There is a very interesting article I found (and Bing translated) that I wanted to share. It's worth reading because it's a reflection on the years of Spencer as the CEO of Xbox and the arrival and reset of Asha.
The easy thing is to criticize XBOX for the thousands of layoffs, the hard thing is to accept that Asha Sharma's plan (with its flaws) was inevitable.
Asha Sharma has undertaken a major restructuring of the studios to try to clean up the accounts and achieve a healthy business.
The change in the direction of Xbox occurred just 8 months ago, but time has not passed in vain. After several years where the decline of the brand seemed unstoppable, today there is a different atmosphere. It's still too early to venture how it may all end, but what no one can doubt is that things are moving. Decisions are being made and strategies are being proposed. All regime changes come with a new impetus that promises to change things. In many cases, it is an amendment to the whole of the previous one. After all, if changes of this magnitude occur, it is for a reason. If things worked well and the business was healthy, executives would remain in their posts.
There are few entities more conservative than large corporations. If there is a change at the top, it is because a U-turn is needed, a pronounced change at all levels. Phil Spencer did it when he arrived and Asha Sharma does it now. But while the former was an expansion, the latter has to oversee a painful, but not unwarranted, contraction.
For too long, Xbox's in-house studios have enjoyed an overly forgiving ecosystem. I didn't get to meet Phil Spencer in person, but his numerous interventions over the years lead me to conclude that he is a good person, a kind guy who wants to get along with everyone and who has infinite respect for creatives. He is a figure far removed from the archetype of the despotic executive that abounds in the management of large companies, and as such, he has always enjoyed exquisite treatment from the press and developers. But the uncomfortable truth is that this aura of a good person has taken its toll on him. During his reign, Xbox has invested more than anyone else, not only in acquisitions, but in financing endless projects with very disparate quality control. At the same time, he went all-in on a strategy that ultimately greatly devalued these same projects once they came to market. The concatenation of these factors and many others came to tighten the rope so much that his resignation became essential.
Asha Sharma has arrived at an upside-down house. A house not with simple dampness in the walls, but with structural problems in the foundations, lead in the pipes, infested with rodents and cracks in the walls. A dreadful cash flow and assets in disuse, or at least with a return well below their possibilities. It is profoundly surprising how a person without exhaustive knowledge of the industry and the corporate arm she now leads has been able to diagnose with such precision the ills that afflict the division. But what is even more incredible is the sensitivity with which she has handled the situation, when she could have entered with Milei's chainsaw to the kitchen. Looking back, there are many decisions that Spencer made irresponsibly. And his friendly personality should not be an obstacle to making a fair judgment about them.
I firmly believe that Spencer's big problem is the cognitive distortion in which he immersed an entire community, a halo of toxic positivity that led him to make misleading assertions or that were directly lies. The main one? That Xbox Game Pass was profitable, that it does not cannibalize the sales of the games offered there and that its catalog cannot disgust anything, accepting all kinds of experiences, even the most minority, the least economically viable. This cognitive distortion, beyond the user community, mainly affected its developers. Studios that were given a blank check to do what they wanted, without restrictions, without stress, without supervision or feedback of any kind. It was this policy of patronage that has led to eternal and disappointing developments.
Hellblade 2 stuck more than 5 years in the kitchen to end up with a game clearly inferior to the first, which was developed without expectations and with hardly any budget. State of Decay 3 has been in existence for 8 years and no one is very clear about its state. South of Midnight is a decent title, but it doesn't make any sense that it ended up costing the barbarity that is being talked about. Double Fine showed everyone that it has the makings to make an outstanding game with Psychonauts 2, but then chose to dedicate itself to other tasks for the next five years. Tim Schaffer may shut us all up next year, but the studio's last two titles were made with their own creative satisfaction in mind rather than a real audience. Even games that have a chance of being excellent like Clockwork Revolution or Fable handle unjustifiable figures. 7 years of development for the first, 10 for the second, a mini RPG of just 20 hours in length. In which head does it fit?
Not all of Sharma's decisions I consider to be correct. The evisceration of a studio that has always met the deadlines and quality required as Id Software is tragic. Taking out the checkbook to fund Kojima's latest extravaganza is a very risky move that can go very well or very badly, but one that has undoubtedly deeply many of the corporation's employees. And the very strange return to exclusivity of certain titles, just when they need all the possibilities in the world to achieve profitability, seems to me an unjustified punishment. But what is clear is that it could not continue like this, and that the bull had to be taken by the horns. The way in which they have acted, facilitating independence instead of closing the studios without consideration, reveals a consideration that the competition, when it has been in a similar situation (see the case of BluePoint), has not had. And it is fair to applaud them for this.
