a personal war, and obsessively have to use every dirty trick in the book. Disturbing.
@Kefka2589
Yes I heard about the refunds.
Good job, about time these companies release they can’t get away with this sort of faulty product.
@blinx01 for me, January sounds extremely optimistic.
@AJDarkstar The “res bumb“ is actually a simple but effective sharpening filter, that counteracts the blurring caused by TAA. The XSX got it too with patch 1.04, and it is applied to every mode. What the “PS5 version“ is still missing is actual higher resolution and SSAO, which provides better shadows. They could add that (a quality mode) before the next gen patch, but I think quirks with Sony’s back compat programme prevents them from doing so.
I would argue that the One X is the best way to enjoy the game right now, but seeing as how the Series X is an upgrade to that I could see how that's even better.
@lokozar Yeah basically the PS5 isn't like the Xbox where backwards compatible games get upgraded with ease. They more or less need to be purpose designed for the PS5. Microsoft simply does a far better job when it comes to enhancing games.
Not even 2021? Seriously what have these guys been doing for a decade?
Aside from some irritating freezes, its been running really well on my Series X. The motorbikes still have the turning circle of a cross-channel ferry, but that isn't a performance issue.
@AJDarkstar Believe me, it's just a sharpening filter. Even the PC version got it. And it really does "provide" more fine details. Reason is, the details are already there, but they are lying beneath the blurr of the TAA. If they would simply deactivate TAA you would see a difference like day and night - even on the original PS4. You can test this yourself on a PC with MK11 for example. Sharpening the picture up counteracts TAA's blurriness, which is why some games already give you the option to activate a sharpening post processing effect (again MK11 as an example, it's hidden under PC Features -> FidelityFX CAS). Some players also like to use shader suites like reshade to sharpen up TAA and FXAA results.
As for the perceived res bump in the new video you mentioned: These results are pretty miniscule. It's not that easy. This game uses dynamic resolution on all console versions. The resolution depends on the current workload of the system. If there is not much to process, it can boost the resolution. If there is a lot to do, it will down the res. Since there are a lot of dynamic elements in this game, you will have a hard time seeing the same results on two tests, even if you try to measure the same scenes. Meaning, DF's results can differ from other tester's results at any given time.
@AJDarkstar The XSX is basically running the One X version and uses it's power for FPS and indirectly more resolution. That is however just a brute force method, no actual refinement. We will see much better looking versions for XSX and PS5 down the road. Maybe even before the next gen patch.
@carlos82 if that's how it looks on the S then I will get it......after the current gen patch.........and when I get a Series S😢
@Menchi Complete BS! That top photo is from the 2018 reveal. Why are you tricking people? Bad form.
Apparently, the game is a hot mess on PlayStation with tons of crashes. The XSX/S versions are probably the best by default at this point. Lol.
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...