Following on from 2021’s relatively successful revamp of Project Zero: Maiden of Black Water, Koei Tecmo returns with a remaster of the fourth title in its Fatal Frame/Project Zero series, Project Zero: Mask of the Lunar Eclipse. Originally released as a Nintendo Wii exclusive back in 2008, this is actually one of our favourite entries from the entire franchise in terms of narrative, however players should be aware that what you’ve got here is still a fairly clunky, cumbersome and glacially-paced survival horror adventure that will frequently test your patience over its roughly ten hour running time.
Project Zero: Mask of the Lunar Eclipse tells the tale of some proper creepy goings-on at Rougetsu Island, a fictional location where five young girls disappeared and were later rescued exactly ten years prior to the events of the game. Now all grown up, and with two of the five having recently mysteriously died, the three surviving victims of the original event - alongside the detective who rescued them back in 1970 - return to Rougetsu in order to investigate what exactly occurred all those years ago. Of course it's not long before the proverbial hits the whirly thing and all of our protagonists are wishing they'd never set foot back in this accursed fortress of ghoulish misery.
It's a narrative setup that sees you take control of all four characters involved over the course of the game’s fairly short campaign, slowly creeping through dark corridors as you solve a bunch of environmental puzzles and make use of your Camera Obscura and a Spirit Stone Flashlight in order to ward off the attacks of a twisted menagerie of spectres and wraiths. As well as using your camera and flashlight to fend off enemies, you’ll also be rewarded for being fast on the draw to capture images of various harmless apparitions that pop up all over the shop as you proceed from one objective to the next. Oh look, there's one staring in the window with its mouth open as black soup pours from its eyeballs. Quickly, take a photo and then go change your trousers.
Mask of the Lunar Eclipse was originally released as a Japan-only title back in 2008 - we had to resort to a fan translation back in the day in order to experience its chills - and it’s genuinely great to see it finally get a proper Western release so that fans of the series can dive into the nightmare. However, this certainly isn’t the most comprehensive of remasters. Yes, the graphics have had a reasonable touch-up, they’ve added a very fitting photo mode, the lighting has been improved and the whole thing looks quite a bit better as a result. But there are still plenty of low-resolution textures to be found on doors and walls as you investigate your surroundings and overall the whole thing continues to look decidedly last-gen, giving the impression that more could have been done in order to justify the remastered moniker.
Besides a lick of paint and some additional sound effects here and there, this is the exact same game we played in 2008 and, as a result, it retains many of the issues that held it back upon its original release. Character movement is painfully slow, even when holding down the sprint button, making the constant retracing of your steps a real chore at times. There is a quick-turn action that can be performed by clicking either thumbstick, but turning around to face whatever is attacking you at any given moment still manages to feel fiddly, especially when you’re constantly switching between your normal view and looking through the Obscura’s viewfinder, thanks to sluggish camera controls and that aforementioned player movement speed.
It makes for combat sequences and general exploration that feels frustratingly awkward and slow – taking on several ghosts at once can leave you cursing at the screen – but, if you can manage to get your head around it all and come to terms with the tankiness of how everything operates, there’s still some fun to be had thanks to the involving narrative, deeply oppressive atmosphere and the unique gimmick that is the series’ signature Camera Obscura.
Yes, as much as we like to complain about the clunky aspects of control and movement in this franchise in general, there’s no denying that using the Camera Obscura to attack and destroy some genuinely terrifying apparitions is a whole lot of creepy fun, and utilising the various different lenses and film types you’ll find lying around locations makes for combat that gives you plenty of options to tool around with. Waiting to the very last moment to take a photo so that you initiate a "fatal frame" shot, a high damage capture that allows you to follow up with combos of snaps, can be nail-biting stuff and getting the timing right whilst using the proper mix of equipment so that you dust off high level enemies in short order sure does feel satisfying. Combine this with the Ringu-influenced style and deeply unsettling atmosphere of the whole thing and this one still retains the ability to send a shiver up your spine at points.
It's just a shame, then, that more effort hasn't been put into refining traversal for more modern audiences, as the constant grind of slowly plodding back and forth through the game’s handful of small locations, the relentless frustration of repeatedly traipsing over old ground only to find more locked doors and barriers to your progress, makes for an experience that’s unnecessarily frustrating and one that remains an acquired taste within this particular genre. We get that the slow movement and tanky controls are all part of the deal when it comes to survival horror, it's what makes confrontations so tense as you struggle to get yourself set in time to repel your foes, but work could have been done here to smooth the edges of a control scheme that irritates far more than it ought to.
Project Zero: Mask of the Lunar Eclipse is a reasonably decent time if you can come to terms with its plodding traversal, clunky gameplay mechanics and repetitive exploration. There's an enjoyable mystery to uncover at the heart of this one, it's got some genuine scares along the way, snapping ghouls is as fun as ever and the whole thing has a deeply unsettling vibe that still feels unique to the franchise. However, as far as remasters go, beyond a bit of a visual revamp, it feels like additional work could have been done to make this remastered version of the game feel like a more modern and polished survival horror experience.
As I've just posted over on NL...
I don't bother with professional reviews of my favourite subgenre, unless it's written by somebody that appears familar with the mechanics of classic survival horror.
The other four mainline games in the franchise are some of my favourite games ever, and I have no doubt I'll love this when I pick up on Steam based on what other fans of the series think about the Wii original.
@jrt87, just gotta say, that is one fantastic profile pic you have there.
Another classic of the genre that were it to be remastered today would score 5/10 for being "old and clunky".
@jrt87, that has a tendency to be an issue with remasters, they usually just get them working on the newer hardware and maybe give them some higher res textures. They don't update the controls to a more "modern" control scheme. They will always feel "clunky" because, let's face it, the controls of the time they were released weren't great. For me personally, I take the "controls are old and clunky" line in reviews for remasters with a grain of salt. I would still love to see a remake, remaster, or just a plain old port of Clock Tower 3 and Xenosaga, even with their old and clunky controls.
Meanwhile 9/6/23 happened
I think that PJ shouldn't review Project Zero/Fatal Frame (he rated both remasters 6/10). He doesn't get the slow gameplay and doesn't really appreciate how immersive, beautiful and frightening this series is if you take it slow. Obviously, if he doesn't like it, he'll never like it but there's nothing like it in the video games industry. Try it.
These games are the best written and most coherent horror games I've ever played. The second, Crimson Butterfly, is one of the best games I've ever played, period. There's no cheap gore and they hook you with the story, Japanese mythology, stories, decoration and architecture, the collectibles (files) and the slow gameplay. If you like horror or supernatural things, don't miss it and support this niche series!
For the record, I bought and played this on Wii several times (with the English fan-made patch applied) and I pre-ordered the Xbox remaster.
Jeez, modern reviewers really don't seem to get on with classic survival horror game design.
I don’t care about clunky controls. I’ve always been able to manage and I keep in mind that this is an old game while I’ll be playing it. Sometimes the controls help the tension in horror games. Otherwise it can be a bit too easy and feel less intense. I cannot wait to play this one. I thought I would never get to play it. This franchise is one of my favorites and the fact it’s finally coming to the west is such a thrill. I wasn’t expecting it to get a great score. The series isn’t for everybody, but for me, this is my CoD or GTA.
I played the last remaster and I had fun, the backtracking was annoying but I pushed through.
Cant wait to play this.
If a game is designed to work well with certain controls, no such thing as aged or clunky.
Tap here to load 10 comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...