The stark reality of the creative industries is that without a healthy business you can't create art on this scale. We can debate ad nauseam about executive compensation or the misuse of resources, but games have to be profitable. It is normal that from time to time a project fails, that it does not find its audience due to a confluence of factors unrelated to it. But it cannot be that the vast majority, one after the other, falls short of expectations, both commercial and quality. There is no business that can withstand that. And Spencer's idea that Microsoft could afford to lose money indefinitely for the love of art was very dangerous. Not only because it was obviously a lie, but because it convinced many unwary people on both sides of the industry.
Bringing up the Manchester City scandal, I believe in the need for financial fair play in the entertainment industry as well. Losing billions to try to suffocate the competitor is despicable. It's not what ended up happening here, but it's clear that at some point during the Spencer stage it was the prevailing idea. Spoiler: it ends badly. It facilitates a cognitive distortion where projects do not have to make sense, objectives, a specific audience or a reason for being. The consolidation that Sharma has ordered may raise many suspicions, but it seeks to put an end to the farmhouses and put everyone rowing in a single direction. It's what makes sense. And that doesn't mean it doesn't taste bad.
Personally, I think it's a tragedy that Obsidian is subordinated to Bethesda, but they had the opportunity to hit the table with their last two RPGs and it wasn't like that. In the reset they are going to pay the righteous for sinners, but we cannot forget how we got to this situation. If things had not gotten out of hand in such a way, perhaps there would be arguments to oppose it. But there are none. Something had to change.
Agree. Forcing Phil out like they did only to replace him by someone who doesnt care about the brand or the gaming was a huge mistake. The fact that she just want to stifle Xbox's creativity and just produce the same old crap over and over like Gears, Halo, Fable just turns me off to the brand. If it wasnt for World of Warcraft I wouldnt support MS at all till they drop her like a bad habit.
The stuff that made me an Xbox fan the variety of the studios and games is gone now because of a person that doesnt belong in the position that Asha is in, she is more business then anything else and just wants to tell people what they want. Yeah dont get me wrong its great that she is focusing on Halo, and Gears and a few core franchises but there is more out there then that. Shes just trying to turn Xbox into Sony which if I want that I would own a Playstation not an Xbox.
Which is fine if thats what she wants to do then I dont need to support Xbox just like I stopped Supporting Playstation years ago it just saddens me because of all the money and time I invested into the Xbox ecosystem just to have to start all over on PC because Asha doesnt have a clue on what to do and is more focused on pleasing her bosses then the actual consumer.
RetiredPush Square Moderator and all around retro gamer.
I Phil just wanted out tbh. Sarah Bond seemed out of her depth and not able to cope; she also came up with some brain-dead ideas too.
I like the new boss, and while it's a lot of pain. Xbox did have too many studios to support. They're now much leaner, fitter and seem to have a more cohesive and focused development structure, which can only be good for Project Helix, along with the move to ever more console exclusives
@TeamAndromeda Sarah was completely disconnected from the gaming world. Her official videos talking about Xbox looked completely fake, but Asha is very clever and knows what must be done. Xbox had become way too bloated, and some studios failed to deliver, so sadly any publisher would have got rid of them. Granted, the successful studios have also been cut back, and maybe the few that have not will, but they have also grown because of the pandemic gaming boom. All the big publishers have reduced their staff significantly, except Nintendo that often outsources development tasks.
The new Xbox team has also been improving and adding tons of features to the Xbox consoles, with FSR4.1 coming soon. I'm excited to see Xbox getting much more focused and the team boosting the console experience and ecosystem, while expanding Play Anywhere for playing on PC and gaming handhelds.
Well it seems quite strange to me that Xbox/Microsoft seem to have sent out massive amounts of public messages around gameing and Xbox as of the last few years yet there must so much non public info to. So the public have like been informed with many, many things yet there must many many things the consumer donβt know.
@TeamAndromeda Sarah was completely disconnected from the gaming world. Her official videos talking about Xbox looked completely fake, but Asha is very clever and knows what must be done. Xbox had become way too bloated, and some studios failed to deliver, so sadly any publisher would have got rid of them. Granted, the successful studios have also been cut back, and maybe the few that have not will, but they have also grown because of the pandemic gaming boom. All the big publishers have reduced their staff significantly, except Nintendo that often outsources development tasks.
The new Xbox team has also been improving and adding tons of features to the Xbox consoles, with FSR4.1 coming soon. I'm excited to see Xbox getting much more focused and the team boosting the console experience and ecosystem, while expanding Play Anywhere for playing on PC and gaming handhelds.
She was out of her depth and came up with some brain dead idea's the best of which was 'This Is An XBOX' Sarah also never engaged that well with the Xbox community, unlike Phil or Asha.
Asha really seems to have her head screwed on and can see what XBOX gamers want for the most part
Like you say, most corps are laying off staff, its not just Xbox. Plus, Xbox just got too big, too fast & they was no communication between the teams
That seems to be all sorted out now & I love the talk from Asha on exclusives and talking up the XBOX brand, something which Sarah never did. You have to take the fight to SONY, not be best chums with them
I do agree with you, and I thank you for sharing that translated article.
I'm not in the position of doing deep comments because I'm not a business man and I know the videogame industry only as a player.
although a financial restructuring seemed mandatory for me.
"Pigrotto" is a slang Italian word that means "very lazy" in a nice way.
@Pigrotto Yep. What Asha is doing is not an easy task, but I think she's doing a better job than both Phil and Sarah, and a financial restructuring was needed because they were bleeding money. I think that Phil is a good man and some of his ideas were great, but the hands-off approach and neglecting Xbox console users was completely counter-productive. Thanks for your comment!
@TeamAndromeda Isn't that right! Nice profile picture, in between. π
@Pigrotto Yep. What Asha is doing is not an easy task, but I think she's doing a better job than both Phil and Sarah, and a financial restructuring was needed because they were bleeding money. I think that Phil is a good man and some of his ideas were great, but the hands-off approach and neglecting Xbox console users was completely counter-productive. Thanks for your comment! @TeamAndromeda Isn't that right! Nice profile picture, in between. π
I still have a lot of time for Phil, but his last couple of years were bad
Asha is so much better than Bond, I was getting sick of this be nice to SONY & lets put out games on their systems
XBOX HR bill was getting silly. Simple moves like having Obsidian make a new Vegas or merging the Playground games with Turn 10 make perfect sense, has does bringing Halo into Activision's FPS studios
Thanks for the kind words btw, I'm a massibe Panzer Dragoon and Team Andromeda fan
@TeamAndromeda (and @Pigrotto) Phil and his team did a lot of great things for Xbox, most importantly backwards compatibility and the hardware quality of the Xbox consoles, but his last years at Xbox were his worst, and he looked exhausted. He attended to the media while travelling the world and declaring in court during the long ABK acquisition. Even worse, he had to read and reply Jim Ryan's emails! Yes, I would love to earn the money he did, but he is a human being, after all. His expansion strategy was not well developed nor followed up properly. He also alienated Xbox fans with the platform-agnostic approach. The focus should be on consoles, Play Anywhere and Xbox on PC, not on PS5 and Cloud gaming on mobile phones.
Sarah didn't have any good ideas because she had no idea, and looked like a parrot reading a script. The biggest problem Xbox had was bleeding money despite massive revenue and, of course, the blank cheques and the hands-off strategy after acquiring many studios, with inconsistent first-party output and dragged development.
Like you said, Asha has made logical decisions. Some of us predicted a few, like merging the Forza studios. Obsidian working on Fallout again is brilliant, and Halo under Activision should be in better hands. I also think she was clever to make Mojang and King report to her directly. Let's hope that Rare makes something great with their IPs and not waste decades on projects with no gameplay like Everwild, now that Activision is their boss.
Asha and Mathews are also reducing unnecessary infrastructure and layers of management, cancelled Xbox Copilot, "This is an Xbox", requested console updates based on fan feedback and restored the brand identity with exclusives. They reduced the price of Game Pass by 25% and removed day-one Call of Duty. After disinvesting in not successful studios, I think it's a good idea to secure third-party projects like Physint. Searching balanced profitability is something she's doing pretty well, and adjusting Game Pass according to the number of subscribers and the price that they are willing to pay is a course correction built on the best things that Phil Spencer did.
And...
Sega is great! When I was a kid, I loved Sonic, still do, because the character looks cool, Tails is adorable, and their story is environment-friendly. I have my Sonic plushie, and I got the two available Panzer Dragoon games on Series X. π
great report and well written!
everything you said is true, in my opinion.
you even brought back the tense Jim Ryan period with his Call Of Duty exclusivity tantrum...
"Pigrotto" is a slang Italian word that means "very lazy" in a nice way.
@Banjo-
at the moment I'm only sorry in Italy a pre-owned Series X is about 830β¬ while a new one around 1200β¬ (if you are lucky to find one that's it).
it is difficult to introduce people to Xbox with these prices, although I'm aware why the situation is this.
my Series X is currently at my nephew house, because he needed one.
I decided to wait for Helix, however I always check the market to see if some occasion arises.
"Pigrotto" is a slang Italian word that means "very lazy" in a nice way.
Yes, it's so difficult to find in most European countries. Components crisis raising the price of the consoles combined with people selling them even more expensive than the already increased official price makes waiting for Helix the most sensible option at this point.
Forums
Topic: Reflection on the Xbox reset
Posts 1 to 20 of 21
Please login or sign up to reply to this topic